Qarz E Jaan (HUM) #3 - Usama Khan, Nameer Khan, Yumna Zaidi - Page 129

Originally posted by: Virgo27

Nashwa's response was totally justified because she is too sensitive about her mother. Burhan should have talked to Nashwa first before sharing this plan with Faryal.

I think the way Faryal presented it to Nashwa played a role in getting her hurt! Faryal said "hum dono ne ek baat socha hai... Us mein tumhaari madad chaahiye!" It sounded as if Nashwa was the outsider, there!

Nashwa has a strong bond only with Bisma, and Bisma is the world to her for whom she lives her life! All she wants is to give Bisma all the khushiyaan and sukoon she very much deserve but is deprived of all her life!

The way Nashwa keeps hugging Bisma, it feels like that's the only place Nashwa belong!

And Faryal was talking about the marriage of that world of her and she felt like a stranger/outsider! This could have really triggered her big time! She is very well justified about reacting the way she did!

But

What Nashwa told was very insensitive, that "how can you decide this? you're not even related to Asim uncle!" The adopted children might already have thoughts like if they really belong to the parent(s) who adopted them!

From how she defended Burhan in front of Ammar we know how aware she's of Burhan's ethics & righteousness! She knew he did all that for Asim, like buying their own house from the people who snatched it!

Nashwa being pissed about Burhan's closeness to Faryal also came out in one of the things she said like "she knew your reality before I did" which Burhan really got, isn't that why he smiles in his study at night?

I take it as Burhan was wrong to make Faryal talk about it instead of directly telling Nashwa(since he never had any problem communicating other things with her), Faryal's way of saying it as if it was all decided made it worse for Nashwa & Nashwa questioning Burhan's importance in Asim's life was insensitive!

https://x.com/coralwarmth/status/1888845524666613961?t=9MWcrpi4odW1eznVHny9gw&s=19

This is very interesting thread.

I really liked faryal's mother's all interactions and I like how the women in this drama are not shown negative, barring of course the dadi, who IMO is the main villian.

Nashwa has a lot of complexes and she's very possessive about her mother, so her outburst seemed justified. But I'm hoping after calming down she'll be on board.

Next week promo seems exciting, but I'm hating the idea of her marrying Ammar.

I like that they are showing burhan's attraction towards nashwa in subtle way. I don't watch smd or any other shows of usama. So don't have problem with his portrayal.

There are a few flaws in this show and one major flaw which is going to come up:

First of all, why was Bisma mother obligated to Barkhat. Why didn't Asim and Beejaan help Bisma and her mother financially. Even Asim was very well off.

2nd Why did Burhan pay such a heavy price to buy Sabreen Villa when that house belonged to Asim only. He is bloody Barrister, why didn't he fight in the court. They could have easily won the case and put even a fraud case against Bakhtiyar for illegaly trying to sell the house. Uff Burhan is such a dumb character

3rd Assuming Nashwa will get Married to Ammar so that Bisma can marry Asim, but why? Bisma is an adult and a widow and even Nashwa is an adult now . Even as per religion, she is entitled to get remarried. They cannot trade Nashwa for Bisma. Why can't bisma and Nashwa just leave that house and later Bisma and ASIM can get married and Nashwa can move in with her mother to sabreen villa. They dont need anyone permission to get Asim and Bisma married. Bakhtiyar and Barkhat dadi have taken Nashwa rights too by not giving Behzaad earnings to them. She can fight for that too. She doesn't have to be obligated to Bakhtiyar for taking care of her. I really cannot find any logic behind her marrying Ammar.

Now I feel Nashwa is Going to defend Ammar and Burhan will fight against him. Because in the OST, Nashwa is going with Ammar to investigate something in his car.

Originally posted by: pilot100

There are a few flaws in this show and one major flaw which is going to come up:

First of all, why was Bisma mother obligated to Barkhat. Why didn't Asim and Beejaan help Bisma and her mother financially. Even Asim was very well off.

2nd Why did Burhan pay such a heavy price to buy Sabreen Villa when that house belonged to Asim only. He is bloody Barrister, why didn't he fight in the court. They could have easily won the case and put even a fraud case against Bakhtiyar for illegaly trying to sell the house. Uff Burhan is such a dumb character

3rd Assuming Nashwa will get Married to Ammar so that Bisma can marry Asim, but why? Bisma is an adult and a widow and even Nashwa is an adult now . Even as per religion, she is entitled to get remarried. They cannot trade Nashwa for Bisma. Why can't bisma and Nashwa just leave that house and later Bisma and ASIM can get married and Nashwa can move in with her mother to sabreen villa. They dont need anyone permission to get Asim and Bisma married. Bakhtiyar and Barkhat dadi have taken Nashwa rights too by not giving Behzaad earnings to them. She can fight for that too. She doesn't have to be obligated to Bakhtiyar for taking care of her. I really cannot find any logic behind her marrying Ammar.

Now I feel Nashwa is Going to defend Ammar and Burhan will fight against him. Because in the OST, Nashwa is going with Ammar to investigate something in his car.

1) I think they will explain first point later or it might be writing flaw.

2) I think we are supposed to think bakthiyar is dangerous man. I don't think asim himself wants to get his property by fighting so burhan might have choosen this way.

3) This is what we are yet to see. I can get why nashwa wants to agree for marrying ammar to give better life for her mother. But I don't think asim and bisma deserve such sacrifice. They both are cowards. They rubbing it off to their children too instead of empowering them. I would be so disappointed at them if they let nashwa marry ammar for whatever reason.

Nashwa defending ammar against burhan never gonna happen. Because in promos, nashwa says she will punish the person even if he is her husband. There is no reason for her to defend ammar even if she marries him. Ammar in those teasers looked guilty so different from current version of him, so there is a possibility that he realised his crime sort of redemption. There is a bts where he was arrested and taken to court. I hope he gets punished.

Originally posted by: pilot100

There are a few flaws in this show and one major flaw which is going to come up:

First of all, why was Bisma mother obligated to Barkhat. Why didn't Asim and Beejaan help Bisma and her mother financially. Even Asim was very well off.

2nd Why did Burhan pay such a heavy price to buy Sabreen Villa when that house belonged to Asim only. He is bloody Barrister, why didn't he fight in the court. They could have easily won the case and put even a fraud case against Bakhtiyar for illegaly trying to sell the house. Uff Burhan is such a dumb character

3rd Assuming Nashwa will get Married to Ammar so that Bisma can marry Asim, but why? Bisma is an adult and a widow and even Nashwa is an adult now . Even as per religion, she is entitled to get remarried. They cannot trade Nashwa for Bisma. Why can't bisma and Nashwa just leave that house and later Bisma and ASIM can get married and Nashwa can move in with her mother to sabreen villa. They dont need anyone permission to get Asim and Bisma married. Bakhtiyar and Barkhat dadi have taken Nashwa rights too by not giving Behzaad earnings to them. She can fight for that too. She doesn't have to be obligated to Bakhtiyar for taking care of her. I really cannot find any logic behind her marrying Ammar.

Now I feel Nashwa is Going to defend Ammar and Burhan will fight against him. Because in the OST, Nashwa is going with Ammar to investigate something in his car.

I also had these questions but now as the backstory is getting revealed bit by bit, I have this theory. It seems like Asim's father died very early maybe when Asim was just a kid. Bakhtiyar's father was still alive and he was the elder of the house. After Asim's father's death, Bakhtiyar's father (and then Bakhtiyar) were running the business. Asim was not independent by that time. He was studying (as he is not that older than Bisma, so if Bisma was in matric or inter at that time then that makes Asim still in the age group where he must still be studying). I don't think Asim had a control of his father's assets or accounts and for that matter Sabreena also I think did not have the control of her husband's wealth. Though I think Asim has/had the details and knowledge about the wealth and accounts but not much beyond that. I think it was being managed by Bakhtiyar's father. That is why Sabreena and Asim couldn't help Bisma's mom and Barkat being the lady of the house was helping Bisma's mom even after the death of Bakhtiyar's father.

I think Sabreena and Asim were in the same situation as Bisma and Nashwa are now. Nashwa's father was also supposedly wealthy and had money (family business and what not) but all of that is being controlled by Dado and Bakhtiyar. I think same might have happened to Sabreena and Asim after Asim's father's death. Bakhtiyar's father must have been managing the accounts and everything related to Asim's father's wealth.

But I am still a bit confused about the house. I want to know the timeline when the two houses were built. It seems like Sabreen villa was the old house built by Asim's father and Barkat villa was built later. If that is the case then everyone was living in Sabreen villa.

Otherwise, another theory is that the 2 houses were built at the same time or with negligible time difference (negligible as in grand scheme of things). Bakhtiyar and his family were living in Barkat villa and Sabreen and Asim were living in Sabreen villa. But then Asim and Sabreen left and Bakhtiyar got hold of the house. My assumption is that Asim and Sabreen were not kicked out of the house but as Asim mentioned that he couldn't endure living so close to Bisma and not being together so he left and at that time then Bakhtiyar's family got control of the house.

My emphasis in knowing the timeline is because I want to establish whether Barkat and her family were in any form or shape dependent on Asim's father or not i.e. was Asim's father richer than Bakhtiayar's. Was it his business and house actually? If it was Asim's father's business and house and Bakhtiyar's father got hold of it then that makes him a culprit as well but according to Nashwa's Nani, Bakhtiayar's father wasn't actually bad.

I would like the story to dig a bit deeper into the past events. The dynamics are quite interesting to be honest.

1) I think they will explain first point later or it might be writing flaw.

2) I think we are supposed to think bakthiyar is dangerous man. I don't think asim himself wants to get his property by fighting so burhan might have choosen this way.

So does that mean Asim was scared of Bakhtiyar and is even now scared. Why would anyone want to give up their rights? Property is a big amount.

Also my question is why didn't Burhan not fight in the court instead of straight away buying the house.

3) This is what we are yet to see. I can get why nashwa wants to agree for marrying ammar to give better life for her mother. But I don't think asim and bisma deserve such sacrifice. They both are cowards. They rubbing it off to their children too instead of empowering them. I would be so disappointed at them if they let nashwa marry ammar for whatever reason.

Again, why does Nashwa need to sacrifice for Bisma happiness. Why do they need permission of Dadi and Bakhtiyar to get bisma remarried?

Nashwa defending ammar against burhan never gonna happen. Because in promos, nashwa says she will punish the person even if he is her husband. There is no reason for her to defend ammar even if she marries him. Ammar in those teasers looked guilty so different from current version of him, so there is a possibility that he realised his crime sort of redemption. There is a bts where he was arrested and taken to court. I hope he gets punished.

But Nameer is saying Ammar is not a villain. He is Just a confused character who has his own battles. I feel he is innocent and will come out clean and He and Nashwa will live happily. I really hope he turns out to be innocent because I don't want Nashwa to be married to a criminal and go through hell. It's better he redeems himself and they end up together. I guess whoever side Nashwa is, that will be the story. Because they will never show yumna losing the case. So if she is against Ammar, then he is guilty and if she is defending him,then he is innocent.

Too many questions and too long a wait

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

Burhan's intentions is not wrong but his approach is.

He doesn't need to be known about nashwa and her mother's bond to think that he should discuss with nashwa first who is bisma's daughter not faryal who is no where related to his father or nashwa's mother.

It's not about how many hours passed. It's the fact that he didn't think of discussing such sensitive matter about her mother to her first.

https://x.com/Lakhi7777/status/1888902427400880494?t=768TMDieOUfRO82CNEJh1w&s=19

Look at their tone and body language. The way they informed "their decision" about her own mother to her. It didn't look they are trying to convince her, they are telling their decision about her mother.

Nashwa is intern to burhan. He is her senior. So she can't act friendly with him like faryal. That would be unprofessional. She doesn't need to act friendly or approachable for burhan to discuss her own mother with her first.

Hard agree. Burhan and Faryal were so out of line for this! I really felt Nashwa’s fury and what she said Burhan totally deserved. This is her MOM ffs. There’s years of backstory and suffering that has to be accounted for before one even goes into hitching Bisma and Asim and the fact that he was gossiping about it with Faryal was really