Maha Episode - Page 4

Poll

What is your opinion o todays maha episode??

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

4.9k

Users

17

Likes

212

Frequent Posters

Nisha_90 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: nikitagmc


Na Varsha Di, in my eyes Savita is sick and has been made to believe by Archu herself that Archu wants to steal Manav for her- that Archu is her dushman. All thanks to her insecurity which STUPID MANAV and STUPID ARCHU did not tackle and instead kept provoking her, Archu kept competing with her for Manav.

She is still not cured I feel. Rather I felt angry on Manav for not understanding Savita and her condition, and blaming her for everything when the woman doesn't even know that all that pretanding was done by Archu to 'cure her' . It has obviously backfired on them big time, and now Savita thinks Archu hates her.

Worst part was when he said to his mom about being happy with money (or something like that) and not valuing relations. It was sick. I wanted to throw a tomato.

Manav fans, I am really sorry, but no support to Manav today from my side. I know you must be thinking I'm being very harsh, but my expectations from him are different cos I love him, and this is not the way I see his character.

I wanted to see him saving archana, separating the two, explaining things to his mother properly, slowly, convincing her, comforting her like he did on Sachu's bday--- thanks to his calm and tactful convincing Savita let K's come in the bday party. Today I wanted him to be firm regarding Archana and yet sensitive to his Aai's condition. That didn't happen. Very very angry on CV's today.


Niki i agree wat manav said to her esp she knows only lovee nd you hatee is worse but just place yourself in dat situation..
dat poorchap tried to explain calmly at starting dat you have mistaken for a long time dat you are mistaken its not the same..but she continously saying the same dat she is a thief etc..he couldve got angry on dat word itself but still he stayed calm and his heart was broken wen she said Manav-Archana were waiting for her death so dat he can occupy her house..

i loved him wen he said a house is not made wid bricks and walls but of love 👏

i dont understand how can a mother say such a stuff to a son like manav who gave up his education and lifted responsibilities at such a tender age,made his siblings educated and ran the whole house on his shoulders without making a word..and today she is having sachu is all because of ArMan only..
He felt like a loser dere after her statement..and not to forget he came from a volatile high drama to another where his pregnant wife is being pushed so hardly...

she came to know Archu is pregnant but still said the same go i give a damn to you guys..dat means all she loves in dis world is sachu and only sachu right?she doesnt give a damn to manav and his kid..

no savita has been completely curedd cos old savita always places her Ego and hate first dan her love for her family and kids..and yes'day she did the same..

in upcoming tracks cvs will defo show savita have a change of heart and will be Archu wen she needs someone the mostt cos the present track is been like dat only..ArMan are being separated frm everyone thnx to Dharmesh..but i dont think i'll forgive her for wat she said to manav..
just my POV..

Nisha_90 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Tanya Di, the movie offers were from big production houses, so they must be good only. It was mentioned by chugalkhor aunty also the other day.


I know he cannot leave PR, he needs to have something really good in hand before leaving it. All I wish right now is that he pay great attention to his short films and focus on other things and not only this crap PR and then leave it as soon as he gets a good opportunity outside.


Niki i told nish the same one day..BW is getting crappier day by day with worst and bakwaas stories..i tell you i'll prefer watching PR or any other show dan going to a theatre and waste my money on dat film..best example TMK
BW is getting one or two hit films in a year and even bestt directors are not producing the same..
a director like Ashutosh made a film like wats your rashee and madhur "Jail" and dere is no need for me to say how dose films are..

and TV actors going to BW and getting successful is not dat easy IMO..see Ragini her first film TTB got worst critics i've ever read..and prachi is signing the comedy/Adult movies

so i prefer sushant do PR and concentrate on his short films and become wat he wants to i.e a good director..atleast BW will get one cool director one day😳
naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#33
Nikita and Jai... thanks for writing all your thoughts ..i will take time later today to read them more thoroughly. and i know how passionately you feel about this issue...Varsha too.

What i meant about not understanding though was that i SEE the things that are said about this viewpoint, for months the same things have been expressed by both sides.. these aren't new thoughts based on today's episode. .i understand WHAT you feel is happening i just can't understand WHY you all see this instead of what i see...the opposite or something totally different. 😛

It's very interesting to me because both sides are sincere and both ideas are deeply felt...so it's interesting that that can happen. I know, ask 5 people what happened in an accident and you will get 5 different answers.

I am a trained social worker although i have one of my degrees in psychiatry Nikita, and so i understand what you speak about mental patients. I worked in a mental hospital for a while as well. However i also have been a spiritual counselor, and my point in this is that Savita's portrayal in this series comes from a spiritual deficit, not mental instability. Her greed - which i keep stressing is not for material things, was not for the necklace itself (she liked it this time because it came from manav - this time, but not always) but for controlling people around her to meet her needs. She IS very insecure, but as i watch her, i actually do believe she is of sound mind. Meaning, she has the capability of deciding to forgive, and to recognize her mistakes, and ask forgiveness. I see that recognition of choice in her facial expression. The fact is that because of pride, she will not. . Thats a HUGE difference guys, someone who really IS mentally ill cannot make those kinds of decisions. I think Savita can, but she chooses not to.

Everyone in life who IS of sound mind has a choice as to how they will handle life's problems. Others can make you angry, but no one else can MAKE you be cruel and abusive and try to kill someone. That choice lies entirely up to each one of us. It's Savit'as responsibility to recognize the error of her ways. If she truly were mentally insane, or clinically depressed, which she is not now (though was during the zombie period) i wouldn't ask this of her.

I really hope the CV's give her an encounter with Bappa...it is the only realistic solution..but of course the CV's can do whatever they decide to write. whether consistent with reality or not.😆

Nikita i am sorry you feel so bad about manav. As a mother, if i had a son like him i would be thrilled.. ( i DO have a wonderful son, and a wonderful daughter !! ) Both manav and archu have been a little immature and made wrong choices but never from maliciousness...

It's morning and my washer is going, i have much to do today...hugs to you all ...i feel bad you are so frustrated with the show...😭 and i promise tonight i will re-read your comments...❤️


Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#34
what are the movie actors doing these days ...
Salman, SRK, Akshay Kumar , Hrithik ,Abhishek , Preity .they are all doing television ...
Sushant is the no. 1 hero of Indian TV ..and the show that has put him up there is PR ..
Even today his work was top notch .he looked great and he did a fine job in terms of acting ..
Even yesterday his scene with Ajit was awesome .
As long as PR is doing well in terms of TRPs , it will only benefit him right now ...The only time for him to think of something else is if he gets a big movie offer ...a really good one or if PR hits bottom in terms of TRPs ...
I don't think even he wants it to end right now ...\Not easy to take a show to 500 mark and that too with such high ratings and also getting so many awards for it .
Edited by Tanyaz - 14 years ago
Nisha_90 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#35
sushant is definitely safe wid PR as he can do any reality shows,concerts,short films...he was also really happy and excited wen PR completed 500 epis..he laughed like a cutee kid wen all the old scenes were showed in the party so as Anki and dey still remember all the dates of PR almost..

and i dun think PR will continue more dan 6months also..so lets see

i hate comparing BW to any other film industry cos i really used to love BW once but i really respect HW in dis issue..despite worstt personal issues all the actors are soo committed so as writers.dey always try to show something new and nice where audience feels attracted..but BW writers umm
Jaishankar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#36
Even I feel Sush wont leave PR easily...He really has close connection with PR and he idolizes Manav and besides PR has given him his love of life..He keeps saying how happy he becomes when public come and give him suggestions...
And I think unless he gets a very meaty role in a movie he wont think of leaving PR..ITs actually Television that now mints more money that BW...people from BW are coming into TV now...So I dont think Sush would even think about doing that for now..And also he respects Ekta mata very much as she was the one who gave him break through twice...And he is wonderful soul..so he wont leave all of a sudden PR for BW..HE would think about the role consult with Ekta mata and only when he feels role is very meaty he will consider that option that too with consensus of Ekta mata...He is such a guy that he does not like to hurt anyone or do things abruptly and especially some one like Ekta who he respects so much...
And besides may be Ekta might herself offer a movie in her banner to Sushita soon based on their popularity...
Also Sush is more focused on completing his short term course in US and become a director...He will not go into acting so easily as his goal is to become a director..so with currently PR rocking thr TRP charts and with Ekta in no mood to even think of ending the show in near future and with lot more things to be told ,I think Sush would be happy continuing with PR for another year or so(Guess tamil version is still running which started almost i guess 6 months or more before PR so PR is not ending any time soon..dont think this year Ekta would end it as this is her ace trump card..I think she will take PR till 2012 for sure it seems now)..get more popularity ,earn more bucks and be with Anki and then once I guess PR ends Sush would go for his course and come back to become a awesome director in BW!!!😊
Edited by Jaishankar - 14 years ago
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#37
@Gene: Just read my replies to Naava and Tanya Di. They made the same point which you made that 'how much can Manav tolerate' and I replied it there itself.

Mentally ill patients often don't see sense, logic etc. They get very abusive, ill treat their family members, hit them, hit doctors, claim that their family members want to kill them etc. I have seen such cases. Is it a big responsibility to take care of them.

If in such a case, one is 'tired' of tolerating daily, then go and leave your parents quietly in an asylum where they will be better looked after. But at least don't insult them by saying that they love money and they don't know meaning of love etc and behaving as if you yourself are the best people on earth. They must remember that they are doing it not bcos they have bad feelings or bcos they are bad people, but bcos they are ill- ill to an extent that they cannot understand what is going on around them, which is what is happening with Savita. She is wondering that if Manav Archu don't love me, then why are they here?

Manav and Archana created hatred in Savita's heart herself and now when they have succeeded they are blaming Savita for hating them and not understanding meaning of love etc,

And the explanations Manav gave to Savita was plain pathetic. He should have handled situation more properly. His explanations were nt making any sense only. All the time he wasted in saying all that nonsense saying to Savita about how bad she was and how good Archu is, agar itna time he had spent in explaining excatly what happened to things would have been better.
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: naava



I am a trained social worker although i have one of my degrees in psychiatry Nikita, and so i understand what you speak about mental patients. I worked in a mental hospital for a while as well. However i also have been a spiritual counselor, and my point in this is that Savita's portrayal in this series comes from a spiritual deficit, not mental instability. Her greed - which i keep stressing is not for material things, was not for the necklace itself (she liked it this time because it came from manav - this time, but not always) but for controlling people around her to meet her needs. She IS very insecure, but as i watch her, i actually do believe she is of sound mind. Meaning, she has the capability of deciding to forgive, and to recognize her mistakes, and ask forgiveness. I see that recognition of choice in her facial expression. The fact is that because of pride, she will not. . Thats a HUGE difference guys, someone who really IS mentally ill cannot make those kinds of decisions. I think Savita can, but she chooses not to.

Everyone in life who IS of sound mind has a choice as to how they will handle life's problems. Others can make you angry, but no one else can MAKE you be cruel and abusive and try to kill someone. That choice lies entirely up to each one of us. It's Savit'as responsibility to recognize the error of her ways. If she truly were mentally insane, or clinically depressed, which she is not now (though was during the zombie period) i wouldn't ask this of her.




I differ completely. Savita doesn't seem completely normal to me. A person can be in depression and yet behave normally in some ways. I know of some people who were in depression and yet carrying out all their house hold duties, attending functions, working in houses and so on. In fact most people don't identify depression at all till it gets very severe. It is like a cancer within them. they keep quiet, sometimes get very joyful, sometimes not. Same with Savita. Remember how nice she was with those kids who were stealing colours and even to Manav Archana when they came for holi? Even when Manav gave her necklace, she said I don't want necklace, I want your love. The good part of her is there, she's no villain. She even told Archana that I have no enmity with you, she didn't respond when archana troubled her, rather she went and slept on the floor.

However, when Archana showed signs of wanting to snatch something very precious to her, she Sachu or Manav- she got scared and started fighting back in whatever way she could. This in no way shows she got normal-- this only shows that she started fighting like an animal defends when it is totally cornered. All this bcos Archana herself instilled hatred in her mind. Savita hasn't recovered, I feel. Just cos she shouts doesn't mean that she has become normal. Rather than noticing the way she shouts and declaring her 'normal' Manav Archana should have tried to understand the pinch which led to the screams--- it is very much intact and it begin bcos of their foolish decisions itself.

Earlier Savita was in depression, yet spoke with love to children, to Manav and behaved indifferently to Archana. Today?-- today she made accusations against the son she loved, and did not melt at all on knowing Archu is pregnant. Rather she threw them all out of the house. This in no way signifies a stable mindset. It only signifies she is going from bad to worse cos now she is not trusting her own people. She is losing sense of her family, well wishers, what is going on around her etc. Today she tried to find a reason of why Manav Archu are still in the house- what reason does she come up with- that they want my property, cos they haven't really given her any reasons to believe they love her. ITs her insecure, crooked mind thinking all this.

I won't be surprised if CV's twist this whole thing to show that yes, Savita really had become normal and she was only greedy and then maybe all will laugh at my posts. 😆 But I'm speaking of whta I see in the serial RIGHT NOW.


Edited by nikitagmc - 14 years ago
Nisha_90 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#39
Niki..blame it on CVs or savita charecter..but remember after ArMan reunion she got a dream dat girishji gave her a nice,hugee apartment and wen she wokes up she got really disappointed dat cos of manav i havent got wat i wanted..

here Manav only left her but still visited her and was wid her wen she needed him most lke wen sachu was sick so as Archu..

but wen sachin died den i dun think one month also passed she got dreams of throwing money to her neighbours saying you are bikaaris and i'm rich and also she tried to manipulate shravani for her property so as got really veryy happy after seeing Jewellery she received on manav-shravani's engagement..

i know she went through a rough phase in her life and dats why today she is craving for dem and dats the main reason i felt yes'day she was cured completely by accusing manav of swindling her property..

again i'm saying savita do love Manav but she always places her ego,Hate first dan her love and today if she is suffering den its cos of same reason..

i'll say end dis crappy track and concentrate more on Dharmesh track..even if he wants to harm ArMan dats all we love..seeing dem suffering :) TRPs will go high lke a rocket wen dey suffer to hell
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#40
@Gene: When did I say Savita is not greedy? Yes she is, but right now her behavior is not because of greed but because of illness and what Manav is doing right now is that he is punishing her for mistakes committed during her 'normal' period by saying you are greedy and you don't know love etc. That's all I wanted to say. There's a time for everything. Even criminals are not given punishments when they are sick. You help them recover first, then you punish them or whatever.

what is being shown right now is sick.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".