Worst Judge - Page 8

Originally posted by: Deep08

In regds to Farah Khan,. yes she is a successful choregrapher, But this is NOT bollywood where the contestants are ONLY devoted to this show and nothing else. These people have 2-3 serials their working on as well as this. They have other "major" aka "bread and butter" obligations as well as this.....Plz dont take it as an excuse for them....but as a reality. Whatever time they have left over, they lack sleep and devote to dancing for this show. SO YES AS FOR SOME OF US, THEYRE TAKING THIS SHOW SERIOUSLY. Then again you will have the rest who will agree with these judges. But then they're those like us who see the truth in all.

Bollywood and Tellywood, are different, those stars are rolling in the high bucks, and can afford to devote all their time to that ONE film. Whereas this is just a dance show, also involving money, but reality, you can't ask the jodis to give more than necessary to this show, since their serials are more important to "pay" the bills. Farah Khan is used to bollywood stars bending toward her and devoting ALL their time to her and will do anything to make her happy...But she failed to realize the same thing is happening with these jodis and example in point are the injuries. These jodis are lacking sleep and all to appease her and the other judges....yet nothing....

We as well as the judges are basing everything on the best they can do. These people are NOT professional dancers and the judges are trying to turn them into that, that's wrong. This show should be dance as best as you can and with lacking history in dancing be judged/commented as such. Not to give bias scores to some; but to be unfair to the rest (point taken this friday with "strange" scores). Also not show somewhat dislike for a certain team versus another due to popularity.

As for some of the jodis showing facial expressions to farah and the other judges, heck why not; if farah can go off lacking professionalism 'all" the time, why not show signs of 'DISGUST" from the jodis. Hell I was getting SICK to death of listening to the degrading comments by Farah and the other "puppet" judges. Seems like they are afraid of farah so they follow her.

As I must say the same thing is continuing...They comment on one thing and then score differently...that confuses me as well.

Originally posted by: Deep08

[

In regds to Farah Khan,. yes she is a successful choregrapher, But this is NOT bollywood where the contestants are ONLY devoted to this show and nothing else. errmmm SRK is one star who farah choreographs who has the luxury of just one movie at a time especially his home production; but even he shot for some portions of kbc3 during the making of oso--may i add that songs are usually choreographed back in mumbai as was desi girl--it wasnt shot in miami and so John did have aashayein he was shooting for and abhi was shooting for dilli6 as well as perhaps shooting for or promoting drona--he wasnt oohh soo free to spend his entirreeeee day shooting just 3 lines from the desi girl song These people have 2-3 serials their working on as well as this.as far as i know kapil-anjali are just in one show(raja ki aayegi baaraat), as is daljeet; as is mohit; is reshmi even ina show--i think ksbkbt has stopped its shotos and reshmi is not in KYM as of now; what show is naman in; megha has one show; They have other "major" aka "bread and butter" obligations as well as this..and they knew this BEFORE they signed onto the dotted line for nb4...Plz dont take it as an excuse for them....but as a reality. did they not know that they had these shows..and farah has praised shaleen and daljit numerous times; as abhijeet-shilpa(which show do they have BTW??)Whatever time they have left over, they lack sleep and devote to dancing for this show. they knew what they were getting into when they signed the show; they knew they would have to practise and shoot for their showsSO YES AS FOR SOME OF US, THEYRE TAKING THIS SHOW SERIOUSLY. Then again you will have the rest who will agree with these judges. But then they're those like us who see the truth in all. hmmmmm really so the lot who sees truth in all isnt biased at all😕😕😕

Bollywood and Tellywood, are different, those stars are rolling in the high bucks, and can afford to devote all their time to that ONE film. yes i am sure abhishek told the dilli 6 dir and sonam K--please keep on waiting for me as i appease farah khan and shoot for desi girl until she okays my shot; as did John tell the YRF film director that he had to go to NY for--thats why these two are praised for being professionals--sure they r sooo freeeee and have no other movies to do except KJo's dostana and shoot for farah--little wonder then that even tho abhi needs to be promoting dostana he is shooting for mani's film in the jungles of kerala and falling ill BUT not making a hulabalooo; and giving 100001 intvws about how he has to be back to mumbai or giving excuses to mani R about his illness and how he just cannot shoot--despite being abhishek BACHCHAN...Whereas this is just a dance show, also involving money, but reality, you can't ask the jodis to give more than necessary to this show, since their serials are more important to "pay" the bills. they are not doing this show for free, progressing to the next episode means money as does winning the show Farah Khan is used to bollywood stars bending toward her and devoting ALL their time to her and will do anything to make her happy.sure that is why on KWK with srk, she was complaining that srk never answers his phone; is always relaxed when she is shouting; and heaven forbid that she screams at him during the making--the world will end coz he is soooooo free--he has nothing to do despite being at her beck and call; and i am sure priyanka chopra ignored her cover shoots; her fashion shoots and her other movies just to shoot for desi girl until farah khan okayed it😕😕😕But she failed to realize the same thing is happening with these jodis and example in point are the injuries. These jodis are lacking sleep and all to appease her and the other judges....yet nothing....once again did they NOT know what they were getting into; and when this week's jodi was eliminated farah was upset...

We as well as the judges are basing everything on the best they can do. These people are NOT professional dancers and the judges are trying to turn them into that, that's wrong. neither are john and abhi professional dancers; nor is srk a professional dancer--not every1 is hrithik but they still work hard and the desi girl promos are there for everyone to seeThis show should be dance as best as you can and with lacking history in dancing be judged/commented as such.suree we can then turn it into popularity contest baliye and the jodi with the most fans will win within a week Not to give bias scores to some; but to be unfair to the rest (point taken this friday with "strange" scores). Also not show somewhat dislike for a certain team versus another due to popularity. despite the fact that certain jodis just cannot dance at all--some judge that would be--like i said; what are the judges doing here then---it could just be popularity contest baliye...

As for some of the jodis showing facial expressions to farah and the other judges, heck why not yes and that is soooo professional; if farah can go off lacking professionalism 'all" the time,she is doing her job and she is a very successful choreographer and director why not show signs of 'DISGUST" from the jodis.if they are soooo disgusted, then can quit and devote their time to doing better things then Hell I was getting SICK to death of listening to the degrading comments by Farah and the other "puppet" judges. yes they too should put all these tv actors ona pedestal and tell them how they are better than srk, john, abhi, bips, katrina, priyanka, aamir, hrithik--no one can dance as well as them and give every1 30/30--what a great show it would be then--like i said--just change the name to popularity contest baliye Seems like they are afraid of farah so they follow her.

As I must say the same thing is continuing...They comment on one thing and then score differently...that confuses me as well.

Well Said Sheenie,
Here is my 2 cents, I feel the judges are quite fair, Farah has experience judging choreography she has choreographed some of the best songs in the industry and she is established... Arjun is being fair, Karishma tries that people arent hurt, they have right of individual judgement and they are paid for judgement, if not 100% accurate they are alteast right 90% of the times and 10% errors they have aright to make since they are human...But most of their judgement i think its right, sometimes my views my differ but am no one when compared to their experiences!!

Luv,

Shagun

Well there can be arguments and counter arguments whether Farah is a good or a bad judge and whether the jodis were aware or not of what they were getting into when they joined NB.

Originally posted by: belissima

Well there can be arguments and counter arguments whether Farah is a good or a bad judge and whether the jodis were aware or not of what they were getting into when they joined NB.

For me one thing holds - Farah's comments sucks!!!!

Criticism is necessary for a performer to improve, constructive criticism is always welcome, but downright rudeness is not done. And Farah is often indulging in downright rudeness. There are ways you can say the same thing and have the same impact.

If the jodis should know how to dance without bumping into each other and to always come prepared with their heels and other stuff then by the same token Farah should know that being an ace choreographer (as far as bollywod is concerned, don't know about the rest of the world) is all very good. But to become a respected judge she should take courses in people communication. She needs to correct her language and tone of judgement.

She has every right to criticize but no right to cross the levels of basic decency on national telly. Hitting below the belt with comments like my kids can dance better and i feel like giving you 3 slaps are absolutely no no. What actually she does and says to SRK, John, Preity and the rest of the bolly gang are not aired in public. Nor do we know how these people react to most of her comments - so comparing these NB jodis with the bollywod stars as regards there interaction with Farah is absolutely baseless.

in regards to farah khan and other judges, i am so tired of all these about pointing out how bad is one over the other, i will just say as little as possible

I feel Farha is the worst thing to have happened to NB in its 4 seasons...

Originally posted by: its me tan

in regards to farah khan and other judges, i am so tired of all these about pointing out how bad is one over the other, i will just say as little as possible

is anybody noticing that the judges actually praise rather shower the contestants with praises when they dance well?

that farah actually praised reshmi for her devi durga act? that farah finds the mouli majhar act of zinda outstanding? that farah thought in the contrasting day megha and naman has danced really well although it did not fit into the theme?

did anyone notice how shaleen and daljeets performance of bakhuda got complimented? coz it was truly a wonderful performance/

did anyone notice how kapils act of dam in contrast was praised by all?

or is it like: they r good when they praise and shower them with praises and evil when they comment on bad performances or not upto the mark performance?

or r we supposed to have slective opinion about judges:

wide eyed and open eared only when they say its foul to the bad performances of the jodis?

as for jodis beeing busy , not proffesional dancers blah blah blah! for the 100th timethey knew its going to be like this, none of the previous NB jodis made this an public excuse when the judges commented, none of the previous jodis complaind.

in NB@, hiten and gauri were always at gunpoint for their poor performance and they were t the time busiest telly starts, but i never hrd hiten saying something like we have been shooting all day and rehearsing then at night as an excuse in public, everyone said that in press interviews and all but never to the judges that we r busy and so we r under pressure,........

may be these jodis have much to learn yet!

I completely agree with you....Farah and the other judges have to do their job, the job that they get paid for....and the jodis have to theirs....Somehow the jodis of NB-4 except a few totally lack interest, energy and motivation.....and as a result of that we see a screaming Farah Khan.......The appreciation and compliements go completely unnoticed and only when the jodis are criticised, everyone gets offended......

Originally posted by: svesum

I completely agree with you....Farah and the other judges have to do their job, the job that they get paid for....and the jodis have to theirs....Somehow the jodis of NB-4 except a few totally lack interest, energy and motivation.....and as a result of that we see a screaming Farah Khan.......The appreciation and compliements go completely unnoticed and only when the jodis are criticised, everyone gets offended......