Why is Babita wrong?

Lakshs thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1

This is long post and sorry this is not to offend anyone....but just my 2 cents:

In the last few days, I heard such negativity about Babita's reactions. Why so? Simply because Imarti came out of our imagination and portrayed a strong and passionate woman? A fairytale eye candy story?

A lot of us when we start our journeys, have desires, outlook, and don't forget a strong backing from our parents in most cases. In Imarti's case she was young strong, bold, did what she wanted, and knew her father would support her no matter what and so, boldly put Hanuman in place on the first night and to her luck, Hanuman was a nice guy who realized his errors right away and embraced her the way she was- gave her the freedom. (We all like to see ourselves like that too). This helped build a beautiful, strong and passionate relationship between the 2 until her death and perhaps beyond. He adores her even now.

Babita's story is a bit different. Remember, her brother saying that she was the dear daughter in the house, however she by nature was simpler and more mellow always caring for others. Fact is there are a variety of people in the world how much ever we want all the women to be strong and bold and what not... next her marriage proved different. If you remember the first few episodes, no one saw to her comfort. She worked for everyone and this was not for one or 2 days or months for 17 years- no joke. She did not have the support of her husband who stood by her like in Imarti's case either which is a big thing for a woman especially in a joint family. And moreover, her parents were nothing like Sardar Singh who would fight until the end for his daughter. And remember they passed away leaving not such a strong younger brother behind. I am not saying that her in laws were mean.

The dynamics change in this situation and the girl is left alone in the world with no one. They become insecure regardless of how strong they were as a child. And I know her strengths as a child keeps popping up now and then after a long time but it takes time- as you see in the after ashok phase with some prompts from Minnie and Hanuman.

One may think there is Minie, but she has become a great source of support only recently. Please don't forget her age. And yes she is sensible and forgives Hanuman for he recently told Babita, but remember she is still young and sees hanuman as the father figure. She really wants this to work for her mom and hence she is quick to forgive. I am not saying she is wrong or that Hanuman is a bad person. But remember her situation. Yes, she has gone through rejection from her dad but what her mom goes through is totally different. I am not sure how to explain but a woman giving everything to a man is so different especially for someone like babita.

It took a Herculean task for Babita to come forward and accept her new feelings and then Hanuman yelled at her saying my space my life etc for stopping him from drinking pushing her away. next day he came and claimed to be Minnie's dad building a relationship and confusing her further and thentelling her to stay within her limits. Paraya Mard is not a small thing for people like Babita to whom self respect is everything. One wrong move and it could have a big negative effect/impact. She was groomed by the society's thought process. She is slowly coming out of the shackles of her fear and accepting life as she wants it and an accusation so deep for whatever reason hit deep in the roots. She has a daughter too she is responsible for who might be a big strong girl with a strong mind and personality. But a mother is a mother. She feels responsible as naive as she might be. It is unimaginable for a mother to take risky steps for a woman who has been shunned and left with no support all her prime life and later to be accused in court by her ex in the rudest way to easily forget everything.

Like I said she has moved past Ashok, she has become independent in many ways, and is bolder. But saying "don't have so much interest in Paraya Mard " by the very man she is ready to move forward and try and build a new life after a lot of hesitation, is no joke.

And why should she stay right now? hanuman is cute and a good man and many positive things to add to these qualities ( I love his character), but he has made it clear that his Imarti is all he cares for. Then why should she sit and wait for something that is not cooking? You and me know Hanuman's feelings but please wear the shoes of a women like Babita and think from her side. It is not easy to just fight and say what do you mean by paraya Mary you are mine when he has not said anything in words and claimed Imari is everything for him.

NB is also portraying a section of well wishers who mean well but may not be looking at Babith's perspective. They look for good endings If Hanuman was hurt in the worst way would we have given Babita this much slack saying she is a good person and loves him, so he should forgive her easily? Kudos to the makers for representing this part of the society as well.

I am once again very impressed with the makers for understanding the true psyche of a woman going through such a situation despite the nice man in her life and a daughter who pursues her to stay, and take a bold stance in the right direction. There is no stupid ego in this but a very deep hurt insecurity and fear that is being portrayed .

This is not just a thought, but is coming from a woman who has gone through the exact circumstances with a 17 year old strong daughter and a 14 year old son. In my case I was much stronger than babita in many ways during my marriage and before but sacrificed everything for the family. It took me more than 4 years to rebuild my confidence and I am still hesitant with moving on with my personal life with another man. And I live in a modern society and still hear so much ...so imagine her state.

Thanks for hearing me out and thank PB TEAM for making this show so realistic and informative to the society at large.

Edited by Lakshs - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

8.5k

Users

23

Likes

181

Frequent Posters

MJ_1009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 6 years ago
#2

I agree with your post. It's not easy to overcome from one relationship and to move onto another one. Feelings will be feelings, however, there are things that will continue to have a strong impact on our lives from the past. Babita followed the societal norms for 17-18 years as she observed from a young age that this lifestyle was appropriate. Imarti was the polar opposite of Babita & Hanuman supported her for that. Babita only had financial support from Ashok & his family. Yes, she was adored by her family but they, technically used her, if you come to look at it. For example, Lovely used to ask her to cook her delicious food for her kitty party and when Meeta entered as the new DIL, Lovely continued to pin for Babita's food when Babita and Minnie separated. Out of pity, Babita continued to cook for her kitty parties despite their relationship only being joined through Mini as part of their family.

It can be easy to break away from a relationship but, moving into a new relationship(s) can pose challenges given the hardships from the former one. Minnie adored Babita for sure but, as you said, she became her main support recently, alongside others. It took Babita time to overcome Ashok but there are times when she is reminded of her time with him & his family. She still used to panic/freak out a little whenever her moments with Ashok are brought up. Similarly, Hanuman also reminisced his time with Imarti. Certain people/moments leave such a strong impact that they have a tendency to pull us back before entering a new phase of life or relationships. It's like hesitating to enter the highway/express lanes from the road as it is riskier to drive/merge into the lanes; it takes the experience to develop the technique of merging seamlessly.

I have witnessed similar incidents in real life where my friends took time to overcome past relationships depending on the reason: compatibility, financial constraints, societal issues, etc. It's not an easy task.

Edited by meenachem - 6 years ago
Chrys thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Very apt analysis Lakhs. I agree wholeheartedly. Babita is the underdog of the series. And what you have said here resonates with me. Entirely. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

yoyogagirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Lets forget about everything thats happened in the past between Babita and HS. Lets talk about from the time Mini was admitted to the hospital.

HS was Babita's biggest support, emotionally and otherwise during Mini's operation. He stood by her like a rock. He was a friend, a confidante, a support system. Babita was subconsciously starting to think of HS as more than a "friend" since Mini's hospital incident. Then comes the pottery making incident, HS pulls her to make pottery with him, and they have a beautiful intimate moment. HS awakens that desire in her that had been lost somewhere during her marriage with Ashok. Babita in a way has never been intimate with Ashok after he started seeing Meeta (don't know when exactly that happened during their marriage), but nevertheless she has not experienced something like that, and here comes a Man (who she knows "likes"/"loves" her), and she also starts to feel the same way about this man. During this incident, she finally realizes that she has feelings for HS. Then, we see her contemplating with her feelings, breaking down and finally accepting her feelings (to herself), which makes her confident enough to "try" to stop HS from drinking because she somewhere feels she has that "haq" over him now. Yes, maybe her approach was naive, but she did feel that sense of "right" over him at that point. Then, we see the way HS reacts when she brings up Imarti. She knows she hit the wrong button, but she also realizes that HS is not over Imarti yet. HS comes to the Puja and claims Mini as his daughter, to which Babita is shocked, confused, but happy nevertheless. Then HS confuses her further by saying "paraya mard", "maryada mein rehna", completely crushing her and hurting her. Then, she finds out about imarti's court case, and yes Babita initially decides to leave the house because she's hurt by HS's words from the night before, but more than that she's confused about everything. Finally she comes back and supports HS "silently". I know people are mad at Babita for leaving, but I think she redeemed herself when she help mend HS and SS's relationship, and beautifully explained what Imarti meant to express in that letter.

Now we are at the present situation. There's two way she can go with this: Either she confronts HS and clearly communicates her feelings with him (which is the most logical and sane thing to do), or she leaves the house. I mean I understand why she decides to leave the house. HS hasn't talked to her or looked at her since the Imarti's incident. He's giving her the cold vibe. What is she supposed to do in that situation? Go up to him and confront him, sure yes but she's not Imarti or Mini (who would have done that), she's Babita and she reacts and responds to situations differently than how Imarti would have. Is she just suppose to stay at the Haveli as a tenant, when she knows that she "loves" the landlord and when she feels that this relationship will not go anywhere... what is she supposed to do just stay there and be miserable everyday? So, I totally understand why she wants to leave the Haveli.

At this point, I am not understanding what Hanuman wants? Does he even like Babita anymore, does he wanna be with her and continue this relationship, or does he just wanna have a relationship as a tenant and landlord and co-parents to Mini? Its super confusing for him as well I am sure, but he needs to make a decision, like how Babita is finally making a decision to leave and move on from him (in her head obviously, we know she will come back to him), but for now she's made a decision and whatever it is, it is her decision.


My opinion. No offense meant ✌️

Edited by LoveInAutumn26 - 6 years ago
Chrys thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Another very apt take on Babita. As I mentioned earlier, she is the underdog of the series. But I’m with her all the way. Thank you LoveinAutumn for sharing your thoughts.

When we’re in a serious situation, flight or fight is the reflex. And it’s human to express either of them.

Srilata.Mineil thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: LoveInAutumn26

Lets forget about everything thats happened in the past between Babita and HS. Lets talk about from the time Mini was admitted to the hospital.

HS was Babita's biggest support, emotionally and otherwise during Mini's operation. He stood by her like a rock. He was a friend, a confidante, a support system. Babita was subconsciously starting to think of HS as more than a "friend" since Mini's hospital incident. Then comes the pottery making incident, HS pulls her to make pottery with him, and they have a beautiful intimate moment. HS awakens that desire in her that had been lost somewhere during her marriage with Ashok. Babita in a way has never been intimate with Ashok after he started seeing Meeta (don't know when exactly that happened during their marriage), but nevertheless she has not experienced something like that, and here comes a Man (who she knows "likes"/"loves" her), and she also starts to feel the same way about this man. During this incident, she finally realizes that she has feelings for HS. Then, we see her contemplating with her feelings, breaking down and finally accepting her feelings (to herself), which makes her confident enough to "try" to stop HS from drinking because she somewhere feels she has that "haq" over him now. Yes, maybe her approach was naive, but she did feel that sense of "right" over him at that point. Then, we see the way HS reacts when she brings up Imarti. She knows she hit the wrong button, but she also realizes that HS is not over Imarti yet. HS comes to the Puja and claims Mini as his daughter, to which Babita is shocked, confused, but happy nevertheless. Then HS confuses her further by saying "paraya mard", "maryada mein rehna", completely crushing her and hurting her. Then, she finds out about imarti's court case, and yes Babita initially decides to leave the house because she's hurt by HS's words from the night before, but more than that she's confused about everything. Finally she comes back and supports HS "silently". I know people are mad at Babita for leaving, but I think she redeemed herself when she help mend HS and SS's relationship, and beautifully explained what Imarti meant to express in that letter.

Now we are at the present situation. There's two way she can go with this: Either she confronts HS and clearly communicates her feelings with him (which is the most logical and sane thing to do), or she leaves the house. I mean I understand why she decides to leave the house. HS hasn't talked to her or looked at her since the Imarti's incident. He's giving her the cold vibe. What is she supposed to do in that situation? Go up to him and confront him, sure yes but she's not Imarti or Mini (who would have done that), she's Babita and she reacts and responds to situations differently than how Imarti would have. Is she just suppose to stay at the Haveli as a tenant, when she knows that she "loves" the landlord and when she feels that this relationship will not go anywhere... what is she supposed to do just stay there and be miserable everyday? So, I totally understand why she wants to leave the Haveli.

At this point, I am not understanding what Hanuman wants? Does he even like Babita anymore, does he wanna be with her and continue this relationship, or does he just wanna have a relationship as a tenant and landlord and co-parents to Mini? Its super confusing for him as well I am sure, but he needs to make a decision, like how Babita is finally making a decision to leave and move on from him (in her head obviously, we know she will come back to him), but for now she's made a decision and whatever it is, it is her decision.


My opinion. No offense meant ✌️

I second u dear...

Same thoughts came into my mind after seeing the precap....

Even I thought the same that he is cold towards her... And when we see Al those moments they shared I felt that if he loved her so. Much why is he d oh no this to her and himself this... Everytime they fought or said anything wrong he always spoke to him he don't do like this... So Babita reacting this way is nothing wrong when u see it like a woman... No woman can take a word on her character...

This is what I expected the day after his harsh words but she went after the truth of imarti Case... But it's not late... Babita has taken a stand for her self-respect I respect that... Bcoz HS still says that he can't make. Any relationship with the mother of his daughter then whats the use of her sticking back to a man who don't want her in his life... That's what she did earlier also right(i not comparing Ashok and HS it's just the situation)

Now. Let's c what HS will. Do....

Cinnamon_Kisses thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

After understanding both Hanuman and Babita's struggle and feelings ... I think what they need is plenty amount of time

uknaik99 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

I completely agree with you, this move is not about Babita stupid ego (as few members described) but it is about her being a woman and her pride. It is not about Hanuman's few bitter words this is about her love.

If Hanuman was just Minnie hanuman uncle she would not any problem to stay there but Hanuman is the man she loves who is in love with his late wife, If Hanuman so much in love with Imarti why he even got close to Babita, it is not fair.

now Babita is wounded, it is time for her to move away and hanuman to realise how important Babita is in his life, it is time for a new love story, new promises and new life.

check my post which written even before this track started.

/forum/patiala-babes/5108382/babitas-next-move

sheeluneelu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Completely agree with lakshs n loveinautumn.. I also think the same..

Babita supported HS though she was very hurt but I doubt HS ko idea bhi h usne kitna hurt kiya h babita ko..i think usse ab tak realisation bhi nhi h.. I know he will apologize soon.. I want my old HS back.

guddi01 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

But she is seriously flawed character look at the amount of times she has given him signs and than flip and flops. She has done him wrong many times and been rude and questioned his intentions prime example with the Camera and after it was sorted did not even have the guts to apologize even once but HS turned the tables on her so that she could not get away with it again.

The position where she is at today is mainly due to HS, he has had to hit a nerve for her to move forward this is seen many times from there talks etc.

He says one mean thing to her during his Court Case and her ego gets hurt, than its suddenly a woman thing etc.

But when Nayeem Be says the truth to her she storms off and gets a house, and does not want to listen at all. Here I think she is going to be taken for a ride and has she been protected by HS and as she is his tenant no one has stepped out of line in respecting her etc, she is looking through rose tinted glasses and is going to get a shock when She takes Mini in the big bad world.

She has been neglecting her business even before this drama started and HS did tell her to concentrate on it and Mini, was mentioned for a reason as she has taken a back seat in her Business which is a 1st mistake but she has got too confident as things have fallen in her lap. Lets see how she survives now. If it was not for HS looking after Mini, I don't know how Mini would have turned out.

Her Catering and Internet Shows are not going to make her Rich the way her business is going, prime example is the cooking which she is supposed to do but does not do anymore and also her running costs and rent if the shop are going to cripple her. Let reality start for her now.

Also not getting good vibes about this new lady, who I take it will be her friend, who I think is going to distance her from HS and drag her into a mess or scam her and this time HS will not be able to help her and why should he..

Welcome Babes to the big world now.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".