Arnt we thinking wrong?

freakandnut57 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Kya Raj sach main bekusoor hai????

Lets think of the whole story and characterize someone else playing Rajveer.....say some ugly fellow!


And then thing of what happened???


See, we are partial to Raj often over Naina......because the character s played by our favourite Rajeev....who goes beyond reasons to all of you.....and you all love him so!

So we never see a fault in him.....

But if we think rationally.....and put ourselves in Naina's shoes????.....Would anyone of us forgive a man, however good and perfect he maybe......if he killed our family!?!

What she said illustrates my point perfectly...that bhaiyya se maut kareeb thi....woh maut chahte the....par maut unse utnihi door thi..woh zinda the......mere bhaiyya.......aur aap kamzor insaan ho!

i think i m making a point!

its difficult to digest but think about it!



Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

991

Users

10

Frequent Posters

friskysam thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
hmnnnnnnn............u do have a gud point

wht rajveer did is a case o;f mercy-killing i think

but rajveer cld have told Naina the truth earlier, i just dont understand y he made a false story first( remember in the earlier spisodes, he told naina tht naveen shot himself)
Souma.N thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I am not against Naina's anger......

I am against her roughness.....i am even ready to forgive her for shooting Raj...but then why kick him after that???? does she not have a heart....i am not even asking her to fall in love for Raj????/

But how can someone be such a stone...and forget all the things that this one person did for you....right from agreeing to sacrificing his career to going to all extents to keep her in the academy inspite of her foolishness.......

I am against Naina's selfishness......her loves her brother beyond anything else fine......but she cannot go about hurting and killing innocent ppl along the way......

When she shot Raj she was in rage...very impulsive...but what after that.....her frustration should have atleast subsided right??? but no she though to hell with the mission...to hell with the triggers ...i have shot my brothers killer (even if he was forced to do so) and i am off......

I agree that no person i Naina's place would forgive Raj....but no one would be this heartless also......when Raj was suffering away in the hospital then she dint even think once abt him...as a human being should she not have thought abt him for once????/
but instead she got involved in finding Abhimanyu.......

They say even when you kill your greatest enemy...and in war whne you kill someone from across the border to save your country...you feel guilty of taking life....and Raj was her well-wisher someone who would sacrifice his own life for her......someone who Naina knows killed her brother only to reduce his suffering.....Naina should remember that even her parents told her that Navin was being tortured a lot.......

Inspite of all this she dint even feel guilty once....

Only in front of BC she was nervous...and that too not becoz she was guilty but becoz she wa safraid that if Raj took her name she would be thrown out.......

Naina is selfish with a 'use and throw' attitude ...thats what i hate abt her...she even uses her friends...she is sweet to Huda only when he is giving her info....she has no sense of patriotism.......

To tell you the truth...i believe that Naina does not deserve to be best cadet......not becoz she shot Raj...not becoz she kicked him...not becoz she made that person cry who has always wanted to see her happy...not becoz..even now..she wants to hurt him at every point.....not becoz...she is least bothered abt him...not becoz she is selfish....but becoz she does not even care for her country..........she wanted to risk the lives of 1 billion ppl for herself........

I am not saying thos coz i love Rajeev as Rajveer but simply becoz Naina is disgusting

pinka28 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: friskysam

hmnnnnnnn............u do have a gud point

wht rajveer did is a case o;f mercy-killing i think

but rajveer cld have told Naina the truth earlier, i just dont understand y he made a false story first( remember in the earlier spisodes, he told naina tht naveen shot himself)

RANJHE ko pata tha ki agar vo use sach batyega to kya hoga vo usk khilaf ho jyei

aur agar RANJHA use vakt use ye baat btata to bhargav pahle naina k jriye RANJHE ko naina se dur kerta aur phir naina ko bhi army correction centre bhej deta

aur naina shayd sahi hai per RANJHE criminal nahin hai nahi usne usk bhai ko jan bhjh ker kuch kiya apne dost ko is halt mein tadpte dekh RAJ kamjor ho gaya aur jo usl*ga use vakt usne vahin kiya

kya naina RAJ ko goli marne k decision ko nahin regret kerti hai.

usi trah RAJ bhi kerta hai per use vakt vo bhi kamjor ho gaya, vaise bhi jise vo khud ka idol manta tha [aur ye baat vo kai baar kah chuka hai ki NAVIN usse se humesha bahtar tha aur vo humesha usek jaisa hona chahta tha perfect ] use is halat mein dekh koi bhi apni concious kho sakta hai

aap jisse se himat ki umid rakhte ho usi ki himat tut jaye to jaise naine ne ki RAJ se sach ki ummid

Edited by pinka_anshu - 18 years ago
friskysam thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Souma.N

I am not against Naina's anger......

I am against her roughness.....i am even ready to forgive her for shooting Raj...but then why kick him after that???? does she not have a heart....i am not even asking her to fall in love for Raj????/

But how can someone be such a stone...and forget all the things that this one person did for you....right from agreeing to sacrificing his career to going to all extents to keep her in the academy inspite of her foolishness.......

I am against Naina's selfishness......her loves her brother beyond anything else fine......but she cannot go about hurting and killing innocent ppl along the way......

When she shot Raj she was in rage...very impulsive...but what after that.....her frustration should have atleast subsided right??? but no she though to hell with the mission...to hell with the triggers ...i have shot my brothers killer (even if he was forced to do so) and i am off......

I agree that no person i Naina's place would forgive Raj....but no one would be this heartless also......when Raj was suffering away in the hospital then she dint even think once abt him...as a human being should she not have thought abt him for once????/
but instead she got involved in finding Abhimanyu.......

They say even when you kill your greatest enemy...and in war whne you kill someone from across the border to save your country...you feel guilty of taking life....and Raj was her well-wisher someone who would sacrifice his own life for her......someone who Naina knows killed her brother only to reduce his suffering.....Naina should remember that even her parents told her that Navin was being tortured a lot.......

Inspite of all this she dint even feel guilty once....

Only in front of BC she was nervous...and that too not becoz she was guilty but becoz she wa safraid that if Raj took her name she would be thrown out.......

Naina is selfish with a 'use and throw' attitude ...thats what i hate abt her...she even uses her friends...she is sweet to Huda only when he is giving her info....she has no sense of patriotism.......

To tell you the truth...i believe that Naina does not deserve to be best cadet......not becoz she shot Raj...not becoz she kicked him...not becoz she made that person cry who has always wanted to see her happy...not becoz..even now..she wants to hurt him at every point.....not becoz...she is least bothered abt him...not becoz she is selfish....but becoz she does not even care for her country..........she wanted to risk the lives of 1 billion ppl for herself........

I am not saying thos coz i love Rajeev as Rajveer but simply becoz Naina is disgusting

very true indeed, i almost forgot tht kicking incident.........very ruthless

And i feel Naina is also very ungrateful especially to Rajveer who hepled her thru thick n thin( the bhargav incident)

anamikaaa thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: friskysam

very true indeed, i almost forgot tht kicking incident.........very ruthless

And i feel Naina is also very ungrateful especially to Rajveer who hepled her thru thick n thin( the bhargav incident)

da point iz naina iz wrong...& if any1 else other thn rajeev wud have been rajveer thn i still wud hav supported raj

anamikaaa thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: friskysam

hmnnnnnnn............u do have a gud point

wht rajveer did is a case o;f mercy-killing i think

but rajveer cld have told Naina the truth earlier, i just dont understand y he made a false story first( remember in the earlier spisodes, he told naina tht naveen shot himself)

but at sum point of time he tells her da truth....rite....

Souma.N thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: friskysam

hmnnnnnnn............u do have a gud point

wht rajveer did is a case o;f mercy-killing i think

but rajveer cld have told Naina the truth earlier, i just dont understand y he made a false story first( remember in the earlier spisodes, he told naina tht naveen shot himself)

We never said that Raj was perfect....he is a human....

Put yourself in Raj's place....you have a mad girl...hunting for her bro's killer....will you go and tell her that you are the one she is looking for ??...or will you wait till she is mature enough to handle the truth and understand the circumstances under which Navin was killed

And if Raj would have told her the truth that day...she would totally give up her training....

If you remember ...Raj made up that story just after Naina's trial and BC giving them the warning that if Naina further investigates then she will be suspended.......

Edited by Souma.N - 18 years ago
friskysam thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Souma.N

We never said that Raj was perfect....he is a human....

Put yourself in Raj's place....you have a mad girl...hunting for her bro's killer....will you go and tell her that you are the one she is looking for ??...or will you wait till she is mature enough to handle the truth and understand the circumstances under which Navin was killed

And if Raj would have told her the truth that day...she would totally give up her training....

If you remember ...Raj made up that story just after Naina's trial and BC giving them the warning that if Naina further investigates then she will be suspended.......

i do agree but i cldnt naveen just shoot himself using rajveer's revolver rather than asking him to do . 😕 cuz Rajveer is still in guilt.

Souma.N thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
ya...Naveen could have shot himself......maybe he dint have the guts.....and shooting himself would mean suicide....and they say a true army officer wants to be shot in his chest....showing that he was not a coward...maybe thats why...

But you know what samreen di...i dont think Raj shot Navin...i have a feeling that someone else from the back shot him when Naveen closed his eyes


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".