Hello.
I am a silent reader here and have loved the show, the writing, characters and the acting. There has been much discussion in the last few days about Babita and her ego and HS and his hurt/love. I have enjoyed reading all comments and perspectives and just felt like sharing something from my side now -
Aniruddh Dave - Has been a fantastic actor and stayed consistent in every emotion, track or moment they scripted. He made us believe in HS's goodness, love, unlimited support and understanding.
HS - The character. I feel the PH has been inconsistent with this character. It seems that the character graph or certain story bends got written to bring out Aniruddh's brilliant acting.
PH - They have scripted Babita in reality. but it feels to me that they kept scripting HS scenes the way they did as they understood AD is connecting with the audience brilliantly.
I have few questions/thoughts on the character HS (keeping AD out of the equation).
Disclaimer - This is a very long note. I just had many thoughts :-)
Hanuman Singh -
1. He says Babita hurt him many times and he ignored. Am trying to understand when did she hurt him and why was he hurt.
- Camera incident - Babita was returning everyone's invested money. All were well-wishers. NB took hers but HS refused. The way he reacted, NB understood for the 1st time that he has developed feelings for Babita. Now NB could be society and anyone will assume he has a soft corner for Babita if he reacted in such a manner.
Babita was still on a journey to moving forward from the painful events in her life. Her past was still around her and she was in no mind space to love anyone else.
Any self-respecting woman in that situation, understanding that another man has started having a soft corner for her, will attempt to clearly draw boundaries. No one needs that complication at that particular juncture in life. it was way too soon and she was not ready.
When he got the Camera from the returned money, she didnt like it and asked mini to return it. do we not tell our kids to not take expensive gifts from others - be it friends or family. and HS is someone in whose house they stay. He is a support but it is all the more important to ensure that the boundaries are maintained when you are not ready.
HS got upset. I don't understand this. Did his love come with a condition that it should be reciprocated immediately and in the manner he wants? This can't be the case as he has been shown to be mature so she clarified the boundaries, he accepted, then why carry the hurt. She was not in the love phase and it is important to have boundaries when living in this close proximity.
2. Babita says 'Thank you' to HS which he doesn't like - I understand the feeling but again from her perspective she is simply thanking him for everything he keeps doing.
Babita is not compelled to fall in love just because HS has fallen in love with her. Even if Babita loves HS, she is not compelled to act on it. She is just coming out of her life events that happened just a few months back. It is all too soon so she is OK to draw boundaries. Why should this hurt the man who understands her too well and knows relations are complicated? And why is he carrying this hurt? Did it hurt his love when she didn't reciprocate or his ego?
3. HS says he doesn't want to change Babita. He wants her the way she is with all her past, insecurities, cracks and more.
- Then how on the 1st clear view of her insecurities (when she demanded the sorry), does he worry so deeply and talks about Amrit Manthan and him drinking the poison and fear if he will be able to live with it. This is a man who knows the sensitivities of their relationship. The fact that both come with a past and the fact that she has many pains and insecurities and was willing to accept her with all.
Babita didn't ask him to apologise with folded hands. She asked him to apologise and mean it. He chose the style of doing it himself. I feel the PH is stressing on Babita's ego as that's what they want to highlight but in Babita's situation, any real woman will have insecurities and not once has HS ever verbalised his love for her. It has all been implied (from both ends) but any woman (or man) needs to hear it. She chose this way to assure herself that he really loves her (maybe the wrong way but in a real person, there are many emotions going on within simultaneously, in any moment - it's not like we deal with one emotion at a time). It was her hurt at the words, her confusion, her insecurity (maybe about herself if she is really worthy of this new happiness) and insecurity and the need to know if he really loves her or will leave at the first sign of discomfort.
She really didn't ask him to apologise with folded hands. She simply asked him to apologise and mean it. The first time he apologised, it was like 'you have also hurt me many times but i let it go. You knew the circumstances and why I said what I said, but sorry'. Yes, she knows the circumstances now but words once spoken cannot be taken away. In this scenario, I would like the man to apologise on his own which he didn't so if it was me, i would feel 'taken for granted'. she doesn't want to be taken for granted this time. HS will not but she is protecting herself (it's a natural instinct).
You cannot erase the past and her current actions will have impressions of the past. At least till the point, she is fully confident of her new life. In this scenario, just knowing the man loves you is not enough. Human psyche runs deeper.
Being taken for granted - extended the point above, HS came in during the Puja, sat next to her and announced himself to Mini's father. All this in full public view. Irrespective of the bond between HS & Mini, babita is Mini mother. HS has not declared his love for Babita in words but announced himself to be mini's father and this without even asking the mother even once. All discussions post this tell us that the father-daughter bond is not dependent on Hanita bond, which is true. Then the question is when the father-daughter bond is not dependent on Hanita bond, how can Babita be sure that the Father announcement was his declaration of love for her? It was simply his declaration of his love for mini ! And he didn't even bother to ask the Mother before doing that. Extension of this - he comes back and pushes her away with the harshest words. The Father-Daughter bond continues after this. In all this, only Babita would feel completely taken for granted and left assuming many things.
She understands his hurt, the Imarti situation and what he was going through but she is a grown woman with a past not an optimistic teenager free to choose relationships. She understood his situation but he had hurt her below the belt so she cannot just jump in. She doesn't know if she will be pushed away if she did that or if he even wants that. A teenagers response in this situation and an adult's woman's response cannot be compared.
Mini asks her to come to NB's house and help the situation. She hesitates. Mini goes by herself thinking Babita has given up. Mini talks to SS and gets the letter to read. Against all emotions and hurt, Babita comes there by herself (she just took longer to make that decision but Mini had already left and Babita could have chosen not to come but she did). Babita helped, she translated the letter but kept a physical distance. This is the distance HS created and she maintained. How the hell will she erase this completely when SS leaves and just jump back into romance. It takes guts. HS has still not verbalised his feelings and she finally took a leap of faith by vocalising her intention. (She proposed). She knows he loves her but love is not enough to drive a relationship in the real world. She needed assurance. She didnt hide her hurt and told him she was hurt and expected an apology. This is not one-dimensional. It was not just about the apology, it was about reassuring herself, not being taken for granted, wanting to know for sure if she is his priority and if he will stand by her even in an uncomfortable situation. There were too many emotions in that one act. The PH is over-simplifying this and labelling this as EGO. Humans are not so shallow.
4. HS kept his ego aside and apologised with folded hands - He kept his ego aside and chose love. Then why feel bad about it? and bad to this extend? He knows her too well so he knows she has many insecurities especially after the recent experience and the messy divorce. She has stood strong, listened and learnt from everyone but acted on her own and brought herself forward in life. This is what he fell in love with. He didn't fall in love with perfection but a woman with an inner strength to learn & grow. Accept what life throws at her and face it.
When he tells Lala that she never got a chance to take out her frustration & pain of past experience so she took it out on me - he is right. No-one just comes out of her kind of experience in a blink. It is not a switch and she has simply been moving forward since. But have her emotions got any outlet. So her insecurities came out.
The only answer to insecurities is love. A strong love anchor (which HS was supposed to be) will heal insecurities with time. He has a lot of love to give so why is he suddenly afraid and why is the woman's emotions suddenly her ego?
He meant his sorry so why is he so upset (even till the next morning) that he is so low and doesn't want to join the chunni selection? Why show a feeling of 'what have I gotten myself into'? If his love is strong and he understands Babita, how can he not see her insecurities? and If he sees her insecurities, why is he so afraid of the future? He knew she will have many 'kharashe' and he wanted her with all - so why be so deeply effected at the first sign of it?
or was the PH trying to cash in on AD's brilliant acting skills to show him emoting angst, pain, tragedy?? and the outcome is simplifying Babita's emotions....
The PH and us all know that the 2 characters (Babita & HS) are written as love interests to each other but that doesn't mean the characters know that (or should know that). If HS does something sweet, Babita cannot be expected to reciprocate on the same level. If she doesn't, she has hurt HS!! But she doesn't know she is supposed to be HS's love interest in this story.....she is living her emotions and drawing boundaries.
You don't love with a condition to receive love back. So you shouldn't hurt if the other doesn't reciprocate as expected. If you are willing to wait and give space to the other person, then how can you be upset that the other is taking time to step over boundaries! I don't understand how Babita hurt HS by not reciprocating his love as and when he wanted. She was simply not ready.
And HS has been shown to be more mature than this so the up & down of this character's emotions do not fully feel justified now. And in life, you don't just go from one thing to next without any space in-between which is what Babita is required to do in this script.
btw, he is also the one who said - 'Imarti, imarti thi' and walked away in angst. The next day when NB mentioned that his words hurt Babita, his response was 'I don't think I said anything hurtful. she knows my past with Imarti'. If he doesn't think he said anything hurtful, he cannot understand the impact of them.
Babita - why is she expected to understand all this and absorb everything without even expecting a heart-felt apology? Yes, Imarti, Imarti thi. Babita just wants to know if 'Babita, Babita hai ya nahi'. Why over-simplify and call it ego?
Like Babita, too many thoughts in my mind too :-)