Urgent Update - Feedback from the director - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

87

Views

8.7k

Users

40

Likes

543

Frequent Posters

ShellJA thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: manzilmukul

Well for me it will be a Vikram Sugni show..even if not paired romantically..MY ONLY PROBLEM IS THE ACTOR Playing Adi..Trackwise thumbs up but ADI -THE ACTOR PUTS ME OFF..AD-SUG are LIKE chalk and cheese in chemistry ...Adi -CHARACTER IS LAYERED Adi -THE ACTOR MAKES WANNA BANG MY HEAD ON THE WALL.I love Vikram Sugni dynamics even if they are at opposite poles at loggerheads it will be FASCINATING to watch



you're so right. Even if Vickram and Sugni are not together even their fight scenes will be amazing. I look forward to that fire/heat/chemistry too. If the actor playing Adi had a fraction of Varun's charisma we would be having a different discussion here. There may have been a love triangle for the audience as well. Who do we love more ...Vick or Adi :). But sadly that is not the case.

Transference thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Shell16



you're so right. Even if Vickram and Sugni are not together even their fight scenes will be amazing. I look forward to that fire/heat/chemistry too. If the actor playing Adi had a fraction of Varun's charisma we would be having a different discussion here. There may have been a love triangle for the audience as well. Who do we love more ...Vick or Adi :). But sadly that is not the case.

Yup SHELLY ...I really do not care about the jodi as long as we see some power packed performances
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: chalhov

I want to see the story as the director and the story writer wants to show otherwise how will i like dislike the show. ok I like the acting and chemistry of Vikram and Sugni but what is the story the director wants to show and if SE is not a good actor then I dont like to see him much with his insipid acting but finally its the story I want to see its progession and leave that to the Ph after all its different from saas bahu and G meet B fall in/out of love stories and underlying in the show is also the social problem and life that the bednis face .Like in the precap Gulabiya telling Sugni she will never be a Thakurian and VS wont marry her so let me see what happens.

We read a story and then criticise it for different storylines and structure but here with each week episodes we want some change or another in the story lines not only we viewers probably the channels and other related people based on TRPs and story the kachumar likal dete hai and creatives think something they are made to do something else and finally editing people make the final mess edit important parts and ok the most unimportant section and we viewers sometimes(not always) get the garbage
The other day one creative writer was saying the average television serial comes out with one film every week working under high pressure Films takes months/years to complete shooting and re shooting



You can still dislike a show if a writer and director do not give us a good story. Problem is the storyline was sold to us one way and not very well.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: -rupa-

Thanks for sharing the info , Can u share which email id we can send mail to director of PSH .

With so many articles on vikram i did made my mind that he is gonna be grey or atleast not love of sugini ...but i always wanted equation between sugini & vikram ..bad , good , lust , love ..what ever ..up & down but not adi falling for sugini . he can be support system to her ...most of the time lead leave there first love GF for lead actress .cant adi be supporting sugini without being part of her life .
I dont think i can ever ever see adi & sugini love in PSH . Sad ...i feel very dishearten that why i started to watch this show ..i like vikram as character with all the shades in him but always look forward sugini in his life too .



Emails should never be shared in public unless it is with the consent of the person. However, you can reach these people indirectly through zeetv, facebook etc. 😃 I will send you a private PM.
Edited by Laila2009 - 13 years ago
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: manzilmukul

Well for me it will be a Vikram Sugni show..even if not paired romantically..MY ONLY PROBLEM IS THE ACTOR Playing Adi..Trackwise thumbs up but ADI -THE ACTOR PUTS ME OFF..AD-SUG are LIKE chalk and cheese in chemistry ...Adi -CHARACTER IS LAYERED Adi -THE ACTOR MAKES WANNA BANG MY HEAD ON THE WALL.I love Vikram Sugni dynamics even if they are at opposite poles at loggerheads it will be FASCINATING to watch



The reason he bores you is not the actor but the character. Not even the finest actors from Hollywood could breath life into this dull character. He is not a lead; he has no depth. He is perfect as a side character who could turn negative and manipulative. The minute I saw him show up, I knew in an instant this is their lead and they are heading in the direction of Adi Sugni.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
We are definitely going to witness a twist and we are to enjoy the show for now...but this twist that is coming up could disappoint us and as we all know, the only way we will be disappointed if there is no TVS-Sugni jodi.

Do NOT stop watching the show after reading this post otherwise TRPs will drop with these TVS-Sugni scenes...I am going to stop the MINUTE the Sugni-Adi romance starts.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Shell16



Laila, Thanks for taking the lead in this and sharing the information.

In response to your comment above, I have read a lot of threads on this forum in the last couple of days. I have not seem anyone say that they don't like the Vick-Sugvi pairing. In fact everyone seems to love their chemistry, camaraderie and romance. However, what I and lots of others have a problem with Vickram, in the episodes post confession, is his approach. He is moving too fast, he is using higher level of technique to woo Sugvii when more basic getting to know you is required. He touches her when they should be just talking. He is telling her she has 10 minutes to tell him she loves him. This is what a lot of us are saying is creepy and manipulative behaviour. However, it makes complete sense as it is an indication of what the director told you. which is a breakup between V-S and forced pairing of A-V.

Having said all of that the actor playing Aditya will have to up his game a 1000 times in order to become a lead and win the audience after the V-S breakup. At the moment he can't hold his own against Gulki and Varun. however, in this game TRPs dictate how things happen in the future. So i have a feeling that as soon as they breakup V-S and start moving forward with A-V the TRPs will go down and they will have no choice but to go back to V-S.

I just hope that they don't butcher Vickram's character too much that the audience loses all interest by that point.



Director said he also did want to please the fans...but I did not get that impression that he really "gets it" or what we want. The main writer has not responded to me yet. You are right with your observations in one respect this is not the typical courtship we see on Indian television. So, I can only say is that this is actually going to mean the Adi-Sugni romance. It's not the actor who is at fault - the character is boring and the scenes are poorly written. I hope you are right about everything and that looking at the TRPs they will know better. I can handle anything - even a negative, grey TVS - but no Sugni-TVS in the end or scenes without them or no chance of them being together. 😔
Transference thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Laila2009



The reason he bores you is not the actor but the character. Not even the finest actors from Hollywood could breath life into this dull character. He is not a lead; he has no depth. He is perfect as a side character who could turn negative and manipulative. The minute I saw him show up, I knew in an instant this is their lead and they are heading in the direction of Adi Sugni.


I disagree with this JUST MY POV ..Adi the character is not boring...He could have been a powerful character..A boy who has a tormented past...You have to seriously watch all those intro scenes like the one where he remembers his father...near the bargad tree..An immensely layered character wasted due to the actor...We cannot see ADI as the lead due the Actor being completely overshadowed BY Varun's acting...You betcha...even JT against Varun stands at par coz JT 's acting is grt...he is not the lead though..So one has to understand that The actor has the responsibility to breathe life in the character..The character is extremely well written but Mr.SE actually gives the same expression in every frame which makes you YAWN...
To pitch someone average against Varun was a wrong choice which backfired and WE ARE MISTAKING THE ACTOR'S LACK OF CONNECT WITH THE CHARACTER BEING BORING...Completely UNFAIR...
Edited by manzilmukul - 13 years ago
devashree_h thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
Since the first promo I was pretty sure that its not going to be Vikram Sugni. That promo was supposed to give the full gist of the show and it did. Vick wants to her Sardakhai and she runs her away from him. If they show Vick-Sugni story, how will they progress the story? How will they show her fight against all these dirty rituals?
Acutally even I had my doubts that may be they changed the storyline. Glas to know they haven't.

This is the bit of the story I read but I did not post the link before because I was not sure. Now I am.😃You can read the whole story on the link given:

In her journey sugni will not only encounter the evil face of the man who becomes her 'owner' but she will also experience the love with young adityababu who inspite of belonging to the thakur clan showers her with respect and holds her diginity.

Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: manzilmukul


I disagree with this JUST MY POV ..Adi the character is not boring...He could have been a powerful character..A boy who has a tormented past...You have to seriously watch all those intro scenes like the one where he remembers his father...near the bargad tree..An immensely layered character wasted due to the actor...We cannot see ADI as the lead due the Actor being completely overshadowed BY Varun's acting...You betcha...even JT against Varun stands at par coz JT 's acting is grt...he is not the lead though..So one has to understand that The actor has the responsibility to breathe life in the character..The character is extremely well written but Mr.SE actually gives the same expression in every frame which makes you YAWN...
To pitch someone average against Varun was a wrong choice which backfired and WE ARE MISTAKING THE ACTOR'S LACK OF CONNECT WITH THE CHARACTER BEING BORING...Completely UNFAIR...


We are going to have to differ here...the character is very flat and they need to do more with him. I saw the scenes...just to let you know. The character just does not have enough substance or depth to create the potential for a romance with Sugni. JT might not be the lead but he is played by one of the most talented actors of Marathi theater and there is a lot of potential for more scenes with him and Gulabiya - this is something writers could also have done.
Edited by Laila2009 - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".