19/5 - Everything has changed

BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Such an amazing episode. So here I am with my thoughts! Couldn't wait to post!
Thank you to all, who requested me & some even PMed me to write daily. Its really heartwarming. I will try my best to pen down some thoughts each day, but I can't guarantee.

So the episode continues with Sher looking on suspiciously, with a bored expression as Shraddha speaks about how she met Virat. And he looks unhappy when she tells him that she found out from her father about Virat's transfer. Boy, he doesn't like her keeping tabs on ViratšŸ˜› And just when its getting bad, she makes it worse by telling Sher that Virat is a truthful, honest man who she has loads of respect for. Girl, he was just suspicious about you guys & you are praising the other guyšŸ˜† And Sher has it! Then begins the EPIC question of the day & as usual, Sher doesn't go straight to the point. He has the habit of intimidating first in a roundabout way with indirect taunts, then he hits the nail on the head. Its very interesting how he paints himself as the bad guy & Virat as the good guy. It answered my question from yesterday when Sher told Shraddha that he can read the expressions of the face he fell in love with. So it wasn't just a comment meant for the moment. He hasn't been oblivious to her pain. He knows what he is doing, but like he mentioned in the funeral - he doesn't know what his fault is. He knows he has done wrong, but he feels that he isn't wrong, because to him, whatever he has done so far has been out of love. His intentions have been noble but his actions have been wrong. And for Sher, that is enough for now.

And the best reply from Shraddha so far to Sher's svyamwar question. Shraddha tells Sher that if I said yes for you, you would think I am lying & if I said no for you, you would feel bad. And now that I have accepted you as my own (as my husband), I do not want to be proven as a liar in front of you & neither do I want to hurt you. This was definitely the second best moment of the episode for me. Her reply made her stand on her life very clear -
1. Even though she did not answer his question directly, she did indirectly. Virat stood nowhere in her reply - she worded her reply in terms of either saying yes to Sher or no to Sher. Not yes to Sher, or yes to Virat. So no matter what, she would pick Sher.
2. She has accepted Sher as her husband & she will not break this bond.
3. Sher's feelings matter. Even though he has done wrong with her, she does not hate him. She did not say it, but somewhere she acknowledges that Sher is not a bad person.
Sher's expressions following this revelation were just amazing. There was shock written all over (remember he said to her when he was drunk that even if she were to start feeling for him, he would think of it as mere pity) & I think to some extent, he understood that she has accepted him. As he looked away from her face, there was some amount of guilt even. It hit him for the first time that she cares for him too & that is also one of the reason she's stayed on. As I said time & time again, Sher is all about reciprocity. So now that Shraddha has accepted him from her heart, he told her very honestly that she is now his wife, no matter how the relation was formed, & that he doesn't like her talking to Virat. There was no assertion of right, or rude remarks/taunts here. He shared his feelings very frankly that he doesn't like it. He closes his eyes to sleep, but the confession by Shraddha is not able to let him sleep. So he looks at her only once she has laid down, so that he can avoid her gaze. Both of them are unable to sleep & they both know it that something has changed between them.

Shraddha wakes up in the morning, scared & tries to search for Sher frantically. Is she scared that he will do something wrong again? And she bumps into BD. Hilarious scene IMO. Even BD can't comprehend what is going in Shraddha's mind beyond the 'i-am-scared look'šŸ˜† This scene reminded me so much of Sher's attitude. She wants Shraddha to keep Sher in the house, but yet she doesn't want Shraddha to influence Sher. Sher wants Shraddha for himself & wants her to do as he says, but yet he wants her to accept him on her own terms willingly. Both mother/son need to figure out what they really want.šŸ˜†

And the funeral scene - the best moment of the day for me. Sher's anger has settled down, & we see a calm, guilty Sher taking part in the rites. Just like a good husband, he woke up early (i don't think he slept though) to go for the rites. Shraddha's father tells Sher that he will have to pay for all the wrong he's done with Sher. And surprisingly, Sher remains calm. He gracefully thanks the master for teaching him that one who does wrong will also have to go through that. So has Sher realised that he is not the only victim in this entire scenario? But the very next moment, he tells the master that he doesn't know what wrong he did. And he walks away with a sad, guilty face that is looking down. I think my heart really went out to Sher for the first time. This guy has been mean to Shraddha but he didn't do it out of the intention of hurting her. It was impulsive & the anger of the moment. He doesn't know how to comprehend this marriage, & he is constantly torn between wife & mother. His feelings have been on the edge, without anyone to anchor it. For him, everything he's been doing is out of love & he has been so influenced by BD's upbringing & environment.. that he doesn't know how to love. How to deal with the honesty that Shraddha brings. So all he does is to avert his gaze & look away.

The last shot of the episode. BRILLIANT symbolism. We see Sher cleansing himself before entering the house, while BD & Shraddha look on. Clearly, he is not just cleansing the physical dirt on his body. The Sher that enters the house in the next episode, will be a new Sher Singh. And the precap seems to be a hint of that. Notice he did not scold Shraddha or suspect her, rather he warned Virat not to speak to Shraddha against her will.

Do share your thoughts!!

P.S Thank you CVs! I am starting to like Shraddha since the past two episodes.

Cheers,
Samridhi
Edited by prc_fan1 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.8k

Users

8

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

CatcherInTheRye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Some how that silent story took a turn,Shraddha said something for the first time to Sher with all the honesty she carries.Her expressions were not that she was scared but she really wanted to share that to Sher what she said.
Don't know but someone said that Sher asking her about swayamwar is kind of lacking trust on Shradha,but no it was not..it was just insecurity which he is having regarding his bade bhaiya towards Shradha.The moment Shradha confesses to him that now he is everything to him..he trusts her or not,she means it.
Agree that some where it was clear guilt on his face,i think that was coz somewhere he was doubting Shradha because he just can't handle it that she was in love with some one else than him. Her reply was so clear and he trusted her,din't doubt her again that as if she would think that he 'll trust all whatever she is saying.He trusted her without anymore queries.
He cares for her but doesn't know how to express that to his life,to his beloved wife.
I don't like Virat peeping in forcibly ,like come on dude she is married and don't want your interfernce.
Then why the hell you are making her life hell😔
šŸ˜†loved that u said "i-am -scared-look"...she really remains the same always, even if Bhanwari talks casually thn too. She was searching share then too.i think it can b like "i-m-confused-look" 🤣
Even she is not sure whats going on in her mindšŸ˜†
But ohk,people were complaining that why she din't mourn for her granny's death, she had dream in the morning ,got scared and woke up. Even then she was not relaxed that it was just a dream. She knows that Bhanwari is not good and an do anything wrong. Don't kow if she thinks even Sher can do nything wrong to her family or not.
Sher had guilt and then without saying a word he went to his bed. I just loved that moment.For me that was precious ,he din't say anything but then too his silence spoke volumes. He loves his madamji badly but as i said he doesn't know how to expres his love.
As you said that he just can't bear it that Sharadha talks about some other guy infront of him and evn he doesn't want her pity to accept him as her husband. But now he declared it directly that she is his wife and he won't bear she talks to Virat in future.
Sher went to the funeral,Masterji gave him gyaan.He understood because he knows it well that they are not good people but confusion lies there that what he did wrong with them??šŸ˜† He has been cheated by his mother and his love,thn how come he has done ny wrong doings with them??
Even i think he is rightšŸ˜† Loving some one is not any crime,she rejected ,he accepted her rejection. Now what else can he došŸ˜†

Precap was amazing : Exactly Sam, he din't say anything to Shradha but straight way told his badke bhaiya that he wont spare him if in near future he finds him near his madamjiā¤ļø

Sam amazing analysis as alwayz..loved itā¤ļø


Edited by BabbaR_SheR - 10 years ago
amrapali_dubey thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Superb analysis... Love ur post...!!!
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: BabbaR_SheR

Some how that silent story took a turn,Shraddha said something for the first time to Sher with all the honesty she carries.Her expressions were not that she was scared but she really wanted to share that to Sher what she said.

Don't know but someone said that Sher asking her about swayamwar is kind of lacking trust on Shradha,but no it was not..it was just insecurity which he is having regarding his bade bhaiya towards Shradha.The moment Shradha confesses to him that now he is everything to him..he trusts her or not,she means it.
Agree that some where it was clear guilt on his face,i think that was coz somewhere he was doubting Shradha because he just can't handle it that she was in love with some one else than him. Her reply was so clear and he trusted her,din't doubt her again that as if she would think that he 'll trust all whatever she is saying.He trusted her without anymore queries.
He cares for her but doesn't know how to express that to his life,to his beloved wife.
I don't like Virat peeping in forcibly ,like come on dude she is married and don't want your interfernce.
Then why the hell you are making her life hell😔
šŸ˜†loved that u said "i-am -scared-look"...she really remains the same always, even if Bhanwari talks casually thn too. She was searching share then too.i think it can b like "i-m-confused-look" 🤣
Even she is not sure whats going on in her mindšŸ˜†
But ohk,people were complaining that why she din't mourn for her granny's death, she had dream in the morning ,got scared and woke up. Even then she was not relaxed that it was just a dream. She knows that Bhanwari is not good and an do anything wrong. Don't kow if she thinks even Sher can do nything wrong to her family or not.
Sher had guilt and then without saying a word he went to his bed. I just loved that moment.For me that was precious ,he din't say anything but then too his silence spoke volumes. He loves his madamji badly but as i said he doesn't know how to expres his love.
As you said that he just can't bear it that Sharadha talks about some other guy infront of him and evn he doesn't want her pity to accept him as her husband. But now he declared it directly that she is his wife and he won't bear she talks to Virat in future.
Sher went to the funeral,Masterji gave him gyaan.He understood because he knows it well that they are not good people but confusion lies there that what he did wrong with them??šŸ˜† He has been cheated by his mother and his love,thn how come he has done ny wrong doings with them??
Even i think he is rightšŸ˜† Loving some one is not any crime,she rejected ,he accepted her rejection. Now what else can he došŸ˜†

Precap was amazing : Exactly Sam, he din't say anything to Shradha but straight way told his badke bhaiya that he wont spare him if in near future he finds him near his madamjiā¤ļø

Sam amazing analysis as alwayz..loved itā¤ļø



What is your name? Hilarious username btwšŸ˜†
@bold : WORD. It wasn't about trust but rather his insecurity. He's scared that someone like her who's precious to him will slip away, especially because of the circumstances in which they've gotten married & also his bad behavior to her (which he himself acknowledged). He's definitely going to be more careful towards her from now on & try not to hurt her feelings, unless he is angry. You know I think its not expressing his love that he doesn't know. He does. He made it very clear in his first meeting with her that he's interested in her. Second meeting he placed marriage proposal. And third meeting he confessed his love by letting her go. I think its how to love meaning how to take care of someone. He's realised that mere words of 'I love you' are not enough because if they were, Shraddha would never have rejected him. He needs to win her over, & that's what he doesn't know how to do. He's been used to tough love all this while..so he doesn't quite know how to be tender, which is why her confession left him speechless. It hit him right in his heart, & it was so deep that he didn't know what to do to make it up to her, or what words to say that would show his love. His silence definitely spoke volumes & Shraddha felt it too.

And thank you for penning down your thoughts! You write beautifully too😊
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: amrapali_dubey

Superb analysis... Love ur post...!!!


Thank you😊
CatcherInTheRye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: prc_fan1


What is your name? Hilarious username btwšŸ˜†
@bold : WORD. It wasn't about trust but rather his insecurity. He's scared that someone like her who's precious to him will slip away, especially because of the circumstances in which they've gotten married & also his bad behavior to her (which he himself acknowledged). He's definitely going to be more careful towards her from now on & try not to hurt her feelings, unless he is angry. You know I think its not expressing his love that he doesn't know. He does. He made it very clear in his first meeting with her that he's interested in her. Second meeting he placed marriage proposal. And third meeting he confessed his love by letting her go. I think its how to love meaning how to take care of someone. He's realised that mere words of 'I love you' are not enough because if they were, Shraddha would never have rejected him. He needs to win her over, & that's what he doesn't know how to do. He's been used to tough love all this while..so he doesn't quite know how to be tender, which is why her confession left him speechless. It hit him right in his heart, & it was so deep that he didn't know what to do to make it up to her, or what words to say that would show his love. His silence definitely spoke volumes & Shraddha felt it too.

And thank you for penning down your thoughts! You write beautifully too😊


see my UN is quite similar to Sher🤣
ReetšŸ˜‰
Yeah insecurity which erupted with the arrival of his badke bhaiya, I want a lover like him🤣, who confesses his feelings in a go, why to wait for so long and waste ones timešŸ˜†.
Alright, as i have started watching the show just few epis back so kinda not clear about all when he said what and how he expressed his feelings,my perspective is all about the recent episodes but now m getting the clear picture that love happened to him at first sight and that to ishq vala lovešŸ˜†, he confessed it too but got rejected and accepted the rejection with heavy heart😭. But then he got married and was not aware that Shradhas feelings for him were fake/or she said yes under Bhanwari's pressure. Till then he was so happy but that bitter truth teared his heart into two halves and now Virat is trying to make tiny pieces out of those two halves,which he can't bear anymore that's why he made it so clear to Shradha last night. And will make this more clearer to Virat bhaiya by today nightšŸ˜†.
M dying to see that passionate love, i don't want a silent love story but want Sher to do anything for Shradha to win over her. I don't want Sher to force himself over Shradha but want Shradha to accept Sher with all the love not just that its her responsibility as a wife.

And thank you Sam for appreciating my useless wordsšŸ˜†.
Edited by BabbaR_SheR - 10 years ago
CatcherInTheRye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Even mamaji said to his Jiji...
hum bole the na apko jiji k sher bahuriya ki dadi k antim sanskaar mein hi gya hoga, nahi to kahan uthta hai hmra "Babbar sher" itni savere🤣
Fr0zen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Awesomme post samridhi.. šŸ‘ šŸ‘ ..
Was actually waitin for ur analysis... šŸ˜› ..
Lekin abhi time mila comment karne ki...
Lovvedd yesterday s epi... ..
Cant wait to see more passionate scenes of Sher Singh... šŸ˜Ž ..
Do post such awessome analysis in future ... 😃
Fr0zen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: BabbaR_SheR

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="3">Even mamaji said to his Jiji...</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="3">hum bole the na apko jiji k sher bahuriya ki dadi k antim sanskaar mein hi gya hoga, nahi to kahan uthta hai hmra "Babbar sher" itni savere🤣</font>


...
šŸ˜† ..Wat does Babbar mean... šŸ˜• ..My hindi is bad...
WinniethePooh. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Glad to see your post. It was truly an amazing episode and I loved every moment of it.
I loved how Shraddha shut Sher up with her honesty. I think that's what draws Sher towards her besides the fact that she is pretty. She did not take his hand in the 2nd meeting and walked away, and we saw a grinning, happy Sher. He does not mind her rejection. He can take it..remember how he let her go? But its her dishonesty that has the potential to hurt him. He was hurt when she didn't tell him earlier that she was forced to marry him, when she ran away without making him privy to her plans and this time because she hid the fact that she knew Virat. And he made this point very clear..before the swyamvar question I recall him saying something like you will only tell me everything when I ask you right..
And yes you are right that comment about him knowing her feelings well wasn't just a comment. He meant it. Sher means what he says..he is not one to just say stuff for the sake of it.
Shraddha's reply was gold. And your thoughts on this scene, I have nothing to add. I was always wondered about Shraddha's feelings towards Sher. And this scene made it very clear. She might not love Sher but she does not hate him either. She has accepted his position in her life, & accepted him for who he is. Sher really does not have to do a lot..he just needs to give her some strength & confidence..like he did when he passed her the sari. I loved how he avoided her gaze & went to the bed immediately. He was overwhelmed by her reply and probably thought through it the whole night.. I am also certain he did not sleep. I think that him going for her grandmother's funeral was out of guilt as well as to avoid her gaze before he clearly thought things out. And the funeral scene in my opinion made things very clear for him. More than her reply, I think it is her father's comments that hit him hard.. made him realise the injustice Shraddha has been going through..his question - what did i do wrong.. was like him hitting his head against the wall, questioning why he is being blamed.. he loved, accepted her rejection and was forced into the marriage..now he has to face his mother's wrath & Shraddha's scared face all the time.. it hurts him bad. You are right - the last shot was the re-birth of Sher - he was cleansing the anger within him, all the bad things he's done...what's done cannot be undone but he will do all it takes to make things better.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".