English Vinglish vs Dedh Ishqiya: Box Office Comparison - Page 2

Originally posted by: tvdekha.

I don't think that a comparison is needed.

Sri D got the right script at the right time and she made the film top notch by her fantastic acting skills.

I have seen that movie 3-4 times already and can probably watch once again.

I have not seen DI and most likely won't see it anyway. The promo didn't impress me at all and neither did the songs, hamari attariya somewhat did.

Originally posted by: Riya.S.007

omg is that Rohan from rishta.com?

Originally posted by: DB_reloaded

English Vinglish vs Dedh Ishqiya: Box Office Comparison

• Posted in : Bollywood,Box Office
• |
• February 1st, 2014.

• 0

Ever since Dedh Ishqiya released in theatres, we have received a lot of requests from readers for a comparison between Madhuri Dixit's latest release and Sridevi's English Vinglish which released in 2012 - both films received critical acclaim, but the latter was way more successful at the box office.

English Vinglish was more commercial and clashed with a small film like Vivek Oberoi's Kismet Love Paisa Dilli. Dedh Ishqiya on the other hand was a sequel to a fairly successful Ishqiya, but released with a youth-centric multiplex film like Yaariyan - which was promoted very well.

Sridevi in English Vinglish - Madhuri Dixit in Dedh Ishqiya

However, the fact that English Vinglish held up much better on Monday with a drop of less than 10% from Friday, helped the film go on to be a HIT' at the box office. Dedh Ishqiya took a slow start, but couldn't sustain well enough on Monday (drop was 35% from Friday). Also, English Vinglish almost doubled its collections after its first week.

In the overseas markets, Dedh Ishqiya has collected around 5-6 crore, while English Vinglish was a huge blockbuster with business of $4.7 million (Rs 24.5 crore).

• Cost: English Vinglish - 25 crore, Dedh Ishqiya - 35 crore
• Release: English Vinglish - 700 screens, Dedh Ishqiya - 1200 to 1250 screens
• India distributors share: English Vinglish- 18.4 crore, Dedh Ishqiya - 13.2 (could touch 14)
• Runtime: English Vinglish - 135 minutes, Dedh Ishqiya - 152 minutes.
• Verdict: English Vinglish - Hit, Dedh Ishqiya - Flop
• English Vinglish: More commercial and feel-good factor, released with a smaller film, critical acclaim, medium-budget
• Dedh Ishqiya: Released with Yaariyaan which affected multiplex business, was critically acclaimed but limited commercial appeal, costs were high considering the star-cast.

Vote for the film that you think is better and also check out the detailed box office collections of the two films.

Which comeback film did you like more?

• Dedh Ishqiya
• English Vinglish

View Results

	English Vinglish	Dedh Ishqiya
Day 1	2.35	2.86
Day 2	4.67	3.79
Day 3	5.82	5.02
Day 4	2.13	1.86
Day 5	1.85	2.74 (holiday)
Day 6	1.6	1.72
Day 7	1.4	1.45
First Week	19.82 crore	19.44 crore
Remaining Weeks	19.6	7.86 (expected to touch 8.5)
Total India Collections	39.42 crore	27.3 crore (3 weeks)
Overseas	24.5 crore	5 - 6 crore