NNow Purvi is being REALLY foolish, - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

78

Views

8.1k

Users

27

Likes

438

Frequent Posters

Gauravc_More48 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: celina30

Really, is Purvi so lacking in self esteem and so weak? She gave up Arjun for Ovi, she gave up her family for Ovi and now she is basically giving up her husband for Ovi. Dr Onir does not deserve this. I am surprised that she is asking the Doctor to give up his patients who cannot afford private care and run to the little spoilt brat who can afford the best doctors- her judgement here is poor . She also is partly responsible for the mess that Arjun is in now (I know nobody put a gun to his head) but she used emotional blackmail on him. IMO, both guys should trade in their wives for ones who really love them and not putting someone or family before them- they both deserve better. And when is someone going to put Ovi in her place- calling people filthy poor people- her parents were once there

First of all,Purvi is doing right thing bcoz she wants her sister to get treated n i no where found her highly mistaken but i m really fed up of that Ovi n her Tamasha's she is the one who is making everybody to dance on her nakhras,What i can say is OVi is biggest fool here n she wiil be bcoz of her Childish Behaviour..
Ovi is the culprit in between Arjun n Purvi
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#62
A person being personally unselfish , atruistic and a daughter does not give her the license to control everyone's life and make deisions for them .

None of these 3 things give one unlimited power to do what she wants to do .

If Ovi is drinking and endangering the baby it is wrong period . She being spoilt , she being a tantrum queen , she being an unhappy wife does not excuse her action . A human life is at stake and its safety is the priority , love stories and Arjun can come later .

Similiarly ...forcing someone to make changes in their life ...unpleasant , important life affecting changes is not being a bit unfair but unfair as hell and its high time someone puts this girl in check . None of the changes she expects r a bit unfair and resolvable later ...Arjun is trapped in an unhappy marraige for life due to her silly altruism [ which i do not think was altruism at all as that word for me has a different meaning] and Onir is being asked to leave his practice in Kolkata and his needy patients and treat her rich sister who can afford any doctor here and this expectation is no small thing .

If i was a doctor and if my husband left the home and city with the expectation that i follow him and treat his brother or sister who has categorically refused treatment from me i would be hopping mad coz i have a busy practice here that calls for serious commitment and if my husband left city with my kid and used that kid as a weapon to dangle before me to make me do his bidding i would take serious offense and i would show him how much . That is exactly what Purvi is doing , the kid is unborn right now but she has calculated that due to attachment for it her husband will follow her and she has hit when the iron is hot ...when the man is most vulnerable . Just as there is a big hue and cry when female vulnerability is taken advantage of there must be something shown in this serial that men cannot be taken for granted and their vulnerability is not for attacking by female predators like Purvi . The Too Too Too music when she comes ...[..i call it the Purvi music ] and her sad lovely face don't make her actions right .

Me and my Aai is her motto and she expects all to toe the line . She took advantage of Arjun's vulnerability of being madly in love and made him agree to atrocious conditions and now she is taking advantage of the doctor's attachment to the unborn baby and secretly hoping he will follow her and treat her sis as that will make her Aai happy .

How will she feel if the doctor takes the baby away when it is born and goes to a foreign country and dangles it attacking her vulnerability and making her join him there against her wishes . How would she feel then . Two can play the same game . And i hope the doctor teaches her a good lesson by doing exactly that . Ovi demands atttention and teddy bears and is called spoilt but i find this extremely serious as she plays with lives for getting her way . If this is what she has learned from Archana's famous parvarish it is dangerous . Lowering her eyes , acting all demure but ensuring terrific emotional control she butchers lives .

She can do whatever she wants with her life . If she does not mind going personally scathed herself it her choice , her life . If she feels committed to making her Aai happy i can understand that . But then that should be strictly for herself . She should take decisions involving only her . Like refusing to marry Arjun is her decision to make . But asking him to pass a test of love , marry her sister and later sleep with her and bring a kid in the picture was not her decision to make . She has no right to destroy the Kirloskars and Duttas to make her Aai happy . The baby in her tummy is , i assume , a Dutta . The baby in Ovi's tummy which has come in this world coz she forced Arjun to sleep with his wife is Kirloskar . The man she ditched was a Kirloskar . The man she has left now is a Dutta .

If u only want to be a daughter all ur life , fine . Don't marry then . Take care of ur Aai , spend ur salaries on her , take her for sightseeing ,fight court cases for her , do whatever . But when you marry , you give a commitment to another family , its a very serious promise made in front of God and if u don't believe in him , a court . A marraige does not mean u cease being a daughter . That relation will always remain . There often comes a time in life when the two commitments clash . At such a time one has to be very responsible , mature and outweigh what needs priority and while doing that one family does not suffer as now your work is twofold ...you are committed to two families .

I did not see the parents asking her to make any sacrifice . They had come to talk to the doctor . They were puzzled to see her suddenly here . They r asuming she has told her husband . She has lied to them that all is fine between her and the husband . She had lied to her husband about many things too and shamelessly told him that ' maine tumko jhoot bola'.

Lying comes effortlessly to her . She has to understand that she cannot control lives nor can she make everything right . All have a right to live their own lives , even villainous Punni has a right to make her choices , moneyed lifestyle or middle class marraige , she is a grown up adult . Her choices need not be acceptable to many but they r her choices . Constantly being a roadblock in them is not Archana's business nor Purvi's business . Why force on her that the chote log lifestyle is the best ...it may not be for all like Punni or Ovi although Arjun has suddenly changed and concedes it is the best and although Manav Archana have forced their thoughts on an entire new generation brought up in a foreign land .to live in a chawl . Truly liberated thoughts is living your life the way you want to but respecting others choices , whether you agree with them personally or not . I see only force by Purvi everywhere and since i do not believe in benevolent dictatorship, i object .






crazy2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#63
Yes, Purvi is foolish because she loves her family too much - the family which has given her lots of love, respect and recognition as their daughter. Purvi is worried about Ovi (her Aaai's daughter, her mom's happiness, hope and everything) - Purvi knows that if Ovi & Teju will remain happy, her mother Archana (who has done a lot of things to her) will also be happy..

she has tried a lot - directly indirectly to keep Arjun Ovi's conjugal life in pace...but unfortunately, Arjun still loves her - this is not pruvi's fault.

now if Purvi asks her husband to do something for her family, he should off course help her. because he should understand what place they hold in her life.

purvi is foolish because she never thought about her own happiness. she could easily marry arjun - ovi could not force her (kyuki jab miya biwi raazi to kya karega kaazi), but she didnt...if we can give respect to her, we should not insult her.
strega thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#64

The post was asking if Purvi is foolish - and my answer would be yes. But NOT manipulative or evil. Both of which she is being accused of.


Absolutely - No one has the right to force their decisions on others. The issue I have is not that at all. My issue is that different standards are being applied to the two girls.

We have to use the SAME measure for everyone. What is sauce for the goose should be sauce for the gander :)

Going back a few months, Ovi made sure EVERYONE knew how upset she was with Purvi and Arjun. No one saw how upset Purvi was during the surprise engagement party? Or for that matter Arjun? Can you imagine if the roles were reversed? Frankly, I think Purvi should have run away then - away from the crazies. I would have loved to see her meet Onir under those circumstances.

Purvi was wrong in asking Arjun to marry Ovi - but Arjun did not have to agree and Ovi need not have agreed. But by the same measure, Ovi was wrong in asking Purvi to give Arjun up. True once again, she did not have to. But she did. The difference, Ovi did it for HERSELF. Purvi did it for her AAI. Does it make either of them right? No - but why the difference in assessing motives? Purvi is manipulative while Ovi is justified or at worst misguided? I do not think so.

When Ovi is "upset", she is pregnant and needs to be treated gently. Hormones are at play. Hmmm, why not give the same benefit of doubt to Purvi? She is pregnant too, isnt she? Ovi is emotional but Purvi's actions are termed emotional blackmail. Ovi's underlying threat/actions to harm herself or the baby is not emotional blackmail??

And lastly, if my daughter tried to hurt herself for a guy, I would not be saying "Beta, beta" like Manav in that ineffective voice but hauling her butt to the nearest therapist. And for good measure, Purvi as well.



koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#65
My opinion ...

Purvi is not evil .

But she is manipulative all right and needs to be put in check as much as Ovi .

Ovi needs a therapist to get over her attraction for Arjun which she gives too much importance , over the baby , over herself , over her family ...everything . She needs therapy to put things in focus ...that no man is worth this importance . Only the right thing is important .
Purvi needs a therapist coz she has serious psychological issues too . She has control issues and she is a pathological liar . She tries to control everyone's life...literally everyone , and she lies like hell . To all around her and even to herself . The truth slipped out a bit when she told her mother who has zero sensitivity and is naively idealistic , before leaving for Kolkata

I cannot bear to see him with another woman . Lauki halva for u .

Manav and Archana need to haul the butts of both the daughters to therapists and while they r at it , book some sessions for themselves to solve many of their personal unresolved issues too .

As for Arjun and Onir ...they should run but sadly it is too late now as babies have already come in the picture and they now have lost that freedom.
jdronamraju thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#66
We probably need some therapists too for watching this show despite such crap !! 😆

OK, I am kidding !!
strega thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: jdronamraju

We probably need some therapists too for watching this show despite such crap !! 😆

OK, I am kidding !!


Viewers who actually try to analyze this nonsense certainly could benefit from therapy. Not quite kidding!!
ameilia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#68
The whole Ds and Ks should be hauled off to some therapy sessions.No one is perfect and in PR no one is near that.
They all have faults and imperfections but that is what runs this show.Someone makes a mistake then we see the whole process of them trying to rectify it .
Purvi is far from perfect.She may be called Mahaan but she never sought out to be one.She did make alot of bad decisions and so she is paying the price for them.Both Arjun and Purvi have accepted their fates and have moved on in their lives.Only person that i see not wanting to move on is Ovi caz she is just stuck on Purvi this,Purvi that.I think in the process of wanting to claim Arjun that badly has sunk Ovi to a new low.Now she has risen high so high that no one can see her and she is unhappy abt it.Purvi on the other hand has picked up her life and its getting back to normal until the entry of the Ds back into her life.She didnt have any intention of meeting them as she looked quite content with what she had but that wouldnt last for long.The gurl was bombarded with Aai's rant on Ovi's life,giving Purvi a summary of what had panned out the last six months.
Now the doctor doesnt want to treat Ovi caz she has too much attitude.The Ds cant convince their princess by giving her toys like how you convince a six year old so they turn to Onir.Directly or indirectly pointing towards their other daughter Purvi to help out.Purvi is the kind of girl who can risk her own happiness for others.Whatever she does call it foolish,manipulative watever its not for herself,its NEVER for herself unlike Ovi who does ALL for herself and is even willing to put her baby at risk.

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#69
I disagree that Purvi never set out to be mahaan . It was her goal , being the Miss Perfecto of the readymade family with everyone doing wah wah of her always . Archana the mahaan was her role model and she sacrificed Arjun ruthlessly to get this position and fled when Arjun foolishly declared his love loudly in a party by chiding him

Now bcoz of u they will dislike me .

Onir refused to treat Ovi coz Ovi categorically refused to get treated by him. Her attitude was no problem with him , he did not mind it a bit . He had told Arjun that he was going to treat her although she thought western treatment was the best .

And i feel that not wanting anything personally is hardly a justification for being horribly unfair to so many people . Some people don't do it for themselves but for causes ...her cause is supposed good of her family and thats precisely my point that to help her family she has no right to play around with people from other families .
Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 12 years ago
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#70
Kool I think this whole thing about being an orphan is very very deep rooted in Purvi .I know Archana has loved her so much and even Manav pretty much had become her Baba right from the time he saw her ...but still this whole thing about being adopted is there in her ..
It is sad that even after so much love she still feels this way but it is natural I guess...
I don't know if you have seen the famous Pakistani Tv show ' Dhoop Kinare ' , it is very old but it is a classic and the story in that show was also about this hero who was adopted ...he is a very big Doctor and owns a hospital , is good looking and extrmely rich .His adopted father loved him so much ( just like Archana loved Purvi ) but despite of all that , there were so many comlexes in this guy ..
I guess no one can really feel the pain of someone like this ..
maybe it is this deep rooted complex that makes Purvi do what she does ...
Archana did mention that Ovi needed Onir 's treatment but she told Purvi a fact ...if she had told the same thing to Teju , I am sure Teju would have also tried to make things happen for Ovi but she would not have taken such drastic steps that would put her own life in jeapordy ...
But Purvi did this because of what I said ' the deep rooted feeling of being adopted " by this family ...
I wish this was not the case ( she is way way more precious to Archana than even her own children ) ...but unfortunately despite of having so much love from her mother , Purvi still feels this way ...
Manav's approval is the most important thing for Purvi because it is his name she carries ..
Arjun understood this and that is why he did what Purvi wanted him to do ...he does loves Purvi hell of a lot ...
Maybe her life partner Dr. Onir will also understand this and he will come through for her and help her out .If he does that then this will make their relationship much more stronger than ever .
Edited by Tanyaz - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".