What was that ???? Is chanakya really dead ???? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

4.3k

Users

9

Likes

141

Frequent Posters

luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: EtherealRati

you are indirectly saying that something like this happened in history and chanakya did miraculously escaped. It reminds of that dialogue...jab god ki marzi ho toh cheezo mein logic nahi magic hota hain.


No nothing such happened...Alexander aur Chankya Kabhi Nahin mile...😆 Chankya beas ke USS paar tha
luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#32
Chankya outlived Alexander porus and Chandragupta Maurya so why people are believing that he is dead...can Tiwari really shock everyone 🤬 this Tiwari guy has distorted every bit of history so can he do this also
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: luckySnow


No nothing such happened...Alexander aur Chankya Kabhi Nahin mile...😆 Chankya beas ke USS paar tha

nahi ...i was asking about his miraculous disappearance in any historical event. Not about chankya and alexander.
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: inlieu

About today's ☢️

I am 😡 with the CVs for destroying Alexander's character graph, and 😕 for Rohit for having to act these scenes out and mouth those awful dialogues about torture. I feel for the Taxila awaam who are ruled by Ambhiraj under Alexander and who have to witness such a horrible end to their respected Chanakya.

There may be many reasons and "justifications" within the script for Alexander to do this but I was disgusted by that bull scene. I didn't think they'd show it in such detail. I felt the same way during the scenes of Alexander killing his loved ones, in the illusion sequence.

What the heck have they done to this show's storyline???

(Inspired by Sony Alexander in episode 157):

Badi badi baatein kar rahe the
Thailand, Umergaon, aur actors ki intense training ki kahaaniyaan suna rahe the
Aur kiya kya? Dhoka!
Dhoka kiya fans ke saath!

Sone ki chidya ki history hai yeh sun kar aaye the iss show ke baare mein
Magar yeh nahin jaante the ke yahaan ke scripts to giddhun ke bhi samajh ke baahar niklenge

Fan bana kar newta denge aur paagal bana kar chod denge

Bohot khoob CVs 👏👏👏 Bohot khoob! 👏
Dekhlo Bhaarat waalon, yeh hai SidT ki haqeeqat

Suna tha show ke khaatir 500 crore ka budget rakh rahe hain yeh SidT
Par yahan to show ka fan bana kar dimaag ka dahi banaya jaa raha hai

Khair, qubool hai!
Par kam se kam duniya ki tareekh yeh to maanegi
Ke Rohit ne apne junoon aur lajawaab acting se fans ke dilon par fateh ki
Aur uski shikast hui, to uljha hua story arc ke dikhaane par

Bade fakhr se kehte the SidT, ke bade paymane pe show hai, pehle shows ki tarah nahin
Par yahan to story ka arc befazool tracks ki buniyad par khadi ki gayi hai

Theek hai SidT, aage badho!
Sony Alexander ke fans tumhare saamne nihatte khade hain! 🤗


Okay...this was an amazing read...love how people are so talented on this forum with words...masterpiece...is par toh ek post ban jaani chahiye thi ...yeh post toh highlight hain...⭐️
ananda29 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#35

How come we are not seeing your ex Barsine😆
I guess she may appear again with Alexander or with her new enemy Puru😲
Strange are the happenings and cruelty shown😕
Just wondering
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Surbhi,


How can you be so gullible?😉

But di they showed that dead body...that was shocking... that's why i made the post...i had thought he would run away before he will be placed in that bull...dint thought they will show him survive after he comes out of the bull...because that's technically impossible...

Of course he is not dead. As I had written on the episode 173 thread, I agreed with Inlieu's guess that the mud coating would (in defiance of the laws of physics and of the thermal properties of materials, in this case the human skin, but when have such minor issues😉 bothered our CVs?) protect him from the scorching heat.
I am stilll shocked that they are gonna show that someone can survive after being in the bull which was put on fire...and that too through mud coating...maine suna hain desh ki mud jakhm bhar sakti hain...dekha bhi hain...par jalne se bhi bacha sakti hain...this is the first time, i will see something like that...cv's ka maatrbhoomi love is crossing limits...our maatrbhoomi itself is also fighting alexander and is siding chanakya...😉

This is exactly what has happened. In fact, I had thought that Chanakya might not look dead at all, and might emerge from the bull undamaged. But that was an illogical guess of mine, for in that case, Alexander would simply have killed him by more conventional methods.

So he had to appear to be really dead, and that is what has happened. They clearly do not check to see if he is breathing or not, for they are sure he is dead
Yaar ...this is so unbelievable...alexander inko aise kaise harayega ...yehhh tohhh overequipped hain...kayanat is also protecting them...😆.

He will regain consciousness after a while. The very lucky thing for him is that Alexander is actually going to ship him across to Porus. By god 🤣He will be in Paurav Rashtra, special delivery courtesy Alexander😆, when he comes to himself again.

Neat!!!
Sach meinnn...by goddd 😆
Shyamala Di


Edited by EtherealRati - 7 years ago
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: luckySnow


Arre Chankya ne yoga karke sans rok 😆 ki hai...how hell Chankya can die he is real historical character yaar😛

ya...he can't die...but it would have been better/believable had he done something before he was placed into that metal bull.
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#38
sorry guys...i will not be able to reply to everyone individually.here...because i am really tired ...i wrote a lot today already...so i hope you all won't mind that...thanks everyone for replying to my post..its lovely to read discussions...🤗...the gist of the post is that chanakya will not die...thanks everyone for sharing your opinion.😊
Vaishnavi_ thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Well, if she was really the way you described her courtesy the Alexander Romance and Massimo's book, no wonder she smiled😡. So did Olympias at the end. Monster No.1 and Monster No. 2.


Alexander looked petrified for a moment before he lit the fire - so much so that I thought he was going to have a change of heart and abandon the whole thing - and he never smiled. Small mercies.

However, the whole shebang, with the trio of Alexander, Olympias and Roxanne sitting there as if they were at a theatre performance, to watch a man being roasted to death was horrible and disgusting. 😡😡😡

Yes, Alexander would have been fully justified in killing Chanakya, for after all Chanakya had tried to get him killed by deceit. But there was NO need for this ugly display of sadism.

This said, there was something very odd about the screaming. In fact, I didn't expect Chanakya to scream at all.

A master yogi would have been able to control the reaction of his body to the heat, and so he would not have felt the pain and would not have screamed. However, I have never heard that Chanakya was a great yoga master with such special powers. So it must have been just the mud pack.

As I noted above, Chanakya will now get back to Paurav Rashtra express delivery courtesy Alexander😉😉. But the mystery of the potli of extra mud remains unsolved.

Lastly, Alexander has now given Chanakya the formal title of Sansaar ke sabse bade Aalim. Aristotle, if he had got to know of this, would not have been pleased!😉

Shyamala Aunty


Aunty, is it really possible being baked alive and not feeling the pain? I have never heard of this.. it's interesting but I doubt that there would be someone with such strong meditative capabilities in today's times.
inlieu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#40
Thanks Aunty, glad you liked it! 😳

I felt the same way towards SidT/the CVs yesterday as Sony Alexander did about Chakanya's betrayal and I could find no better way to express myself.

I have been trying to stay calm the past few days but yesterday's episode finally hit the ceiling as far as my level of frustration was concerned. I just really had to offload all that was pent up. Aargh!

It is indeed a testament to how much I love Rohit's work that I'm still around, watching this show. If it were any other show, I would have probably left by now.

One of the reasons I stopped watching Game of Thrones, of which SidT is apparently a big fan, is the gratuitous violence and gore. Though Porus is extremely mild in comparison, I can certainly see some influences. I hate it when that happens. That Chanakya will escape is clear (because we know history), but the fact is, this sequence was uncalled for. Alexander could have punished or killed him off in many other ways, and to me the bull scene was gratuitous.

Sony Alexander's character has been degraded continuously, but the last few episodes have shown an exponentially sharp decline. 😡 😡 😡

Not just the story tracks but all those big announcements about the scale of this show and the attempt to do something different had us intrigued last year. Yet, we are just getting more and more 🤬 as the time passes.

I wish they had wrapped this up last month with a quick battle sequence. Right now, I'm not sure how I can go through this for another 2 months (or whatever is left). The finish line doesn't seem to be in sight just yet. 😕

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Beautiful, child.👏👏👏 It is such a perfect, bitter take off on Alexander's speech in the Paurav Rashtra court. Bravo!!

I am glad and relieved that you feel exactly as I do and exactly as you ought to about that ghastly bull scene. This is what the CVs wanted, that we should be forced to abandon the Alexander we had adopted, admired and cared for so deeply ever since he appeared. I simply cannot get over the sight of him sitting up there, watching the smoke and hearing the screams issuing from that iron monster.

Do see my posts on the earlier pages. One has to block this horror out of one's mind, and there are a couple of odd points left to be cleared up.

Shyamala Aunty

Edited by inlieu - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".