Too much pressure?

Is this daily competition putting too much pressure on these contestants? Tonight's piano round was the worst of all 4. Everyone looked tensed, some fell flat on sur, some forgot lyrics. Altogether with a round with such beautiful songs I expected so much but what we got is, excellent were good, good were bad and bad went to worse. Most of the contestants started flat in the beginning and then caught up soon.

Do you guys think that Sony should have given contestants at least a day to rehearse? We want to hear brilliance not mediocre.

The ones who impressed me tonight are Bhavin👏 and Emon👏. Even though Abhishek was doing good his forgetting lyrics could make a bad impact because judges were stressing on it otherwise he was good. Amit and Padmanav were good. Meiyang, Amit, Rehan and Prashant were OK not that great. Anish and Parleen were bad. Suhit killed the song. One of the worst performances of Indian Idol 3.

I am only seeing and hearing Javed ji's judgement. I have put Alisha and Udit Narayan on mute.

Yeh i agree...short time periods arent good...contestants dont get time to prepare and deliver to the best of their abilities...even in the girls one ONLY Deepali..made me smile...everyone else realli irritated me 😡 .....but i even thinkl its not their fault...u cant be 100/100 given only half a day to prepare urself!!!.....And boys let me not even start!!!

Yeh ,,lol..Alisha repeats same comments fr atleast 11/12 boys, Udit ji keeps saying lekin, gayi, sunayi, acha laga...over and over again...!!!! 😕 😕 😕

Javed ji ke liye standing ovation coz he is able to bear this torture!!!! 😆

alisha and udit are extras they shouldnt even speak up 🤢 🤢 🤢 udits and alishas comment are so horrible, what is wrong with udit ji, the only person i liked was javed ji, who gave opinion and even taught some of the singers how to pronounce etc. i also liked emon, prashant, bhavin and padmanav. abhishek forgot his lyrics, felt bad for him. may be they should be given at least a day. the girls how ever didnt look pleased at all after what sony showed them. its ridiculous for sony to show such remarks of the girl. i didnt like it at all!

Originally posted by: ~srk_abhi_apu~

Javed ji ke liye standing ovation coz he is able to bear this torture!!!! 😆

👏

Originally posted by: raunaq

alisha and udit are extras they shouldnt even speak up 🤢 🤢 🤢 udits and alishas comment are so horrible, what is wrong with udit ji, the only person i liked was javed ji, who gave opinion and even taught some of the singers how to pronounce etc. i also liked emon, prashant, bhavin and padmanav. abhishek forgot his lyrics, felt bad for him. may be they should be given at least a day. the girls how ever didnt look pleased at all after what sony showed them. its ridiculous for sony to show such remarks of the girl. i didnt like it at all!

Read that ousted contestant Roshan who looked like Suneil Shetty said that Alisha is an useless judge. Her comments doesn't make sense. Only if Sony showed that instead of girls badmouthing each other.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Is this daily competition putting too much pressure on these contestants? Tonight's piano round was the worst of all 4. Everyone looked tensed, some fell flat on sur, some forgot lyrics. Altogether with a round with such beautiful songs I expected so much but what we got is, excellent were good, good were bad and bad went to worse. Most of the contestants started flat in the beginning and then caught up soon.

Do you guys think that Sony should have given contestants at least a day to rehearse? We want to hear brilliance not mediocre.

The ones who impressed me tonight are Bhavin👏 and Emon👏. Even though Abhishek was doing good his forgetting lyrics could make a bad impact because judges were stressing on it otherwise he was good. Amit and Padmanav were good. Meiyang, Amit, Rehan and Prashant were OK not that great. Anish and Parleen were bad. Suhit killed the song. One of the worst performances of Indian Idol 3.

I am only seeing and hearing Javed ji's judgement. I have put Alisha and Udit Narayan on mute.

very valid observations...bas Chang ko bacha lo...I want to see him right till the end!!😛

Well, I feel all the contestants are already aware of all the songs that they will be singing in the Piano rounds, provided they stay in after every performance ...

anyways, I really liked Emon, Bhavin, Meiyang and Amit's performance .... some were ok ... Suhit, I don't want to say anything , rehan also was bad .... But, even the last girls round was equally bad ... I mean I felt only Smita, Charu and Aisha (she is out though ) were upto the mark !!!!

Originally posted by: TallyHo

very valid observations...bas Chang ko bacha lo...I want to see him right till the end!!😛

Ashu, Chang is my personal fav. too but one thing I noticed clearly tonight is that he is gong to have trouble with pronuncing some words and in future Javed ji is going to pick on that.

Originally posted by: finfreedom

But, even the last girls round was equally bad ... I mean I felt only Smita, Charu and Aisha (she is out though ) were upto the mark !!!!

I agree that girls were not up to the mark last night but tonight boys were worst. Except Emon and Bhavin all others fell flat on sur in the beginning and some easily picked up (like Chang), some half way(like Shantanu) and some didn't pick the sur at all (Suhit).

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Ashu, Chang is my personal fav. too but one thing I noticed clearly tonight is that he is gong to have trouble with pronuncing some words and in future Javed ji is going to pick on that.

Ya , I know Maya....Hope he can work on his diction...also he sounds a lil nervous...maybe because he isnt a trained singer...He will really have to choose his songs intelligently...he sings with lots of feelings ...and sometimes that is a hit with the audiences...just counting on that to take him further....and Javed sa'aab is pouncing on everyone baari baari so it wont be long before Changu gets his share of firing!😭😉😆