Indian idol 2 was more mature, aggresive - Page 2

Originally posted by: lezz_law

Abhijeet, Amit Sana, Rahul Saxena, Prajakta, Aditi Paul, Karunya, Amey Date, Antara. Is anyone from II-3 even close to any one of these names?? I don't think so. Very disappointing

I do agree with you on that one!

Originally posted by: lezz_law

The first Indian Idol was the best, it had the best singers and the final was between the best two singers.

The level dropped a little in II-2, and moreover not the best singer won the competition.

And with II-3, it seems more like a school singing competition (specifically the girls), only Deepali seems to have good potential amongst girls and Chang and Emon from the boys sound better than others.

Abhijeet, Amit Sana, Rahul Saxena, Prajakta, Aditi Paul, Karunya, Amey Date, Antara. Is anyone from II-3 even close to any one of these names?? I don't think so. Very disappointing

I agree. But I feel that Emon, Chang, Deepali, Smita are really good.

Frankly, when the piano rounds started, I was under the impression that hte singers were MUCH better than last two years. But again, their performances have been mediocre and the audience voting has been very sad !

Originally posted by: lezz_law

The first Indian Idol was the best, it had the best singers and the final was between the best two singers.

The level dropped a little in II-2, and moreover not the best singer won the competition.

And with II-3, it seems more like a school singing competition (specifically the girls), only Deepali seems to have good potential amongst girls and Chang and Emon from the boys sound better than others.

Abhijeet, Amit Sana, Rahul Saxena, Prajakta, Aditi Paul, Karunya, Amey Date, Antara. Is anyone from II-3 even close to any one of these names?? I don't think so. Very disappointing

I agree, they are some of the best.
Whats more disappointing is that we had such high expectations from II3.
Lets see how the galas go.

Originally posted by: madhavi_r108

I agree. But I feel that Emon, Chang, Deepali, Smita are really good.

Frankly, when the piano rounds started, I was under the impression that hte singers were MUCH better than last two years. But again, their performances have been mediocre and the audience voting has been very sad !

Maybe the format of the piano rounds made a difference. I wonder when they get the time to practice (or how much?).They must be shooting everyday, probably for hours. And then the promotional avis etc. 😕