Hanuman Singh - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

129

Views

13k

Users

27

Likes

562

Frequent Posters

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Mishti_Dahi

Another member here explained to me yesterday that how HS now gets to face the dirty sides of her personality, which he already knew of but how he is facing them for real.

I think he did accept the ugliness but his idea of their perfect relationship shattered. Perhaps that was the intent of writers which bombarded as something 10 times powerful than what was intended.

@Bold - Agree. I have liked the writing so far but feels like this track is not being set up right.

HS is not a child and he went in this with eyes open. He cannot be shown disillusioned to this great extend even before taking the first few steps.

I felt the whole lala conversation in last episode was extreme and off mark. He could simply have reflected on Babita's insecurities.

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: annx

But then Mishti wasn't Hanuman wrong at assuming a 'perfect' relationship... it's not like he's a saint either or without flaws... that's what is bothering me... we (or rather Hanuman) gets to see one flaw and he ends up saying things like 'mere andh kuch mar gaya' and drinking the poison... I mean then why did he said 'mujhe tu daughter ki mother puri ki puri chahye' which meant including her ugliness... I still can't understand the shock Hanuman had...

@Bold - My thoughts exactly. This is such a U-turn of a character that has been shown as mature, understanding and patient. The extreme reaction confused everyone.....

Am hoping the writers cover this nicely....

Cutiie_Pie thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: annx

But then Mishti wasn't Hanuman wrong at assuming a 'perfect' relationship... it's not like he's a saint either or without flaws... that's what is bothering me... we (or rather Hanuman) gets to see one flaw and he ends up saying things like 'mere andh kuch mar gaya' and drinking the poison... I mean then why did he said 'mujhe tu daughter ki mother puri ki puri chahye' which meant including her ugliness... I still can't understand the shock Hanuman had...

Yes Daughter ki mother is not a perfect person. If he wants her puri ki puri then it will include her ego, her fear, her insecurities etc etc.

Srilata.Mineil thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#34

Thanks for this post dear... U echoed my feelings too towards the whole thing...

HS ne galti ki wo bastion bole to matter whatever was the reason.. Words once said can't be taken back... And u need to apologize for that... But u don't....

Problem. U know what it is everybody wants them to be couple that's but nobody thought that need to talk and sort out. Some. Issues and then proceed.. Even they don't do..

When Babita was hesitating to try the relationship ahead and verybody were saying that it's her ego which is stopping her... But nobody thought how difficult it would have been for a woman to take those words from the person she loved once again... But when she voiced out u r feeling bad... HS was the person who said her to take a stand for. Herself... But when she took u taking it in wrong way...

She said to choose ur ego or her and u chose her and I respect u for that but u can't say that she will choose her ego. Over u... She was the one who. Proposed first... Keeping aside her ego then how can u say that she will leave if her ego is hurt...

Yes u have to do her amrit manthan to clear her her insecurities but u need have to the poison... U can simply explain her talk to her but no u will talk to. Minni or lala how will. It work if u both won't talk....

Even I felt he overreacted.. Soon he will. Also realise that.... Babita testing his love was wrong but he have also misunderstood her thinking she will. Leave him. For. Her ego...

Edited by porankisrilata - 6 years ago
Resham thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#35

They messed up with the writing I believe... HS talked extreme... On one side he wants her as full so it means all of her insecurities, her fears, her past he assumed to come with it... He should also have understood that whatever apology she asked comes out from her insecurities she had of her past relationship... I still say it was measured in wrong way... He too had just walked off after declaring himself as Mini's father and not wanting to share his sorrow... And all of a sudden he questioned her character... In whatever intent it was... So didn't he went wrong here...

If he says that she needs to accept him with his past... As he is doing... Why go to an extreme say... He can back off even now..i say both are carrying flaws.. It's just that they need themselves to talk abour and shed all kinds of inhibitions and awkwardness now they r taking steps to marriage

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: porankisrilata

Thanks for this post dear... U echoed my feelings too towards the whole thing...

HS ne galti ki wo bastion bole to matter whatever was the reason.. Words once said can't be taken back... And u need to apologize for that... But u don't....

Problem. U know what it is everybody wants them to be couple that's but nobody thought that need to talk and sort out. Some. Issues and then proceed.. Even they don't do..

When Babita was hesitating to try the relationship ahead and verybody were saying that it's her ego which is stopping her... But nobody thought how difficult it would have been for a woman to take those words from the person she loved once again... But when she voiced out u r feeling bad... HS was the person who said her to take a stand for. Herself... But when she took u taking it in wrong way...

She said to choose ur ego or her and u chose her and I respect u for that but u can't say that she will choose her ego. Over u... She was the one who. Proposed first... Keeping aside her ego then how can u say that she will leave if her ego is hurt...

Yes u have to do her amrit manthan to clear her her insecurities but u need have to the poison... U can simply explain her talk to her but no u will talk to. Minni or lala how will. It work if u both won't talk....

Even I felt he overreacted.. Soon he will. Also realise that.... Babita testing his love was wrong but he have also misunderstood her thinking she will. Leave him. For. Her ego...

Am really hoping that this has been set up wrong so the writers can lead them to talk and build an understanding..... It has been a beautiful story so far and will be a shame to ruin it....

@Bold 1 - you made the decision to choose your love over your ego, then why are you feeling this bad about doing so is my question to HS. You chose love - you should be happy. She showed you her insecurities - think that you will give her so much love that her insecurities will be healed. If you can immediately think that she will react negatively, then did you really understand her all this while? She was always someone who has a past and you were always someone who was ready to take her with all her 'kharashe'....

@Bold 2 - If you love her enough then trust her enough to talk. Maybe thats what the writers are leading to *fingers crossed*.

ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: Resham

They messed up with the writing I believe... HS talked extreme... On one side he wants her as full so it means all of her insecurities, her fears, her past he assumed to come with it... He should also have understood that whatever apology she asked comes out from her insecurities she had of her past relationship... I still say it was measured in wrong way... He too had just walked off after declaring himself as Mini's father and not wanting to share his sorrow... And all of a sudden he questioned her character... In whatever intent it was... So didn't he went wrong here...

If he says that she needs to accept him with his past... As he is doing... Why go to an extreme say... He can back off even now..i say both are carrying flaws.. It's just that they need themselves to talk abour and shed all kinds of inhibitions and awkwardness now they r taking steps to marriage

I would have loved to see HS feeling sad about her insecurities and positive about the power of his love to heal......

They both don't need this negativity. and this is not ego.... it is a woman's natural insecurity & fear...

Resham thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#38

True Arch... Would have loved to see that perspective as well from HS but it's all messed up by the writing... PB is surely going off the track now.... Don't know how much hard is for the makers to show people COMMUNICATING...

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#39

I have always said that HS should have apologized to her on his own for his words (perhaps not the reason behind them), due to his own principles, regardless of whether Babita demanded it or not. It was not ok to say those things to her, he could have found a better way to achieve the same result. Fine, maybe he was in distress so couldn't think straight but after the matter on the court case was sorted out, nothing prevented him from apologizing. I also think she was right to be offended enough to leave for the sake of her self-respect but the message she gave was that she was leaving him/the house in his time of need because she put her self-respect above him then.

He has seen what a good marriage looks like and what total surrender in a relationship is about, what letting go and overlooking the other person's mistakes is about. He told NB that aise na hota prem ka rishta, because he has a point of reference. Babita has not experienced or seen such a thing and the fairytale image she has of a perfect marriage and the expectations that come with it is not necessarily something HS expects or looks for. The mistake both are making is assuming the other person will react or think the same way they do about situations and words.

This is why I have been saying this whole wedding is rushed, it's too soon. They should have taken the time to evaluate whether or not they want to spend their lives with each other, whether they are a good fit for each other or not. Proposal without sorting out underlying issues was the main problem here. She rushed and he did too. Babita is still not ready, and I've said this for ages, and neither should HS or anyone else, including Babita herself, expect her to be this soon. She hasn't moved on from her past completely. Whether or not she was partly or fully to blame in her past marriage is a different matter. It will take time. A few months cannot erase 17 years.

Society puts pressure on people to get married the first time round, and in many ways the second time round too without trying to understand that it can be harder and more complicated. "They love each other so they must get married soon." Why must it be that way? I also think the PH was trying to highlight this but it hasn't come out correctly for some reason.

HS' reaction and chat with Lala was not about discovering her ego issues or insecurities or anything like that. He had always known she had them but I am starting to wonder if he has now become insecure that no matter how much he loves her and tries to protect their relationship she could leave him because of these issues. He cannot even bear to imagine that he might lose her one day and is feeling this way because he thinks it is inevitable even though that might never actually happen. After the whole Imarti track there was no introspection shown to us on his part or on Babita's as to how they both felt about it, and it was swept under the rug as usual. They don't know explicitly where they stand in each other's lives and all the underlying issues have yet to be handled and communicated about. As I said other posts, HS should not do this to himself. If he is feeling this way he should either back off or resolve the issues before marrying her. In either case, he needs to have a discussion about it with the person who it affects and not just Lala or NB.

The fact that the PH are having to justify their stance on social media shows that they missed the mark with those scenes.

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago
Mannmohanaa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: annx

But then Mishti wasn't Hanuman wrong at assuming a 'perfect' relationship... it's not like he's a saint either or without flaws... that's what is bothering me... we (or rather Hanuman) gets to see one flaw and he ends up saying things like 'mere andh kuch mar gaya' and drinking the poison... I mean then why did he said 'mujhe tu daughter ki mother puri ki puri chahye' which meant including her ugliness... I still can't understand the shock Hanuman had...

Maybe that whole reaction itself was wrongly done.

I don't know beyond this point. It's all moving in circles aur mhaare Sar ke upar se jaa raha hai!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".