Jodha Akbar - Vachan ya Karuna??? - Page 9

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

Oh Really! If Jodha was so great indeed, would she have been able to make an Akbar out of Shariffuddin had she been married to that Cheapu? She would have been a forgotten thing very soon. Had she married Suryabhaan too, she would have been a nobody. It is only due to Akbar that the world even remembers her.

Don't worry all this will be forgotten once the serial is over.

No one can give credits for Sachin's achievements in cricket to his wife, however supportive she is. Kasturba Gandhi was also a supportive factor in Gandhiji's life. Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi would have become 'Mahatma', would have changed world history with her or without her. Akbar's achievements too are due to his ability and goodness only. He shall always be considered Great as he was a great man himself.

Originally posted by: adianasr

So we are at a point where TE has progressed into Love - and his journey to become Insaan - e - Kaamil' has begun - and we are at a point where Jodha has not even started her journey.

I say this becoz this is the point that I had raised after TE's outburst on 4^th April - when Jodha continued to sing her song of Vachan - and today I once more wonder, what is greater? - a blind need to follow the Vachan aka 'Praan jaaye per vachan na jaaye' - or a need for Karuna in all the decisions that one makes?

If keeping a Vachan is causing pain and wrecking havoc, is keeping that Vachan dharma??? It is said that Vachan and Pratigya are the branches of the Tree called Dharma whose roots are Karuna - then can the tree and its branches survive if the roots get rot - can Vachan be above Karuna? - Can a promise be above compassion? Can anything be above Love?

Originally posted by: fatma201

Unfortunately, there are some people especially young generation who knows nothing about their history who will believe whats portrayed in the show. I think we already have many good examples from this forum.

Originally posted by: shiningways2424

so they should stick to their believe becoz the fact is history cant b changed. And the very fact of controversial name makes me doubt about things which kekta maiiyya is showing. How many people were aware about jodha before release of movie?? I was not, I only saw name of marium zamani in my 7th std as salim's mother n nothing was mentioned regarding her contribution in the making of akbar the great. So ekta maiyya can play with history as much as possible but the fact is in every school children will grow learning that jalal was akbar the great becoz of his deeds n different thinking. He is the only mughal emperor I liked from core of my heart becoz of his refoems in field of child marriage, slavery n sati system. But ekta maiyya is giving these reforms through jodha ,forgetting the fact that her aim was to show relation b/w akbar and his first hindu wife.

Originally posted by: greeshma014

For me it's "karuna" anyday...yeah,it's not rite to break a promise..But think twice before give promise to anyone..In one of the initial episode, jodha says, mein vachan deti hai, jo koi bhi aapke gahne uthare hai, hum uska sar aapke charanon pe arpit karenge..Later when jalal and jodha visited temple, and jalal fulfilled dat promise..agar jalal ne aisa nai kiya, toh jodha woh vachan ka kya karthey..?? promises r not meant to hurt othres..if a person is suffering becoz of ur promise, it's better to break the promise..

Originally posted by: sullii

👏agree...at beginning they showed jalal as a v bad person!! and jodha as devi..

even bfr gettn the tiltle als he was gr8 king and good person!!