I think I'll have to stick to the self-given explanation that they couldn't handle it properly.
Because I'll be honest here, Nazar is dear to me because of PiyAnsh even when I was interested in Dayaan. Ultimately they couldn't handle majority of the tracks but the pure and unconditional love between PiyAnsh makes it different.
RuAnsh marriage was inevitable in a sense because they had to bring Mo out. But Ansh berating Ruby should have taken place before him gatecrashing PiMan's wedding. Because on one hand you are saying, you want to honor your marriage but on the other hand you are ogling another girl, even though you want to protect her from a creep. So where does that leave you?
If it were in my hand, I would have definitely choosen the way that Ruby's truth would come in front everyone, Ansh would end his ties and probably with some Dayaan rituals so we wouldn't have to bother about technicality and then MoRu cursing Ved to turn into a statue. In that way, Ansh ogling Piya wouldn't look cheap.
But they made a weird Khichdi. I guess that's the reason I didn't have any sort of attachment back then because there's Zameen-Asmaan ka fark between reading WU and watching an episode. And binge watching couldn't make it logical then understand my condition when I was reading it and had no idea about the intensity. 🤔
That's why I keep saying Episode 211 was the beginning of my attachment. By that time I had completed YMMKD and became a fan of Niyati so I was rather easily hooked.
As for fan's theory, all of us can come up with many theories when it includes our favorites.
As you know, I am a fan of Sana also. So I did watch Perfect Pati for a couple of months when she had entered. Even though I hated the romantic track between Kabir and Vidhita, somewhere, I did come up with a theory that why out of all people Kabir had fallen for Vidhita?
The acting was amazzing, Pushkar-Vidhita-Kabir in one frame was a total bomb but a story that was thusofied on our faces and I came up with an explanation.
So fans' theory has a dimension of its own. 😆 😆 😆
But what I don't like is that some of the fans go on pointing everything negative to justify their favorites. I mean Ruby could be positive but no way in hell, Piya would be a barrier to that. So why dragging her just because you want RuAnsh?
Yes, even I liked Ruby in the beginning but later she made no sense and Sonya too didn't shine like she used to in the initial episodes. Again, blaming it on the script.