Originally posted by: starstruckk
In "my personal opinion" Mora Piya was weak sauce because it was not presented the way it COULD HAVE been presented. Lack of direction, cringeworthy acting, a drag-fest, and the list goes on.
Pani Jaisa's Pyar's basic concept is the same old romance? really?
@bold: wait.. you're giving your feedback on the ENTIRE show based upon ONE episode that you watched of Pani Jaisa Pyar? 😆 you didn't even watch the entire show..your opinion on the show means absolutely zilch here because you didn't watch it. I don't think an intellectually advanced person would give an opinion on something they're completely oblivious about?.don't you think?
Moreover, you need more than just a plot to grab people's attention. I'm not sure if you just solely look for the story in a show? but I'm sorry, I like to watch the show in its entirety. No where did anyone say that Mora Piya's story sucked..and you're emphasizing only on its storyline. The performances except for Aamina's were nothing to write home about, the direction could've been way better..the story dragged and that in my books does not equal a great show. If it does in your books..then that's great to know. And, if you ACTUALLY watched PJP..then newsflash: it revolved around the same concept of rape and the aftermath of it.
Credited or not credited..it doesn't take away from the fact that Pani Jaisa Pyar is one of Hum's best shows in recent times..Sarmad's breakthrough show as a director which led him to take on Humsafar..one of Saba Qamar's best performances and the show as a whole was illustrated way better than many shows that tackle rape and the circumstances it can lead to. And, it's funny how you take pleasure in people trashing a drama that you have no clue about. 😆
I think we've just given intellectual advancement a new meaning today.
Well you getting all worked up over criticism of Pani Jaisa Pyaar actually proves one point over here and that is "People do take their choices seriously" and they do get pissed off if a show of their liking is criticized unjustly in their opinion.
And yes I am giving my opinion over a whole show by watching one episode because this is what people do, yes intellectually advanced people as well because intellectually advanced people come to know that the show is not worth the watch by just watching one episode and knowing about the concept. They do not keep on watching the show even if they do not like it. 😆 I mean this is what "using your brains means".
Once again YOUR OPINION on a show does not make a show a failure neither YOUR OPINION makes a show good or bad. Neither YOUR OPINION makes a show best ever show and the show that got the director fame and all. It is all in your head.This thread was created to provide suggestions for the shows that people think are good shows and I being a member of this forum provided my opinion that thread starter should watch Mora Piya that I THINK is good. I am not hell bent on criticizing other people's choices over here. I think people need to grow up a bit.
As far as the direction/acting/production of Mora Piya goes, there are many people who think that acting in Mora Piya was really good, direction was very realistic and simplistic and production value was good.
http://www.dramasonline.com/mora-piya-ended/
You do not like my getting excited over a show trashing but you on the other hand is exactly doing the same thing that is wasting your energies on trashing a show. I do not know whether Intellectually advanced got the new meaning or not but yes "hypocrisy" here definitely got the new meaning.
And you SHOULD care about when someone's work gets stolen and not credited because that alone is enough to take away all the credibility of the creators of "charba product". That work SHOULD not give them a way to become a great director or producer or script writer or whatever you claimed and that is not my personal opinion that is the basic moral value.
731