Sharad K. rocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
The judges always talk about Naman-Megha's co-ordination problems and they cut points, but when Shaljit had co-ordination problems in dola re they got a 30. Naman-Megha deserved at least a 29 or 30. Also, even though I am not a big Kanjali fan, I think that they deserved a 30.
Judges really need to stop being bias, especially when it comes to Naman-Megha and Kanjali vs. Shaljit.
I don't mean to offend any Shaljit fans

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

4.9k

Users

22

Frequent Posters

AbhiAni thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

in any show (esp reality shows) judges will have some favorites..(i am not saying it is wrong), but it shouldn't reach to a point where it becomes obvious that they are biased and they are the one who said we should have respect for the stage😕

monu_tan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Actually I agree to this completely.. They are defo being biased and its visible completely.. They gave 9 to everybody in Friday episode..So its like Kanjali's performance was as bad or good as say Sudeep Avantika and vice versa.. Looks like they have a strategy against some jodi.. One reason why we dont go by their scores..
scorpiorule thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Sharad K. rocks

The judges always talk about Naman-Megha's co-ordination problems and they cut points, but when Shaljit had co-ordination problems in dola re they got a 30. Naman-Megha deserved at least a 29 or 30. Also, even though I am not a big Kanjali fan, I think that they deserved a 30.

Judges really need to stop being bias, especially when it comes to Naman-Megha and Kanjali vs. Shaljit.
I don't mean to offend any Shaljit fans

Excellent Topic. I agree with everything...I have a feeling if they can't give it to Shaleen Daljit...then they can't give it to anyone...That's wrong....
chinky801 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
There was 1% co-ordination problems in Dola re dola, where as in Naman megha and kanjali's performances the co-ordination problem was so obvious that the mark should be cut-down. And more importantly Naman megha were doing a mirron refection, which is spell bound to be perfect till 100%.. any failure is not justifying their act itself.. Plz don't always compare Shaljit to somebody or everybody. The judges are not partial nor they are blind, I would rather put it like this they are the most intelligent ones where it comes to judging, as u can see from re-cap how farha was pointing small small mistakes of Naman and megha , similarly she also prasied small small thing for Kapil like his sholder movement and all..
dumbledore1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: t2004sachin

There was 1% co-ordination problems in Dola re dola, where as in Naman megha and kanjali's performances the co-ordination problem was so obvious that the mark should be cut-down. And more importantly Naman megha were doing a mirron refection, which is spell bound to be perfect till 100%.. any failure is not justifying their act itself.. Plz don't always compare Shaljit to somebody or everybody. The judges are not partial nor they are blind, I would rather put it like this they are the most intelligent ones where it comes to judging, as u can see from re-cap how farha was pointing small small mistakes of Naman and megha , similarly she also prasied small small thing for Kapil like his sholder movement and all..



Well said. Don't question their judging. Shaleen Daljit are not paying them to favour them. All the jodis stand an equal chance to impress the judges.
monu_tan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Well nobody can deny that in reality shows judges do have their favorites.. and they do support them without it being so evident.. The only thing is this time this was clearly visible.. Atleast I as a viewer fail to understand how can you give a 9 for a Sudeep Avantika performance then the same marks for Naman Megha and then the same to Kanjali and of course the same to Shaleen DJ. As a viewer for me their performances were at different levels and not at same level.. Anyways the coordination problems are real tricky things. Some will say i saw it as 1% some will say that was 10%..
dumbledore1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: monu1101

Well nobody can deny that in reality shows judges do have their favorites.. and they do support them without it being so evident.. The only thing is this time this was clearly visible.. Atleast I as a viewer fail to understand how can you give a 9 for a Sudeep Avantika performance then the same marks for Naman Megha and then the same to Kanjali and of course the same to Shaleen DJ. As a viewer for me their performances were at different levels and not at same level.. Anyways the coordination problems are real tricky things. Some will say i saw it as 1% some will say that was 10%..



Sudeep-Anantika's and Naman Megha's performances were of the same level, one had more dance with obvious concept the other had innovative concept with less dance. Kapil Anjali's performance was slightly better only because of their shoulder supporting act so for that they did get more marks. The dance had a lot of repetitive steps. Even I am a viewer, and I completely agreed with the scores. Its all a matter of who you prefer to support. This debate will be never-ending.
Edited by dumbledore1 - 16 years ago
monu_tan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Well for me as a viewer of all NB's the act performed by Kanjali was the most innovative as well as the most unique thing done in all NB seasons..Ppl actually hooked up to their tv sets coz they saw something unique which was never done by anyone in any of the 3 seasons before.. And since it is a folk dance of course you have to takes steps of folk dance and cant put innovative steps there..Coordination mistakes well I was trying to find out in the Kanjali performance and i would hardly rate that 0.05%.. Even non NB viewers sitting next to me that day started laughing that these judges made such a hue and cry of Kanjali performance but they dint give them the perfect marks citing weird reasons..So this times the judges are exposed to public by their great 'No Coordination' reason..Some ppl see it and accept it and some ppl will not do that..But atleast we know the bias judges had..
Riya.pk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: t2004sachin

There was 1% co-ordination problems in Dola re dola, where as in Naman megha and kanjali's performances the co-ordination problem was so obvious that the mark should be cut-down. And more importantly Naman megha were doing a mirron refection, which is spell bound to be perfect till 100%.. any failure is not justifying their act itself.. Plz don't always compare Shaljit to somebody or everybody. The judges are not partial nor they are blind, I would rather put it like this they are the most intelligent ones where it comes to judging, as u can see from re-cap how farha was pointing small small mistakes of Naman and megha , similarly she also prasied small small thing for Kapil like his sholder movement and all..



I totally agree with you... I think you feel that Naman and Mehga deserved a 30 because they simply did something different from what they usually do.. but when you're doinga mirror act there has to be perfect coordination or else it's not a mirror act at all.

Shaljit always buff their performances to perfection that's just the difference.
Edited by riyapk - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".