Coordination - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

4.9k

Users

22

Frequent Posters

Sharad K. rocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#21

I'm not trying to say that my fav. jodi is the best, I'm only saying that all the jodis should be judged fairly. Yes Shaljit are great, but when they make co-ordination mistakes the judges should mark them down like they do to the other jodis.

dumbledore1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Sharad K. rocks

I'm not trying to say that my fav. jodi is the best, I'm only saying that all the jodis should be judged fairly. Yes Shaljit are great, but when they make co-ordination mistakes the judges should mark them down like they do to the other jodis.



Okay they did one mistake it was shown, so they should get 9 marks for that. So if a jodi makes 10 mistakes, should they get 0 marks?😆 Considering everything the marks are given. I have seen others making way more co-ordination mistakes but still getting 9. That mistake was not big enough to take anything away from their well deserved 30 for that extraordinary performance.

And did you see NB this week? They were marked down for the exact same reason. Otherwise they could have gotten 30 again.
Edited by dumbledore1 - 16 years ago
TSharan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Sharad K. rocks

I'm not trying to say that my fav. jodi is the best, I'm only saying that all the jodis should be judged fairly. Yes Shaljit are great, but when they make co-ordination mistakes the judges should mark them down like they do to the other jodis.

I agree with you completely.....
Nisha_07 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#24
Well judging by it's very definition is going to be subjective. There are no rules as such - for 1 big mistake, minus 1 mark, for 10 small mistakes minues 1 mark etc etc.

I think there have been times when performances by Naman/Megha and Sudeep/Anantika have been judged too harshly. I appreciate though that it must be hard to give marks straight away - I wonder if it would almost be better to see all the performances first and then give marks, and also give the judges the chance to be consistent in their comments. I think it's the lack of consistency that viewers find hard to digest.
chinky801 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#25
Dear waterlilly,

If u have so much knowledge of dance and u think repeating of dance concepts are not great, then plz show me why ur favorite jodis haven't shown that kind of progress from the begining. In 1st week, If I remember most of them even didn't know dance... Ok, this is a dance competion not a dance learning platform, that everyweek u will learn and perform,Then u should support Reshmi-Amit, because they did improve from last week,right??
Common talk like a mature person, not just to bash Shaleen and Daljit, u will write anything. They are not making mistakes that the other jodis are making.. That's a fact and tehy will also go down in the history of NB as the hatric 30s winner till somebody else will surprass them.. And when it comes to judges, I don;'t think any of us are having neither teh knowledge nor the caliber to crtisize either any of them... so plz stop just writing bad things about judges
chinky801 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#26
One more thing I would also like to mention, repeating dance concepts from previous season, who is not doing that. The mirror refelction dance is also not original . If I remember Srijal and Sneha had did that dance in previous dance competion .. The rajastani dance is also been Aja mahi vay comepetion.. So what's new about it?? It's not unfair to copy a dance form, but it's definitely unfair not to execute it right....
Sharad K. rocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: dumbledore1



Okay they did one mistake it was shown, so they should get 9 marks for that. So if a jodi makes 10 mistakes, should they get 0 marks?😆 Considering everything the marks are given. I have seen others making way more co-ordination mistakes but still getting 9. That mistake was not big enough to take anything away from their well deserved 30 for that extraordinary performance.

And did you see NB this week? They were marked down for the exact same reason. Otherwise they could have gotten 30 again.

If we go by what you are saying, then last week Naman-Megha would of gotten a 30 and this week Kanjali would of gotten a 30 because the performances were extraordinary. Also, Mauli-Mazher would of gotten 30s for their extraordinary performances.
Edited by Sharad K. rocks - 16 years ago
evonora thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: dumbledore1



Oh not again, concentrate on the dance. Tell me who did Tap dance? Can your favourite jodi do it? Going by your theory, you would even say salsa is also a knock off just because it had been performed already by someone. The choreography is different. Even I have seen people lifting up their 'lighter' partners in circus that means a certain dance was also a knock off.😆 Learn to appreciate the hard work. Atleast some jodi is trying to try various dance forms instead of doing the same thing over and over again.

Chill...I am saying in general....!!!! nobody is after nobody here...wat I saw I mentioned..I understand that ppl have favs...seems like something hit home..but I wasnt pointing fingers at anyone😉...!!!!!!!!

Edited by waterlilly - 16 years ago
evonora thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: t2004sachin

Dear waterlilly,

If u have so much knowledge of dance and u think repeating of dance concepts are not great, then plz show me why ur favorite jodis haven't shown that kind of progress from the begining. In 1st week, If I remember most of them even didn't know dance... Ok, this is a dance competion not a dance learning platform, that everyweek u will learn and perform,Then u should support Reshmi-Amit, because they did improve from last week,right??
Common talk like a mature person, not just to bash Shaleen and Daljit, u will write anything. They are not making mistakes that the other jodis are making.. That's a fact and tehy will also go down in the history of NB as the hatric 30s winner till somebody else will surprass them.. And when it comes to judges, I don;'t think any of us are having neither teh knowledge nor the caliber to crtisize either any of them... so plz stop just writing bad things about judges

Dude relex..dont get so touchy... and no need to get so personal...I was stating wat I thought..my pov is important just as much as urs...!!!!

Please don't tell me who I should support....I will support who I think is worthy...

And in regards to the judges..that is my pov....and if u didn't like it ..then skip over it..and don't get involved in that discussion..

I am not here to argue..just to have a stimulating discussion, and if ur thought process is not aliened with mine..please feel free to skip over my comment...

No one is perfect...its a learning curve for most of the jodi's...they are working hard to provide us with good entertainment....

And we like the ones we do....!! so lets all chill and enjoy the show ..k

dumbledore1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Sharad K. rocks

If we go by what you are saying, then last week Naman-Megha would of gotten a 30 and this week Kanjali would of gotten a 30 because the performances were extraordinary. Also, Mauli-Mazher would of gotten 30s for their extraordinary performances.



Who are we to judge who is extraordinary? They have experts employed for that purpose. Atleast Farah Khan is a qualified enough judge. All the jodis started as equals in Nach Baliye. Some just rose above others solely based on their dancing skills and impressed the judges.Whats your problem now anyways? They didn't get a 30 this week for their mistakes.

I think its just frustration on other jodi's fans part that is making them create such topics against Shaljit - whose only mistake is to perform so well each week.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".