Do you think Alisha is a good judge? - Page 3

Originally posted by: S a r a h

Oh so you are a Suhit supporter😆 theres nothing bad in it tho but when public with ZERO knowledge of music also can judge then why doesnt a celeb from the same field😆 undersanding music correctly is certainly not restricted to trained singers or musicians😳

haha here is a member with 0 knowledge. Please read all my posts you are making comments and have no idea who im supporting

Originally posted by: *Ajju*

you got it wrong buddy .Even she praises Richa with Gem and little star words and Richa is one of my fav bcoz of her voice ....Farah khan was any day better than her .Problem with Alisha is she doesn't know how to judge show like Indian Idol and she is not fit for that responsibilty.

About Suhit you want me to write ? He is the worst singer in the lot and thats the reality and I don;t buy his yo yo atitude either ...send any crazy american kid from street and he will do much better yo yo or screaming than suhit

i dont care what you say about suhit, I am looking at this from a neutral perspective and I can clearly see these threads aboiut alisha are only created because of suhit. I have already said I DONT think suhit is a good singer, but you guys dont undersatnd and are giving biased comments because you dont like the guy. If today some how javed saab praised suhit I wouldnt be surprised if there were threads opened against javed saab.

Originally posted by: Jhon1

haha here is a member with 0 knowledge. Please read all my posts you are making comments and have no idea who im supporting

Oh my... master of debates is here😆😆 and with immense technical knowledge😆😆 I shudnt but must let you know that you may have generated 100s of posts after that or before that but I am repying to this particular post eh - comon sense😳

Originally posted by: S a r a h

one thing you all are getting confused with here is

when Anu Malik was there, we didnt notice Alisha but we interpreted her as a nice sweet judge but in Anu Malik's absence her judgement is coming out as the second most important decision... comparatively Alisha is better for example imagine 4 judges in the panel 😆 I want to tell you all that only the situation has been changed that person is same 😆

There is point but I don't think its just because of Anu malik's absense.She is so confused while commenting and she doesn't have words either ...As a audiance I need to know more about singing and I expect Alisha to point out good and bad points about singer.Anu iritates lot and he too goes for looks sometimes but if someone is bad Anu doesn't spare him/her

Originally posted by: S a r a h

Oh my... master of debates is here😆😆 and with immense technical knowledge😆😆 I shudnt but must let you know that you may have generated 100s of posts after that or before that but I am repying to this particular post eh - comon sense😳

Sarah relax. And i never said I have immense technical knowledge. You are just getting upset for nothing!

Originally posted by: Jhon1

i dont care what you say about suhit, I am looking at this from a neutral perspective and I can clearly see these threads aboiut alisha are only created because of suhit. I have already said I DONT think suhit is a good singer, but you guys dont undersatnd and are giving biased comments because you dont like the guy. If today some how javed saab praised suhit I wouldnt be surprised if there were threads opened against javed saab.

If someone is supporting wrong singer what you expect from people here ? If suhit sings well why we will criticise him ? we don;t have problem with Suhit as a person , we think he is not talented compare to other guys and thats the reason this thread.Even Javed Ji praises someone unnecessary ofcourse someone will open thread ...thats what IF is all about😛

Originally posted by: Jhon1

i dont care what you say about suhit, I am looking at this from a neutral perspective and I can clearly see these threads aboiut alisha are only created because of suhit. I have already said I DONT think suhit is a good singer, but you guys dont undersatnd and are giving biased comments because you dont like the guy. If today some how javed saab praised suhit I wouldnt be surprised if there were threads opened against javed saab.

For Javed ji to praise Suhit it will obviously will have to be well deserved.....am sure Javed ji has more music sense then Alisha and will praise Suhit for only his singing not his COOL dude act😃......Alisha really does need to ring Farah and take some tips from her 😛

Originally posted by: *Ajju*

If someone is supporting wrong singer what you expect from people here ? If suhit sings well why we will criticise him ? we don;t have problem with Suhit as a person , we think he is not talented compare to other guys and thats the reason this thread.Even Javed Ji praises someone unnecessary ofcourse someone will open thread ...thats what IF is all about😛

ok fair enough. But you cant start blaming Alisha or even Suhit himself. They dont decide who goes through to the next round.

I have been reading posts here for a while but only started replying now. The reason is , it seems people think that ALisha and suhit have powers over who goes through to the next round. So they are being biased and blaming the wrong people, while it is the janta who keeps voting for him. I also agree with you and have said it many times Suhit does not sing well, all his competitors are better singers than him. If he wants to make through the to the top10 he has to sing 100% better today than he has been.

I think members are trying to say that alisha is unfair in the sense that when others find mistakes in Suhit she doesnt find it..thats why members find it biased..and its even possible coz everyone has different views and they are stating it here.