i don't blame pia i blame bani for this

Everyone including jai and rano told bani not to believe pia but no this madam had to play mahan and she gave a very big lecture to jai about her stupid parents and her stupid promise.

pia did what she always does and bani like a stupid fell into her trap, I think pia is the only one who understands her sisters very well. she knows very well how stupid bani is when it comes to banigiri and jasoosgiri and used that as a weapon against bani.

I don't understand one thing why bani always does banigiri for walia people and not dixit. If she had done little jasoos about pia then she would not be in this position. This proves that she doesnot even know her sister.

I completly blame bani for her condition now and also blame her for putting jai in this condition. If she had listened to rano or jai Instead of using her good for nothing brain then she would not have to face all this.

Even now she believes what pia tells her about jai, she doesnot even uses her brain to think what could be the reason jai did this and doesnot even think maybe pia is blackmailing jai.

What do you expect?!!! Can you..or WOULD YOU shun your own daughter/sister no matter what she did?!!! How can u be so heartless...yes..despite what Pia did, she was then in a lapse of a memory loss...which is not a situation to be taken lightly...Of course Bani should have thought a bit, but it was her own daughter for christs sake! she brought the girl up! how can u expect her to turn away?! she is not heartless at all like those other selfish brats! dont blame bani for this...she is too caring for ehr own good...but dont u dare say her action was stupid inbringing her sister/daughter to a safe place! u would not shun youre own like that, dont expect others to do it!

Originally posted by: tiffany93

What do you expect?!!! Can you..or WOULD YOU shun your own daughter/sister no matter what she did?!!! How can u be so heartless...yes..despite what Pia did, she was then in a lapse of a memory loss...which is not a situation to be taken lightly...Of course Bani should have thought a bit, but it was her own daughter for christs sake! she brought the girl up! how can u expect her to turn away?! she is not heartless at all like those other selfish brats! dont blame bani for this...she is too caring for ehr own good...but dont u dare say her action was stupid inbringing her sister/daughter to a safe place! u would not shun youre own like that, dont expect others to do it!

yea you go gurl!!!!

preech on sista preech on!!

Originally posted by: tiffany93

What do you expect?!!! Can you..or WOULD YOU shun your own daughter/sister no matter what she did?!!! How can u be so heartless...yes..despite what Pia did, she was then in a lapse of a memory loss...which is not a situation to be taken lightly...Of course Bani should have thought a bit, but it was her own daughter for christs sake! she brought the girl up! how can u expect her to turn away?! she is not heartless at all like those other selfish brats! dont blame bani for this...she is too caring for ehr own good...but dont u dare say her action was stupid inbringing her sister/daughter to a safe place! u would not shun youre own like that, dont expect others to do it!

I agree that bani is not heartless and loves her sister a lot but how can she trust her blindly.She should first find out whether pia has really forgot everything or she is acting.The way she brought out the ONS no one can trust her.

Originally posted by: tiffany93

What do you expect?!!! Can you..or WOULD YOU shun your own daughter/sister no matter what she did?!!! How can u be so heartless...yes..despite what Pia did, she was then in a lapse of a memory loss...which is not a situation to be taken lightly...Of course Bani should have thought a bit, but it was her own daughter for christs sake! she brought the girl up! how can u expect her to turn away?! she is not heartless at all like those other selfish brats! dont blame bani for this...she is too caring for ehr own good...but dont u dare say her action was stupid inbringing her sister/daughter to a safe place! u would not shun youre own like that, dont expect others to do it!

Totally agree with you! At least this once, I don't want the blame to be put on Bani. If people don't think JW is at fault then it's okay, I don't care but don't put the blame on Bani who is suffering so much (having her kids taken away, being sent to a mental asylum, being betrayed by her sister, losing her trust in her love) How many times does she have to take the test?

-Pari

Originally posted by: tiffany93

What do you expect?!!! Can you..or WOULD YOU shun your own daughter/sister no matter what she did?!!! How can u be so heartless...yes..despite what Pia did, she was then in a lapse of a memory loss...which is not a situation to be taken lightly...Of course Bani should have thought a bit, but it was her own daughter for christs sake! she brought the girl up! how can u expect her to turn away?! she is not heartless at all like those other selfish brats! dont blame bani for this...she is too caring for ehr own good...but dont u dare say her action was stupid inbringing her sister/daughter to a safe place! u would not shun youre own like that, dont expect others to do it!

i agree!! i cannot do that to my own!
That too, we must also look at the background of Bani's character... She has alwasy had a soft spot for Pia...even after the whole ONS fiasco, because Bani understood pia is a selfish greedy little brat!!!
When Pia came to their rescue during teh car bombing, how would Bani then go on the believe Pia would once again use sucha foul mean to try to get JW again? Nahin na? How would you yourself know? Money or No MOney, Power adn Position or not....You simply would not know!

So i agree with Tiff(if i may call you that!) yes bani could have been more careful, but she was only being humane, nurturing bani!

I agree taht to some extent bani is responsible. Right from the beginning pia has done what she had to do and bani has always covered for her and never reprimanded and the result is visible today. As they say spare the rod and spoil the child and pia is a perfecr example.
when she came to know that bani is paying for her treatment she probably realised the soft spot that bani had and she jumped on the chance.

hey i ahvea new point...peple are complaining right, that Pia had nobody bla bla bla...BUT wasnt bani there for her all the time! silently by her side!!!! pia had someone...pia had someone who cared for her a lot!!!


but, who does bani have now??? NO ONE!!! all of those gfn people deserted her !!!! So, jsut incase...before anyone even tried to defend pia by saying she had no one...it's a lie from there...it was bani who was always left alone and subjected to everyone's cruelty!!

After ONS the way pIA tried to destroy Bani's happiness Bnai shouldn't have trusted Pia. The kasam for which Bnai supported Pia was a binding to Pia also. Pia didn't treat Bani like a mother.

Bnai knows how far Pia can go to get what she wants. If not for her then for her husband she shouldn't have accepted Pia.

Just like being a daughter she has duty as a wife too. Letting ur husn=bands rapist is a biggest mistake.

Even though I won't hold anyon eother than Pia responsible for BAni's condition I hope bani has learnt her lesson.

Originally posted by: suwas

After ONS the way pIA tried to destroy Bani's happiness Bnai shouldn't have trusted Pia. The kasam for which Bnai supported Pia was a binding to Pia also. Pia didn't treat Bani like a mother.

Bnai knows how far Pia can go to get what she wants. If not for her then for her husband she shouldn't have accepted Pia.

Just like being a daughter she has duty as a wife too. Letting ur husn=bands rapist is a biggest mistake.

Even though I won't hold anyon eother than Pia responsible for BAni's condition I hope bani has learnt her lesson.

hahahahaaa!!! point taken! hehehehee

that's true--you really wouldnt want your husbands rapist in the house! lolzz...never thought of it like that! hehehe!!!