My analysis of the best and worst.,... - Page 3

My Analysis
[Richa -- She sounds like the ones who sing in railway stations ! Seriously m sorry if I hurt her fans but her voice doesnt sound good to me at all !!
Vartika --Her own voice is good ,but recently she is trying to put in too much of maturity in it that she is spoiling her voice n song
Charu --Good Singer

Ankita --Good Singer

Harshitha-- ok , not all songs suite her voice or in other words she cant sing all songs


Girl who needs to be out "According to me " ---RICHA !

Originally posted by: preethi_p_r

My Analysis
[Richa -- She sounds like the ones who sing in railway stations ! Seriously m sorry if I hurt her fans but her voice doesnt sound good to me at all !!
Vartika --Her own voice is good ,but recently she is trying to put in too much of maturity in it that she is spoiling her voice n song
Charu --Good Singer

Ankita --Good Singer

Harshitha-- ok , not all songs suite her voice or in other words she cant sing all songs


Girl who needs to be out "According to me " ---RICHA !

but 3 girls will be eliminated

yea richa spoiled such a beautiful song😕dont care if she goes

I couldn't stand Richa's singing yesterday. The song is so melodious and sounds so wonderful in Shreya's voice that it was really jarring on the ears hearing Richa sing it.

Originally posted by: srk_lover

no i honestly felt that way....not just cuz judges said it....i like richa...shes one of my favs and i wanna see her in gala's...but i did feel she did it....other contestants must have done it also but i thut hers was most noticable...😕

It is good to improvise but it doesnt mean add harkathe when its not necessary at all . Can u imagine putting harkathe's in songs like Ek nazar me bhi ..........which is a completely masala number, ok do it but what happens is that the feel of the song is lost and it sounds classical which aain spoils the song.

Many clasical singers who come on to playback have the problem, they give a classical touch to a normal masala song which actually ruins the feel of the song. Yesterday too she gave a classical touch to the song in the middle which again spoiled it , her expressions look forced to me , anyway its not as if we are jumping imto the harkathe bandwagon, its so obvious when she sings and any person who has knowledge in music and has been listening to Bollywood numbers can point that out.

Exaclty , Her voice is terrible ,people tend to like her only because she is chubby n cute ,inspite of her bad attitude n Voice ! Time for her to go .Infact when she sings I feel m listening to someone sing andhe ko paise dedo babuji ..

Deepali- She was definitely the BEST in yday's show. She's gonna be there in the top 5.

Harshida- Completely agree with what Javed jee said to her! 😆 I too felt she has come frm Gaoo. Apart from that, her performance was good. Mistakes could have been taken out from her performance as the judges were noticing small ones in Charu's and Smita's performance!!:P She was good. But unsure if she can sing al type of songs.

Charu- She was really cool. But her previous performance was top of the world. This wasn't up to the mark I felt.. but she was really really good! She's one of the gem's of II3:)

Smita- Ohh that was really a hard task to sing this song. But she sang it well. Yeah I believe she got away frm the sur at times but overall she wasn't bad. She is def. gonna come in the top 5 if you look in totality;)

Ankita- Too much depression in her voice.. I felt. But may be due to lots of critic. Ermm.. I felt I would have reacted the same way as she did! :P She didn't have that masti in her song yday but she was good. not bad. But I wonder if she can sing all types of songs? frm the past 3 performances.. She's singing same kinda songs:S... Masti ones.

Vartika- Her performance wasn't upto the mark. May be she'd have to leave this time

Richa- I felt as if she had sung this song😳. Seriously for the first time.. (putting all the egos aside..wich I ave for her😆) I felt.. she was too good. Great!!! the song suited her voice a lot!!

Puja- What to say about her?! She is ROCKING!! Definitely gonna come in the top 5.

Shifa- Arrey! She wasn't too bad yar! She was GREAT!!! Give her a chance to prove herself na!!😳. Her voice is different- not terrible:).

Originally posted by: tina59

My best today are

Deepali : great voice quality, wonderfully sung with full confidence

Harshida : great performer with good throw and well sung too , I mean entertaining

Charu : shaky in the beginning but got better , good throw again

Smita : for her great voice quality and singing ability, no one else would have attempted that song but she did , she lost sur but then again good voice.

Ankita : contrary to what many say abt her overconfidence , I see a genuine performer, she does it naturally and it doesnt look artifical and forced like many others . She sang well in tune and the song suited her well.

Avreage :

Vartika , she could go either way. The only good thing is her voice quality which is good

Richa : much better than last time , but again I just cant see her singing any song, everything sounds childish and today too she gave a classical touch to a song which wasnt necessary.

Puja : well sung but then again her voice is just not there , its sounds kiddish , I cant imagine her singing for any lead actress.

Worst

Shifa : First of all , she sounds kiddish on top of that she didnt sing on tune . Her voice is a big letdown , cant imagine listening to her album or lend playback for any lead actress.

Bottom 4 thinking abt the public would be

Shifa

Vartika

Smita /Richa

Ankita

i agree but i think shifa mite make it 😃