*RATE THE GIRLS/BOYS PERFORMANCES** - Page 7

My ratings for guys :

Emon : 9 (good voice and throw, controlled singing, best of the lot 👏 👏 👏 )

Prashant : 8.5 (very good performance)

Meiyang Chang : 6.5 (felt he didn't capture the mood of the song)

Shantanu : 6 (disappointed cos i had great hopes on this guy, but still one of my favs.,may be it was a wrong song selection)

Parleen : 6(didn't capture the magic of the mood of the song....he sounded much better in the practice session)

Amit : Didn't concentrate properly on his perf. but found him good

Wouldn't even bother rating the others.

Judges : 🤢

My bottom 3 : Suhit 🤢 Abhishek 🤢 and Padmanav (still can't believe these guys got selected over Sreeju-but why did Sony give so much coverage to him?)

meiyang 10/10
emon 10/10
prashant 9.5/10
rehan - suhit 8.5/10

abhishek 8/10
anish 8/10

BOYZ

Shantanu - 5.5

Padmanav - 6.5

Emon - 10

Bhavin - 6.5

Prashant - 9

Rehan - 8

Amit - 7.5

Bharat - 6.5

Suhit - 6

Anish - 7.5

Abhishek - 8

Parleen - 8

Roshan - 6.5

Meiyang - 8

GALZ

Aisha - 8

Rashmi - 5

Shifa - 7.5

Smita - 8

Vanita - 6.5

Deepali - 6.5

Pinky - 6

Vartika - 8

Harshida - 4

Priyanka - 6

Charu - 8

Richa - 7

Puja - 9

Ankita - 7

Originally posted by: hareshlbhatia

Judges are not giving any negative comments to any contestens as its just the beginning. Anu malik is not there. ID3 wants to just tease the people when anu malik comes.. Just a small Jadka. Because when he comes back to his judge kursi... He will surely pass out negative comments,, and india will suddenly get shocked..
Its a very gut marketing strategy from ID3
Please people understand its all marketing strategy what actually is happening behind indian idol 3
I dnt say the show is bad it is excellent..very well organized.. but if u really understand how the team of ID3 is working u will know the reality.
😊 😊
Most of the performances are not upto the mark..to flat singing.--people concentrating on just performance--
Gut was Emon and Meiyang--Others OK..
Please People Jagooo!! please vote fr the right one..

i totally agree with ur observations/ comments abt ID-3-its kind of marketing statergy -at the moment they are just giving goddy goddy comments and once devil anu mallik comes it will be all negative comments and drama!!!!!!!!!

Abhishek Kumar 7/10
Aisha Sayed 8/10

Shantanu.......... 9/10
Padmanav........ 8/10
Emon................ 11/10 I LUV HIM!!!!!!
Bhavin........... 9/10
Prashant........... 10/10 good job he sung so well!
Rehan.............. 7/10 he was good but just wasn't his song
Amit................. 10/10
Bharat...........out
Suhit.............. 1/10 he can;t sing
Anish................ 8/10
Abhishek...........9/10
Parleen.............10/10

Roshan............. out
Meiyang............ 9/10 he's good but i felt that just wasn't his song

smita adhikari 10/10

ankita mishra 9/10

pooja chatterjee 8/10

vartika 10/10 i like she's good

richa aneja 6/10

priyanka

deepali

charu

shifa.........
vanita..........
harshida.........
rashmi.........out
pinky............out 😳 😳