Entity of Ambiguity, Ms Pia

In a bid to understand her status.

Who is this Pia from the Walia Family?😕

The writers want to create an atmosphere of ambiguity surrounding Pia.😲

I have often questioned myself , post-leap what is Pia still doing in Walia Mansion? (dismissing logistic reasons i.e. the creatives couldn't afford to built another set cause that would make three)😡

1) she has joint custody of Aarthava and Krishna because she got Bani to sign a piece of paper giving her custody of her children. Pia in turn offered JW joint custody in return for shelter under the roof of Walia Mansion.

2) In these five years, JW was unable to get rid of the person responsible for his wife's prosecution, untimely death, his rape, namely his enemy

3) I expected more out of JW. A man who would have gotten rid of Pia through some unscrupulous means,if the hatred is so strong? Yet he did nothing, so it would seem. And Pia is still residing in WM. Enjoying all the material benefits that life could bring. Monetary purse is limitless ( she never repeats her designer sarees) . Whilst everyone else's life is wallowed in guilt and unhappiness.

4) She is mother to a child Veer, whose father is JW (let's just stick to the disclosed facts at the moment and not move into assumptions regarding the parentage)

5) She doesn't share a life with JW, other than living under the same roof.

6) Devoid of sindoor and mangalsutra

7) Addresses herself as Pia , Pia from the Walia family.

8) She professes to love Mr Jai Walia and can't bear to see him suffer

Is this a charade put up by Pia in front of society. An implication that leads to an assumption on the part of society. She does nothing to correct that assumption? Why spoil a good thing that works in your favour for your benefit.

Or

Is she really Mrs Pia Jai Walia?

1) Diya introduces her as Pia Walia. Jai Walia's wife. Did Diya make an assumption that Pia was JW's wife or did Pia tell her so?

2) AD addresses her as Jai Walia's better half and she acknowledges that. Is she really his better half? Though emotionally certainly not JW's better half, but in physical reality?

Could Mr Jai Walia have married Pia on paper ? Legal wife? In name only ? No other honour was bestowed upon her thus the scenes showing Bani's footsteps in red stepping into Walia Mansion. Bani is the complete Walia Bahu.

Jai Walia upon seeing Durga refers to her as Bani and his love but not by word wife. Why?

In Rano's confrontation scene with Pia, Rano accused Pia of husband snatching. Pia in return states that there is no difference in their status. Rano the second wife of Ranveer, does that make Pia the second wife of JW?

When JW is imprisoned , Pia demands to know why she was not informed and had the gall to tell Ranveer to shut up. By what authority? That she is Mrs Jai Walia?

When JW is hospitalized she goes with Rano, Ranveer , Aditya and Dadi to the hospital but not Jigs and Karuna? Is it because she is Mrs Jai Walia?

If indeed she is married legally to Jai, what were the reasons that compelled him to marry his perpetrator? To protect Veer from the bad influence of his mother?

If in the future, Bani does understand the reasons behind JW's behaviour and action, Will JW ever tell her that he is married to Pia as well? Will Bani be able to accept this marriage? Will it become another hidden truth from her?

From what the creatives are showing, we have two possibilities before us, either JW married her or just has a fettish for rearing enemies in his own backyard. Should we be surprised if he did? The clues are there for us to infer and use our imagination. As far as the creatives are concerned they are leaving an open story line for the future, could go either way.

Thank you for reading my 2 cents.

Yeah...Agree...It's all just 😕 at the moment...

Oval, I love your logic and all the points stated…But I do feel that Jai and Pia are not marriage…Pia was never shown to be married to JW…even the implication was not shown until the last episode…

Creatives will never mess up with JB – Jai cannot marry Pia – as simple as that. Creatives do realise that marrying Pia to Jai is the biggest risk they can take for KS. Besides, if they really wanted JP marriage to happen, it could have happened pre-leap…But it's because creatives did not want JP marriage, that they brought in the custody issue…Otherwise custody things have no importance in KS…Pia should remain in WM for the hangama but she cant be JW's wife as they will lose audience, hence an alternative – custody papers.

Dia is just another Pia, illusioned person…so she might have assumed that Pia is Mrs. Walia and AD could have purposely asked if Pia is JW's better half to spike Bani…This sudden reference to Mrs. Pia JW and JW's better half is to create way for DDG…That's all.

My 2 cents.😛

Ovaltine,

do not think that jai is married to pia. the only reason he agreed to marry her was to save bani's life and when bani was declared dead there was no reason to marry her. when everyone comes to know that bani is there, rano says we will get her back home if jw was married to pia there would have been some scene to show that this could be a confrontation abt this.
pia is a master in playing things to her advantage as already shown. she introduces herself as pia from the walia family. knowing her obsession to be mrs. vollya, if she was married she would not even use her name pia but i think settle for mrs. jai walia only. so when she meets diya she just says that she is frm the walis family and soon after that she loves jw a lot. any person in normal world would presume them to be married and pia being the character would never correct it and play along for her so called social status.

Originally posted by: Je_aime

Dia is just another Pia, illusioned person…so she might have assumed that Pia is Mrs. Walia and AD could have purposely asked if Pia is JW's better half to spike Bani…This sudden reference to Mrs. Pia JW and JW's better half is to create way for DDG…That's all.

My 2 cents.😛

Hi Meena,

AD could have refered to Pia as Mrs. Jai Walia, because he liek Bani may not be aware of the complete truth that Pia and Jai's marriage did not take place at all.

And we do have Pia not correcting anyone that she is not married to Jai at all, this could be because she has seen Durga's pic and thinks shes her sister Bani and thus lets the Mrs.Walia stick, without correcting it.

Love

Krishna

Oval darling,

Wonderful post dear👏 and you really got all that the creatives have been trying to show us till now down perfectly.😃

Yes there is a lot of Ambiguity surrounding the status of Pia, thats for sure.

She has got all that importance just living under Jai's roof, I don't think so too, maybe after Bani's death there was nothing to stop Jai from saying No to Pia and to save his child Veer , he does marry her , a marriage on paper and not of the heart at all.

Anything is possible to tell you the truth or it could be Pia telling all those lies as thast what she wants to be, so usese her status of being living in WM as Mrs. Walia when out.

As for AD calling her Mrs. Walia could be like Bani, he too does not know the truth that Pia may not be marrried to Jia at all and that what he was told by Dia.

Lets see what Ekta and her team have in store for us. Lets see when they reveal the truth behind Pia's statues, she married or not.

Love

Krishna

Originally posted by: kubare

Hi Meena,

AD could have refered to Pia as Mrs. Jai Walia, because he liek Bani may not be aware of the complete truth that Pia and Jai's marriage did not take place at all.

And we do have Pia not correcting anyone that she is not married to Jai at all, this could be because she has seen Durga's pic and thinks shes her sister Bani and thus lets the Mrs.Walia stick, without correcting it.

Love

Krishna

But Krishna, from AD's dialogues, it seems like he does know that JW was made helpless. Like he said here Bani is burning in her anger for JW and JW is burning himself is his love for Bani…I think AD does know the truth probably not that Pia blackmailed or something but he definitely knows more than what Bani knows.😕

Yap, dear, Pia not correcting due to her suspicion about Bani is very plausible. But I think Pia was just being herself, illusioned cos Dia also addressed Pia as Mrs. JW – Probably Pia did not hatch any plans at that particular moment and was just being herself.😉😆😆

Either way, Pia is not married to Jai…😃

Personally I too don't want them to be married but was just thinking in retrospect. Judging from the scenes and dialogues they have shown, it just got me thinking. Never know what is up with the creatives. Its just that now it won't be a surprise either way.

Originally posted by: Je_aime

But Krishna, from AD's dialogues, it seems like he does know that JW was made helpless. Like he said here Bani is burning in her anger for JW and JW is burning himself is his love for Bani…I think AD does know the truth probably not that Pia blackmailed or something but he definitely knows more than what Bani knows.😕

Yap, dear, Pia not correcting due to her suspicion about Bani is very plausible. But I think Pia was just being herself, illusioned cos Dia also addressed Pia as Mrs. JW – Probably Pia did not hatch any plans at that particular moment and was just being herself.😉😆😆

Either way, Pia is not married to Jai…😃

Yes, thats what I think too, Pia being Pia, and not correcting Dia as she heard what she always wanted to be Mrs. Jai Walia.😆

The think the creative are creating lots of problem, by creating ambiguity surrounding Pia, and where the creatives are concerned I donot trust them at all dear, they may just end up serving us a Wh*my.

Love

Krishna

oval great post am sure jai and pia are not married....coz pia wld never give up the opportunity to call herself as mrs.vollaya....and till now she has introduced herself as pia from walia family or pia..as for dia the way pia keeps on harping i luv mr.vollaya to one and all she assumed that pia is married to jai....that woman gives new meaning to delusion....and potrays it even more miserably..in the end audience are 😕 😕

as for AD i agree with meena ,he is instigating bani and doing a good job indeed..