purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Imagine a situation where in spite of giving your best -- you are constantly being disregarded compared to one particular pair, or other pairs. Imagine a situation where lesser performances take 33 scores, whereas your performances are seen with a microscope, and your marks are cut because you are a threat.

Imagine a situation where in spite of dancing superbly, emoting excellently, you are being told you are not the winners ... they are ... they! ... pointing them out!

😭😭

What will this do to the morale of any participant on NACH --- even a super talented one. 😭

Imagine a situation where you are in a competition and are giving it your sweat and blood -- but the winners are already declared ... and in every episode of the competition --- not once or twice, but in every episode.

Edited by purethought - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.9k

Users

4

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

bangles thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Then the whole show would be a farce isn't it? - which is what NB6 has turned into!

SP still don't get it- they want to continue with the 'someone' who is very toxic to most participants in the name of humour and entertainment!

purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: bangles

Then the whole show would be a farce isn't it? - which is what NB6 has turned into!

SP still don't get it- they want to continue with the 'someone' who is very toxic to most participants in the name of humour and entertainment!



Actually I don't have anything against the judge ... he is doing this because he has the freedom to do it. Although I like his humor and entertainment. It is fun. But not favoritism please. I think a "judge" should always be neutral and take decisions based on the performance on the day!😕

THE TEAM OF NB needs to take care of this. They are the ones managing the entire show.

Where is the surprise element in this? why are the winners being declared in every episode?

what about other dance shows ... this never happens there, then why NB?
Edited by purethought - 11 years ago
songcouple thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
take a chill pill now listen go and vote for our dearies ashviq ...
i knowi t was bad ...
but cant small small failures pave way to big big success...
i know we are all upset but we will take the competation to a new level the more they degrade us the more we force them to look at us and say we salute you
did you see the look of adoration and admiration in eyes of shilpa ,sajid,and terrance ...when they performed aerial act
that shows ashviq are true winners
i havent seen that look for anybody elses performance ...
did you see the tears in shilpas and terrance eyes in any other couples performance
even their emotions mirrored each other
all of these deserved 33 and fans love ...
we will make them win ...
🤗
now on we will vote better okay
purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: kannansangee

take a chill pill now listen go and vote for our dearies ashviq ...

i knowi t was bad ...
but cant small small failures pave way to big big success...
i know we are all upset but we will take the competation to a new level the more they degrade us the more we force them to look at us and say we salute you
did you see the look of adoration and admiration in eyes of shilpa ,sajid,and terrance ...when they performed aerial act
that shows ashviq are true winners
i havent seen that look for anybody elses performance ...
did you see the tears in shilpas and terrance eyes in any other couples performance
even their emotions mirrored each other
all of these deserved 33 and fans love ...
we will make them win ...
🤗
now on we will vote better okay



As a fan of ASHVIK ... it is paining me to see, that in spite of their awesome performances, they are being told -- you are lesser than the winners. I do not accept this as a fan. 😭 I cannot take a chill pill.

but yes😳 thanks for the kind words of re-assurance.

bangles thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: purethought

[BR][BR]Actually I don't have anything against the judge ... he is doing this because he has the freedom to do it. Although I like his humor and entertainment. It is fun. But not favoritism please. I think a "judge" should always be neutral and take decisions based on the performance on the day![:s][BR][BR]THE TEAM OF NB needs to take care of this. They are the ones managing the entire show. [BR][BR]Where is the surprise element in this? why are the winners being declared in every episode?[8(][BR][BR]what about other dance shows ... this never happens there, then why NB?[8(][BR]



This particular judge does/ says what he pleases because no one seems to have defined the remits of 'judging' to him. Not the NB production team and not SP.

Yes, he is very spontaneous and witty. But this does not compensate for poor judging. He can have his view of the participants'' performances. The way he delivers it reeks of bias. No neutrality in sight at all.

As for the participants, all have had their ups and downs in their performances- I am a neutral viewer who watches the programme with the hope of watching some good performances. My viewing pleasure gets affected by the very obviously biased comments that follow delivered in a very non- judge like fashion.
purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: bangles



This particular judge does/ says what he pleases because no one seems to have defined the remits of 'judging' to him. Not the NB production team and not SP.

Yes, he is very spontaneous and witty. But this does not compensate for poor judging. He can have his view of the participants'' performances. The way he delivers it reeks of bias. No neutrality in sight at all.

As for the participants, all have had their ups and downs in their performances- I am a neutral viewer who watches the programme with the hope of watching some good performances. My viewing pleasure gets affected by the very obviously biased comments that follow delivered in a very non- judge like fashion.



I agree with in bold.

Yes, I always like judges being neutral, and even if my favorites make a mistake, I will accept the judge's verdict. But without neutrality, even I can't sit through the comments. because I know what's coming.
Edited by purethought - 11 years ago
songcouple thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: purethought



As a fan of ASHVIK ... it is paining me to see, that in spite of their awesome performances, they are being told -- you are lesser than the winners. I do not accept this as a fan. 😭 I cannot take a chill pill.

but yes😳 thanks for the kind words of re-assurance.

i am also their fan ...
remember that day you consoled me when i felt bad about sajid ki judjegiri ...
today even i felt bad ...
but i personally feel their should be atleast one low point in dancing or anything for a winner to realize that now he has to give his two hundread percent along with using his banastra...
till now we havent seen rithviqs treadmill energetic performance which makes judges raise from their seat and automatically give standing ovation ...
i feel it time now for rithviq to dance in his level as asha has improved by leaps and bounds
purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kannansangee

i am also their fan ...
remember that day you consoled me when i felt bad about sajid ki judjegiri ...
today even i felt bad ...
but i personally feel their should be atleast one low point in dancing or anything for a winner to realize that now he has to give his two hundread percent along with using his banastra...
till now we havent seen rithviqs treadmill energetic performance which makes judges raise from their seat and automatically give standing ovation ...
i feel it time now for rithviq to dance in his level as asha has improved by leaps and bounds



yes I remember😛
well said😳👏 in bold

They should now really raise the bar! cannot give a chance to anyone to put them down!
songcouple thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: purethought



yes I remember😛
well said😳👏 in bold

They should now really raise the bar! cannot give a chance to anyone to put them down!

they have raised the bar for all other contestants i think except for may be vinod (who has physical disability and each performance itself deserves a standing ovation )
so now they just need to raise the bar of them selves

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".