Was Priyanka correct in her explanation? - Page 3

No I don't agree with Priyanka's decision, it definitely indicated that she did not put any thought into it since her explanation did not back her argument. What I don't understand is if she disliked Hitesh and his mom so much how come she did not write their names on the card which was given to her? Y last min change of heart or mind? She had a lot reasons for her picking Hitesh/mom but very few for the other two and ironically she was able to write down their names wow!!!! Also it was not nice of her to disrespect Hitesh's mom so rudely, I am not a big fan of Hitesh or his mom but if i were in her place i would take the issue with her one on one not to insult someone infront of everyone, you always wanna give them the benefit of the doubt the first time, and you also never wanna drop at the same level as your opponent or else what's the difference b/w Priyanka and Hitesh's mom now.

She did not put Hitty's name because she knew Pooja will save him since she won the task the previous day. As to taking their names and giving that 'explanation', she was asked of whether she would have chosen soemone else other than the one of the chit and she said yes. She had to explain why and she did. She would have gone further and given the exact reasons why if Hitty mom did not cut her short. We have all seen how that woman was dominating in the show, treating the girls as her hand maidens and pretending to be wiser than them, which I dont think she is. I dont think a single maiden there really likes her as future mom-in-law. She is out there to get publicity for herself and her ill-mannered son.

i think pri. did the right think .shezzzz on the show to win her love.

Originally posted by: Showbizz

no one is aperfect model for behaviour and priyanka should have been humble while nominating ppl . She needs to learn humility from rajbirs mom . She said hitesh n mom do politics , but what was the proof , there was no elaboration . No matter what hitesh is , its wrong to insult someone on national TV saying hes nobody's choice , she was arrogant .

very well said

Everybody is just saying that "Why din't Priyanka write Hitty's name, if she so much wanted Hitty to leave", but I would just want to ask a single question here. If it was the turn of a girl to go, and Gaurav had wont he task for the week, would the MILs put Rumpa/Nandita's name in the bottom 1?

why not???? if that is how adamant you are, you in all probably would.

well if she was so sure of hitesh being saved, why even put him in the bottom 3.

now shes just created enemies.

viveks mom wont be too pleased either.

I still don't understand the concept of pleasing the boys and their moms in the whole show. U just have 5 boys and u have to select any 3 out of them, u actually end up displeasing 60% of the population right away. So why care, who those 60% are? U do any kind of permutation and combinations on the 5 kunwars, u would end up displeasing atleast 3 MILs. So why even care who those 3 are. And I don't think she did anything wrong. She wanted Hitesh to be out, and she openly expressed it. She could have wrote his name, but knowing that he would be saved, why to even write his name. She wanted to give Hitty a hint, that she doesn't like him, and she did that very well by keeping him in the bottom 3. Whats the big deal in putting forward ur opinion that ways! Guys give the girl a break, she did exactly what Momma Hitty did last week to Amrita. Dint Momma Hitty also give the same reason for Amrita's elimination, saying her son doesn't see a wife in her. Priyanka also did the same thing for Gaurav. And when she was initially askd the reason for Hitty being in bottom 3, she very clearly said that he is like a brother to her. Usse jyada she never said anything. Only on being askd again, she said something and never opened her mouth all by herself. This goes for her "Maa" sentiment also. She never speaks up all by herself, only if she is questioned again and again, she vents out her frustration/feelings.

well but there is a way to vent out your frustration.
what she did was insult someone on national television.

She may feel like that, but courtesy demands you express it in a way deemed appropriate by 'socity', especially simce she realizes being perfect bride also means being perfect in the society.

she has just shown her class.

i don't know why everyone is taking telling Hitty that no one is interested in him, as an insult. u tell the truth to someone, and how does it become insulting someone. Is it not true that none of the girls r actually not interested in hitty?