Flawed Characterization and Storyline Is Why We Can't Connect

Syama_Luna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I had posted a reply on a very good topic, "In reply.." by mandu that turned out longer than expected. I have added a few more thought in an edited version of the reply here.
Many of us are frustrated and angry with how the story in EMA is moving and nonsensical ideas are being thrown at us, the characters being portrayed unrealistically and our favourite characters loosing their essence and identity. There are many sources to the destruction of a story with such a potential. The main issues as I see it, are lost of direction in the storyline and flawed characterization.

I was baffled as to how can one even think that Kam..la and Paa...khi are positive characters; a very twisted concept of good they have. I actually fear for the people who think this way. Not only is the portrayal of these two ladies unrealistic, they are extremely unhealthy. They have even taken altruism to the extent of it seeming pathological. In their desire to maintain her so called "goodypants" portrayal and the future plot as it seems, they have made Paa..khi spit meaningless dialogues and produce scenes to support the planned story without letting it grow out of her as a character. Actually, they have been handling every other character similarly.

What I see is that the writers, creatives, and directors just did not FEEL the characters. They just WANT their characters to say and do things that lead to these turning points or twist as you may call it. I doubt that they even have a vision of the storyline in mind. They seem to just be squeezing the storyline in between these so called twists. They don't seem to be thinking from the p.o.v of the characters. "What Raghav would do in this situation?", for instance. They have opted for clich's, dramatization, and standardized and repetitive dialogues and scenes. It is sad that some characters are built and shaped well at the beginning but then lacerated ruthlessly to satisfy ridiculous twist created solely to gain trps. They lost whatever vision they had. Everything; the characterization, story, editing, and acting (certain actors and in certain scenes) are choppy. The plot is supposed to be expressed through solid and dimensional characters, but with looks of the mess of the end product we're getting this past weeks, one can only imagine the process of creation to be the same. Not only Raghav is lost but the team too.

I feel that maybe the creatives didn't have a strong concept of the characters to begin with. Perhaps they bit off more than they can chew. What they show doesn't match the message they expect to get across. Why so obsessed to make Kam..la God when she can't even be a human being much less a good one. First love yourself, and then your family and friends, after that you can love the whole world for all I care. Show circumstances pushing her away from Kalpi (not forced) instead of her so obviously being partial to her to the extent of being angry that she is snatching Paa...khi's happiness. Not only she FORGETS that her daughter is drowning, her explanation for letting Kalpi drown is sick! In many countries, the mother can be charged under criminal negligence. It is funny how they wanted to portray a Godlike character through Kam..la but ended up demonizing her. Paa...khi on the other hand just does and says things that don't even project her character. I don't even know what her personality is. Only we are saying that Paa...khi is innocent or she is not innocent, she is smart, they are showing neither and are just playing it safe. Only thing I see is that she's histrionic just like Kam..la. Someone please explain her personality if it is even existent.

I think they might have wanted to portray the complexity of the relationships and situation but failed miserably? If the writers are unable draw out a solid and convincing characterization of the characters, the directors wouldn't be able to bring it out on screen and the same goes to the actors who will only be portraying caricatures.

It is quite obvious that they are just trying to highlight certain aspects of the characters with exaggerated and out of place dialogues. The team thinks that they can just get their point across with loads and loads of ornate dialogues without the appropriate scenes to support it. Take Kam..la for instance; her behavior is clearly biased to Kalpi, and then she just has to shed some tears and say "How can I choose between my both daughters Deva" and we're supposed to feel sympathy for her? And, what can I say about Paa...khi's character? It's a cheat, simple as that. How convenient that she's unaware of what happens around her, so that makes her innocent. First she didn't know about Ragna, and now even after revenge revelation, she still doesn't know. And, I'm irritated of hearing that Shirin doesn't want to do negative roles. All this should have been taken into consideration earlier itself. Alas, yet another proof of the team not having a clear vision of the storyline. At least show her inner conflict between doing what she wants and what is right. Just let her be a grey character, why portray her as an angel. With Raghav, they have chosen to just highlight all his weakness in this new track. People slip, they don't get lost! You want to show him impulsive and hot headed? Fine, at least let him be smart about his revenge.

Moreover, where is the character development is these characters? Or is it a foreign concept? Perhaps turning weak, evil and even more delusional is the development? If only they had put their effort into shaping crisp and solid characters and scenes, they would have been able to get the desired message across and evoke the desired emotional responses from the audience. But no, they don't even care for the integrity of their craft, much less the fans. They are just making garam masala; add self-sacrificing act, add love triangle, add mockery of marriage, add scandals, add bechari act and suffering (doesn't matter if self-induced). There is no harmony, just chaos. Doesn't matter if it doesn't flow with the story or goes against the characters portrayal, and it sure as hell doesn't matter if there isn't a sliver of logic.

Even the actors are just buying into the crap they are asked to portray. Either they are so sucked into the characters or are afraid to accept or let sink in that they are portraying these horrifying characters and sending negative message to the viewers. The alternative is scary to entertain.

Instead of blaming and ridiculing audience and fans, they should look at their work and analyze why they are unable to elicit the responses they sought. They are just deluding themselves into thinking that fans are angry because they are so blinded by RAGNA when it is they who are blinded. It is astonishing that they haven't realized that it is them that have failed, not the audience.

I apologize for the rant and length and if I irritated y'all with Kamki, 😆 couldn't help it.

Comments please and feel free to rant 😆
btw, does the colours make it easier or harder to read?
Edited by Syama_Luna - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

6.4k

Users

24

Likes

149

Frequent Posters

pads23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
They hv failed an intelligent,discerning audience who understand this medium very well.

THEY THINK THEY R GODS.GODS R NOT FOOLISH LIKE THEM.

Please think...Why r we jittery and on the edge after every episode?
Because,we can't trust the characters,,We cannot foresee what they will say or do.
Do u think any one who loves Kalpi as much as raghav does will ever look at anyone else ,leave alone hv SR with her? But with Raghav,u can't be sure.Such is the characterisation in EMA,very shallow...and adhoc...with no essence..
Their sole aim is keep audience glued on an "adhoc "basis with TRP gimmics rather than providing them with a good story line and characterisation.
Same dialogues and similar scenes...i think we r expecting a lot from them...they do not hv it...
A newcomer,who is not even a good actor, can dictate terms and say that she does'nt want to be grey or a negative character...shows that the production house is weak...cannot hold their own...and r willing to sink...good for them...

lurve_life thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Syama you have explained it so well. Yes they have not thought it through. I think they had a story idea, which btw they copied from a Urdu novel called, Thora sa Aasman. They based all the characters on that but lost the plot in between. Coz its a daily soap and because they have not thought it through, we get to see so many blunders. I am so so disappointed wiith the current track. They had a diamond in their hand and they have turned it into coal. How I wish CVs could have borrowed our brains. These guys are not smart, they are just playing with audience's psychology and it does not matter to them that they are being reflected in bad light.
For me, my work speaks for myself and thus I take care with what I present.

Once again, a brillaint post.👏 I wish someone posts the link on twitter to MG.
_TheBlackRose_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
They don't connect to or understand the characters the way we do...
and at the same time we don't see it the way they do
They are the ones who know more about how their story will shape up... but the dragging of these tracks and making the storyline illogical is not something that can be forgiven...
They make the characters act according to their needs, n forget about how the characters have yet been shaped up... We as the viewers can see the difference, but they blindfold themselves to it so that the story can progress according to their ideas...
But our acceptance depends on what these ideas are
They should make the story in a way by which we can relate to it n it doesn't feel like what-the-hell-is-happening...
foram. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
your rant made a sense great post and agree with you
angelpureness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
All this nonsense began after the leap... when Kamla's character got side lined and the focus was Ragna:Career & Revenge... had they focused on the track they had promised there would have been very little scope for Kamla as would have become a secondary character as she was no longer needed for the story to continue. Pakhi's character is to Kamla like Robin is to Batman... she is being given prominence just so that the focus can shift back to Kamla.
Sad that cvs felt they had to bow down to some yesteryear star and ruin a good story!
Syama_Luna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: pads23

They hv failed an intelligent,discerning audience who understand this medium very well.


THEY THINK THEY R GODS.GODS R NOT FOOLISH LIKE THEM.

Please think...Why r we jittery and on the edge after every episode?
Because,we can't trust the characters,,We cannot foresee what they will say or do.
Do u think any one who loves Kalpi as much as raghav does will ever look at anyone else ,leave alone hv SR with her? But with Raghav,u can't be sure.Such is the characterisation in EMA,very shallow...and adhoc...with no essence..
Their sole aim is keep audience glued on an "adhoc "basis with TRP gimmics rather than providing them with a good story line and characterisation.
Same dialogues and similar scenes...i think we r expecting a lot from them...they do not hv it...
A newcomer,who is not even a good actor, can dictate terms and say that she does'nt want to be grey or a negative character...shows that the production house is weak...cannot hold their own...and r willing to sink...good for them...

Yes, they are lost themselves and they behave as if we are stupid. There has been no proper planning to move the story with continuity, consistency, and logic. Looks like they sit and plan how to shock and unsettle the audience and trick them into watching.
Yea, from a logical reasoning, Raghav will never fall for anyone else but we can't be sure it will not happen because the writers are so outrageous with their senseless ideas.
Yea, I'm surprised a newcomer has so much weight. However, it is their responsibility to ensure they choose actors that can perform as the plot demands. If they have planned a threesome (Kalpi-Kam..la-Pa..khi) and love triangle earlier as it seems, is it so difficult to anticipate that you cant continue the conflict as they have without making the character negative or at least grey? No! They decided that she lives under a rock instead.
Edited by Syama_Luna - 11 years ago
Syama_Luna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: artisaggi

Syama you have explained it so well. Yes they have not thought it through. I think they had a story idea, which btw they copied from a Urdu novel called, Thora sa Aasman. They based all the characters on that but lost the plot in between. Coz its a daily soap and because they have not thought it through, we get to see so many blunders. I am so so disappointed wiith the current track. They had a diamond in their hand and they have turned it into coal. How I wish CVs could have borrowed our brains. These guys are not smart, they are just playing with audience's psychology and it does not matter to them that they are being reflected in bad light.

For me, my work speaks for myself and thus I take care with what I present.

Once again, a brillaint post.👏 I wish someone posts the link on twitter to MG.

I've hear that EMA was inspired by an English movie, Tamil novel and now Urdu novel. 😆 I understand that it is a daily soap and it is understandable to have certain bloopers and errors but what they have done is too much. They should have had an idea of the storyline; the events, how the characters might react and the outcomes. Instead of playing with audience psychology in relation to their precious Trp, they should study the psychology of their characters and find more effective and creative ways to project that on screen. They should understand the psych of the audience in this era, where people can actually reason 😲
Thank you or your appreciation. :)
Edited by Syama_Luna - 11 years ago
Syama_Luna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: UB2500

They don't connect to or understand the characters the way we do...

and at the same time we don't see it the way they do
They are the ones who know more about how their story will shape up... but the dragging of these tracks and making the storyline illogical is not something that can be forgiven...
They make the characters act according to their needs, n forget about how the characters have yet been shaped up... We as the viewers can see the difference, but they blindfold themselves to it so that the story can progress according to their ideas...
But our acceptance depends on what these ideas are
They should make the story in a way by which we can relate to it n it doesn't feel like what-the-hell-is-happening...

I so try to see it the way they do, but they are really lost yaar. In the beginning of the serial, at least you can say circumstances forces Kamla. Then they had to bring in the drowning scene that for me blatantly shows where Kalpi and Paa..khi stands in her heart. There is no way you can justify an impulsive reaction like that. After the leap, one minute it's circumstances, next it's Kamla's own biasness. Then during the first engagement, she hysterically screams that she meant Paa..khi as her daughter. She doesn't give a dam about Kalpi's feelings. So, it should imply negativity in her character. But no, I hear that Kamla as a character is spreading positivity. I can understand Raghavs character to an extent, but why they choose to only show one dimension of his character?? Now that you have shown his weakness, show his strengths also through his revenge. Show him scheming, trying to trap his enemies not trap himself. They have no clarity of ideas, instead just snip, paste and tear according to their whims.
Punjabdikuri thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
This is one of the best analysis I have read. This is one of the reasons why almost all the serials die after 150-200 episodes. All the serials spend first 40-50 episodes developing the characters. Then add the love/ hate track. Then for next 100 episodes we see
The relationship blooming and after that there is THE TWIST around 180th episode. After that everything changes the characters the plot and most important no direction. The writers directors editors actors heck even the spot boys start acting clueless.
My only question is what is the purpose of twist if it cannot be executed properly.?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".