Worst Judge - Page 7

Poll

Which of the three judges really gets on your nerves?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

83

Views

8.7k

Users

50

Frequent Posters

svesum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: sweet coco

Farah is mean, but her comments are hilarious. I think the judges are fed up with the bad performances say mean things, but I would too if in their place.




Partially I agree wid you....I like Karishma and Arjun, both have gotten better from the very first episode...Farah, no doubts is a great choreographer but lacks ppl skills, she needs to point out defects in a dance in a much better way....but sadly, I think that the jodis lack energy and shows in their performances. In my opinion, jodis and Judges of NB4 are the worst of all the seasons of NB.

I think NB-2 with Hussein-Tina, Hiten-Gauri, Gauri-Yash, Bhaktiyaar and Tanaaz etc was the best season of NB both in terms on Dance, and judges comments. NB3 and NB1 were pretty good as well, but NB4 is just bad....Most jodis seem to have some sort of injury/sickness and judges keeping building pressure on these jodis which is making the show worse.

I would rather watch a repeat of NB-2 instead of NB-4




Cheetara thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#62
Yeah NB2 was the best!👍🏼
diss thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#63
i can see that farah aint that popular:) lol
AishwaryaRathod thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: sweets42

Farah, I know you have so much experience in choreography and dance but you have to understand that these jodis, most of them are also actors/actresses and barely have the time for themselves, let alone time to really get into the dancing. They are dancing for fun, not for you to make them feel like crap. to be honest I think they are dancing because nb4 is a great platform and because they get paid to participate When I saw that poor girl (Bhoomi from KSBKBT - I don't know her real name) crying because Farah said to her "what kind of dirty shoes are these that you're wearing" and then telling them they should bring their own costumes, shirts and undergarments, that was very very rude.I am sure Reshmi rolling her eyes at farah khan who has more experience in chorepgraphy and has directed oso one of the biggest grossers in bwood was totally fine and not rude😕 I think she could have told them in a nicer way about the things they did wrong in their dancing. It was not a road block or road accident, whatever it was she said. I can't exactly remember. yes it was there was confusion everywhere--megha and mouli were almost bumping into each other when they were changing positions--and i ve been dancing since i was 4--jazz, ballet, hip-hop, ballroom dancing--so i do know that there are ways of changing positions without almost bumping into each other
Is she like this with the people she choreographs dances for and helps with? I don't think so. John Abraham was laughing in an interview the other day about how farah khan needs to be applauded for choreographing him in desi girl(and kjo confirmed on the same show that farah came out of her sabbatical to choreograph desi girl for him) and John said--that farah asked --"john, have you been possessed?? and he was laughing about it; --and there were times during the making when abhishek would look at her and she would say--abhi--stop standing around like an idiot: reference the making of desi girl She should have some empathy for others instead of insulting them and their team....but it is an excuse--does reshmi not own a proper pair of high heels or stillettos--i am not saying she should have brought on Jimmy Choos but her shoes did look rilli weird
Really sad....I hope she apologizes to the jodis for her rude and "bloody" behavior. really?/if John Abraham who in all terms is a bigger star than the jodis on shava shava combined doesnt expoect her to apologise, then why?/she is a judge; a choreographer; its her job to point out what is tacky and what is really a bunch of people bumping into each other....
nothing personal man--just looking at the other side of the coin...

Edited by legallyblonde21 - 16 years ago
246851 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#65
well pointed out sheen👏
my personal feelings:
jodis r not dancing for fun as some one remarked or for a charity event, they get paid to participate, else no one will even move their finger for charity, end of dance competetion there are prize money in lacs : to earn it you need to work hard.
for myself i think kareesma is too swete in her commnets she also needs to point out the mistakes, judges r not supposed to be sweet and sugary they r here to point out mistakes so that you can be better.
and about the stars: they crying r what i dont care coz i feel its all fake, they know veyrr well as long as they ahve "audience vote " with them, and they do a lil dramabazi(refrerring to al sorts ) these votes will be with dem, they r not bothered what a FK or Ar said.
regarding farah khan being polite and all, she is one of the most successful chroeographers and has directed the likes of Srk ,she kows her job. how do we know that she does not rebuke a srk or AB Junior, or a rani or preity like this when they do not dance upto the mark? in making of OSo, everywhere in tv they showed her shouting at all teh starts while choreographing diwangi and no one minded, thats why soe thing spectacular came out in those 7 min.
as for reshmi, she rolled her eyes and made rude facial gesture when Fk commented, you r not supposed to react to judge like that, not at least in public, derz private rooms for that.
I think the judges of nb4 are asssets of the show and by far the best lot of all 4 seasons. and because of them the jodis r also trying improving, why pamper them by covering their mistakes.
wonderman thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#66
All of them are bad. FARAH is the worst and yet the other follow her, due to possible fear of her.
-Akanksha- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#67
I agree with its me tan and legallyblonde12.. The jodis aren't really taking it seriously or working hard enough and that frustrates the judges. What do they do? The jodis won't learn if they don't get the right feedback. And for how long can the judges be polite? There's a limit to this
Demilove thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: its me tan

well pointed out sheen👏
my personal feelings:
jodis r not dancing for fun as some one remarked or for a charity event, they get paid to participate, else no one will even move their finger for charity, end of dance competetion there are prize money in lacs : to earn it you need to work hard.
for myself i think kareesma is too swete in her commnets she also needs to point out the mistakes, judges r not supposed to be sweet and sugary they r here to point out mistakes so that you can be better.
and about the stars: they crying r what i dont care coz i feel its all fake, they know veyrr well as long as they ahve "audience vote " with them, and they do a lil dramabazi(refrerring to al sorts ) these votes will be with dem, they r not bothered what a FK or Ar said.
regarding farah khan being polite and all, she is one of the most successful chroeographers and has directed the likes of Srk ,she kows her job. how do we know that she does not rebuke a srk or AB Junior, or a rani or preity like this when they do not dance upto the mark? in making of OSo, everywhere in tv they showed her shouting at all teh starts while choreographing diwangi and no one minded, thats why soe thing spectacular came out in those 7 min.
as for reshmi, she rolled her eyes and made rude facial gesture when Fk commented, you r not supposed to react to judge like that, not at least in public, derz private rooms for that.
I think the judges of nb4 are asssets of the show and by far the best lot of all 4 seasons. and because of them the jodis r also trying improving, why pamper them by covering their mistakes.

In regds to Farah Khan,. yes she is a successful choregrapher, But this is NOT bollywood where the contestants are ONLY devoted to this show and nothing else. These people have 2-3 serials their working on as well as this. They have other "major" aka "bread and butter" obligations as well as this.....Plz dont take it as an excuse for them....but as a reality. Whatever time they have left over, they lack sleep and devote to dancing for this show. SO YES AS FOR SOME OF US, THEYRE TAKING THIS SHOW SERIOUSLY. Then again you will have the rest who will agree with these judges. But then they're those like us who see the truth in all.
Bollywood and Tellywood, are different, those stars are rolling in the high bucks, and can afford to devote all their time to that ONE film. Whereas this is just a dance show, also involving money, but reality, you can't ask the jodis to give more than necessary to this show, since their serials are more important to "pay" the bills. Farah Khan is used to bollywood stars bending toward her and devoting ALL their time to her and will do anything to make her happy...But she failed to realize the same thing is happening with these jodis and example in point are the injuries. These jodis are lacking sleep and all to appease her and the other judges....yet nothing....
We as well as the judges are basing everything on the best they can do. These people are NOT professional dancers and the judges are trying to turn them into that, that's wrong. This show should be dance as best as you can and with lacking history in dancing be judged/commented as such. Not to give bias scores to some; but to be unfair to the rest (point taken this friday with "strange" scores). Also not show somewhat dislike for a certain team versus another due to popularity.
As for some of the jodis showing facial expressions to farah and the other judges, heck why not; if farah can go off lacking professionalism 'all" the time, why not show signs of 'DISGUST" from the jodis. Hell I was getting SICK to death of listening to the degrading comments by Farah and the other "puppet" judges. Seems like they are afraid of farah so they follow her.
As I must say the same thing is continuing...They comment on one thing and then score differently...that confuses me as well.
Edited by Deep08 - 16 years ago
silverslavish thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#69
Farah . Farah. Farah.
Farah is obnoxious. The tone she uses when she talks to the contestants is as if they are a bunch of kindergarten kids. they are grown ups. I know she means business, but she should really start using a little tact when bringing forth her opinions because a lot of the time they come across as downright rude.
If she's trying to be simon cowell, then huns she looks jus silly in comparison😆 Its a dance show that these couples are doing in their sparetime to get closer to their baliyes.. and not some military camp where their life and death depends on it. Theres absolutely no need to get so rude that u cross the lines of decency.Sometimes a "i jus hated it" with a serious face is sufficient to get ur point across. instead of name calling and what not.
On the other hand if worst judge is meant to be useless/confused/predictable comments.. then karisma FTW!
wonderman thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: silverslavish

Farah . Farah. Farah.
Farah is obnoxious. The tone she uses when she talks to the contestants is as if they are a bunch of kindergarten kids. they are grown ups. I know she means business, but she should really start using a little tact when bringing forth her opinions because a lot of the time they come across as downright rude.
If she's trying to be simon cowell, then huns she looks jus silly in comparison😆 Its a dance show that these couples are doing in their sparetime to get closer to their baliyes.. and not some military camp where their life and death depends on it. Theres absolutely no need to get so rude that u cross the lines of decency.Sometimes a "i jus hated it" with a serious face is sufficient to get ur point across. instead of name calling and what not.
On the other hand if worst judge is meant to be useless/confused/predictable comments.. then karisma FTW!

LOL. I agree with this. I hated when she commented to them, her kids can dance better than some of the jodis. That was a LOW Blow. She needs to think before speaking. Simon Cowell she can never be. Watching future shows with her, will have me throwing stuff to the TV.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".