Worst Judge - Page 6

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Which of the three judges really gets on your nerves?

Frequent Posters

Akanksha

@-Akanksha-

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: Shafza
I hear what majority are saying...and Im probably the most ill judged to comment on this weeks judging coz I didnt get a chance to see the jodi's perform...so havent seen Farah's outburst.

However if u ask most of the jodi's which judge do u want to hear or fear the most they will say Farah. Each knows that they will get a good or bad feedback from Arjun and Karishma..whereas Farah gives it her full. She doesnt dress it up.

The only performance I did see completely was our beloved Kanjali's and each of the judges said their bits:

Karishma was informed by a 'Uorta kabootar😕' erm ur supposed to make ur own opinion and not listen to what others say...otherwise u dont really qualify as a judge...you're just reporting.

Arjun was honest and stated that Anjali had indeed missed a few steps so as a judge I find him true...so couldnt fault him

However Farah was the only one who noticed that Kapil made a last second slip which they recovered from beautifully. Previously Farah told them that the audience shouldnt know about any slips or anything wrong in ur performance and they listened. Infact I think all the jodi's listen to Farah the most bcoz of her skills.

So yes she's harsh...but as a judge she is the best qualified but Arjun executes it very well. Karishma....no comments.

I agree 100%

Quote

Hetal

@ibelieveinpink

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#52

Farah is mean, but her comments are hilarious. I think the judges are fed up with the bad performances say mean things, but I would too if in their place.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nisha_07

@Nisha_07

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#53

Originally posted by: tashmin
Today topped it off for me. These three stooges are horrid judges.

(I'm sorry...as every show passes, I start disliking them all the more)

Farah is rude.
Karishma never has anything useful to say.
Arjun is just sexy...he should just sit there with his mouth shut.

Also, when Arjun laughed after Farah's tirade, that was rude...poor Reshmi is crying and you find it funny?

I remember how in the past shows, if one judge said something another disagreed with they brought it up, I was horrified to see that neither Karishma nor Arjun told that women to shut her trap.....

Spin-less...rude....discouraging...boring...judges..

With you 100%. That was not judging. Actually I don't know what that was, except for pointless. Everything that was said could have been said constructively but oh no.

Vaibhavi last year was also the one all contestants would be eager to hear from. Vaibhavi gave her opinion critically, but never offensively. Farah was just downright offensive.

Quote

pop77

@pop77

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: jibi
No one.
I like all judges' comments and i feel them genuine.

i agree with U..i like all..

Quote

Ria Kaur

@scorpiorule

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#55

As of Sat. I vote all 3 OUTTTTTTTTTTTT.

They should of tried to "stop" Farah from going off the handle or say something to the jodis of Shava Shava.....ie: sorry for farah's outburst...something to make them feel better.....

These people need to be gone. No support, Not fair. What kind of judging is this?? Blunt is one thing...but there is no excuse for rudeness from any caliber of a person and more so from Farah Khan.. This is not her bollywood set. Wise up Farah Khan, you're boring and making people dislike you more.

Edited by scorpiorule - 16 years ago

Quote

Celina

@Celina_

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#56

Woah What You All Are Up To..Jeezzeezz Well I Only Agree About Farah She Was Very Rude..She Start Abusin And Thatz Rong Totally Rong And Arjun Well Ofcourse All He Doez Is Gettin Agree With Farah And He Showz Up Like He Knowz Very well About Dance..He Showz Attitude Which Is Nonsense..And Karisma Is Gettin Betta By Each Episode And Atleast She Is Not Rude Like Farah.. Tjou I Like All Of Them..But Farah Shud Control And Theze Contestantz Are Way Too Lazy Man.Everyday They Are Gettin Injured Or Fever Or That..Only Excusess

Edited by Celina_ - 16 years ago

Quote

Simran

@simisop

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#57

i agree with a lot of people. Why were these three people chosen to judge the competition. they shoul be encouraging towards the teams and not rude and disrespectful. i am so sick and tired of farah khan's judgements.

Quote

ta33

@ta33

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#58

Arjun is sweet and supportive and has a good eye for details. Farah is honest and straightforward but can get angry soon as she expects a lot. Karishma on the other hand is trying to make herself stand out with her trademark three claps. I dont get the idea behind 'three' why just three. She is trying to do something like Saroj Khan's whistle. She seems pretty fake too and on top of that her comments are not very useful either. It's sort of like a lay man's point of view.

Edited by ta33 - 16 years ago

Quote

sweets42

@sweets42

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

#59

Farah is one of the rudest judges I have ever seen on any show whatsover.

First there was Abhijeet who was saying crap against Pakistani's and saying their singing was besura - well he blatantly pointed that out to everyone not to sing songs that were from besura singers like Atif Aslam. That was the first judge I saw who was rude.....

But Farah tops the cake in rudeness towards the jodis.

Farah, I know you have so much experience in choreography and dance but you have to understand that these jodis, most of them are also actors/actresses and barely have the time for themselves, let alone time to really get into the dancing. They are dancing for fun, not for you to make them feel like crap. When I saw that poor girl (Bhoomi from KSBKBT - I don't know her real name) crying because Farah said to her "what kind of dirty shoes are these that you're wearing" and then telling them they should bring their own costumes, shirts and undergarments, that was very very rude. I think she could have told them in a nicer way about the things they did wrong in their dancing. It was not a road block or road accident, whatever it was she said. I can't exactly remember.

Is she like this with the people she choreographs dances for and helps with? I don't think so. She should have some empathy for others instead of insulting them and their team....

And the rudest part - she comes on stage while the Shava Shava team are huddled on the stage consoling the girl who was crying, and Farah just passes right by them like they were her worst enemies, put the points in the box and went right back in such a huff....if you look at Arjun and Karishma, they seemed scared of her too because they were keeping space from Farah as she walked to put the points in and walked back.

Really sad....I hope she apologizes to the jodis for her rude and "bloody" behavior.

BTW, I'm new here! Hello!