If singing was the basic criteria.....

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Xplicit_Desii

@Xplicit_Desii

Stunner

Posted: 18 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: tpam

i agreee

i agree.. i wuz wonderin dat too..they didnt even singg.. they only sang like two linezz.. i think suhit is judges fav lol😆

Quote

buttercup

@buttercup

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 18 years ago

#12

suhit and charu got selected coz singing is the basic criteria..they judged them from the lines they sung.

if they had gone for personality etc..etc..suhit wudnt be there after abusing 😆

even richa wudnt be selected..if they looked for other stuff.. but richa also made it coz its singing only matters

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sumesh

@sumesh

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#13

actually they were singing like 2 minutes atleast & we r seeing just their fault lines only & thinking they didnt do well...maximum 30 seconds we r seeing only...

Abhishek really messed up that song that time but judges said it wasnt bad performance... 😕

even in Suhit charu if u have noticed there singing shown here & there not in order & they just edited & showed their fault place & dance part only....

do u really think if this performance was for 20-30 seconds anyone will forget lines? 😕

But that fainted guy just sing 4 lines only & stopped it & I think becoz of javed only he is selected though they think it was kinda faint drama...I think Alisha & Anu preferred some other guy instead of him !!

Emon Shifa was one of the couple who chose to 46 with all 4 judges support !!!

Edited by sumesh - 18 years ago

Quote

DON't-ASK-IT

@Sara_DONT_ASK

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 18 years ago

#14

I dont think the judges noe wht happened outside after suhit n charu's performance....??? 😕

Maybe afterwards they noe....but not at the moment when they were making decisions..!!!

For a second i was alsho not confortable with the decision but then wht can be done now...!!!

Lets see how dey perform today...!!! And maybe while making the decision....past performances are also kept in mind...???

And tht rythmic harqat of richa was totally unwanetd...not at all required in a song like tht..!!! But if u see her past performances she is a good singer maybe thts why was chsoen...!!

Quote

tina

@tina59

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

#15

Yeah but that could be the case for the rejected contestants as well. Maybe they would have sung as well and the 20-30 secs that were shown didnt do justice to them as well . I mean the fact is they messed up, Anu said that they would be given just one chance and thats the format yet they are still selected when they messed up , but the others were rejected for the same reason. Thats why I feel its unfair.