We are talking about Naagins here though and yes like you said not everyone can use it for the right purpose or to effectively or efficiently accomplish their objectives don't you think the same logic would apply in Rishab's case? or are you expecting him to be a super human with a super brain?
Start a Rishabh Fan-Club then huh.
Sia was not forced to marry Viraj now was she? She married him out of her own choice the domestic violence was a consequence of such a marriage but then again only Viraaj is accountable for the domestic violence since that is his karma alone.
Agreed with the point but I used the argument since your favorite quote seems to be- everyone is responsible for their own actions irrespective of who made them do it.But it does not apply in every case.
If any particular Government engages in a Scam or a country declares war will you hold the Public accountable? Isn't that a stretching a bit too far? Mixing up everything huh.
So that way even Rishabh is not a mindreader himself to guess what's going on in Pratha's mind. Also here it's his childhood friend and love that has targeted Pratha as a suspicious character, and by the way now that i think about it Rishab is not the only one who suspects Pratha, there are other people in the gujraal house who do so especially Urvashi, that chachi, reem's sister and these people are doing it without any proof against her.
Whether Rithik was a mindreader or not deep down in his heart he felt Shivanya wasn't evil as she was made out to be but still chose to stab her because his foster mother or aunt told him to do so thereby he can be held responsible for it.
Yeah agreed with the above point but you ignore the fact that he was entirely misled by Yamini.But as per your logic still Ritik should be the accused one huh?
Really then why do you care so much if Pratha ends up getting hurt or is on the losing end because of Rishab's cynical and suspicious nature. I was talking about pratha using Maahir as an example who was suffering initially because of Bela's unilateral judgement.
Are u out of your mind or what? Then why do you care to defend Rishabh that much? What are u talking about-if any viewer likes or cares about any character then its their choice entirely.
The moot point is not about caring for this character or that character but predicting the future events based on the current story.
If you only express your concern for him alone and dismiss the naagin's who goes through the same thing then yes i would because if I see a bias I will definitely talk about it.
What are you saying? And what's this Bias thing? U r accusing me of Bias really? As if you are not biased against Pratha or the other Naagins before her.Again an irrational point.
What do you mean by what did I expect him to do? Aren't you normalising his behavior because he is a certain type of character by actually asking this question? Did Veer know she was AdiNaagin at that point? To him she was just a mere human being who supposedly managed to kill his weak twin brother. Whether she could retaliate or not are you actually saying that it's okay for a guy to resort to domestic abuse just because of XYZ reason?
So what did you mean when you said that - If you had said it out of humanity then I canunderstand but why should they do it for any other reason? Howdid Humanity come into all this huh?
Aren't you normalising his behavior because he is a certain type of character by actually asking this question?
Stop putting words into my mouth all right-I have already specified that whatever Veer did after Teer's death was totally unjustifiable but its pretty normal from his POV bcoz he saw Bani as the killer there.Veer is a fictional character and yeah even real characters execute unjustified actions in the name of revenge if you had watched Savdhaan India or Crime Patrol.
I am not saying that what they do is right but from their perspective it looks right from their POV which is what I meant to say.
What do you want? A Perfect Real-World or a Perfect ML or FL? U urself have written FF with both the presence of negative/Postive and Grey characters but for every point u seem to bring reality into the same.
So basically you are saying that if a guy is bad from the beginning their wrongs actions can be overlooked? Has it not occured to you that even Rishabh could be a grey character himself? Clearly even he is not a goody two shoes or perfect guy as you are expecting him to be.
Again putting words into my mouth? Did I or anybody else that a person's wrong action can be overlooked if he turns a good guy later onwards huh? What do u want-A Perfect Typed Answer.
People ship characters not because of what they are at the moment but rather because of the potential they see through the pair for the story. That way I see people shipping psychos, murderers, narcissists, with the ML or FL expecting them to change or reform over time. If you ask me Veer wasn't a character to be shipped with Bani at all in the beginning but people liked him regardless which affected the story as a result.
Yeah I know these things already so what's new in that? Every character will have flaws right?
People do keep stuff like that in their bags, that note is a valuable piece of information, you don't really think it would get discarded right away, on top of that it was just half the note which was in her bag. When you have half a message it's natural to keep it with yourself so you could read the entire message on collecting the other.
I don't think there was a scene where Pratha willingly kept that torn note in the bag herself.
Shapeshifters don't exist in the real world but frauds and criminals do right? If you knew that a suspicious person has charmed you sibling are you going to just sit and watch them marry that person? Would you actually not doubt that if your sibling marries such a person they would literally be ruining their life? Yes there are cases where couples break apart but honestly being tagged as a divorcee makes people wonder why or simply avoid pursuing any form of relationship with them at least that's how it's in arranged marriages. Then there is the psychological effect of seperating from a lifelong partner which could leave behind emotional scars. I know this because I have people who are divorcees around me who think twice before pursuing another relationship.
Honestly man such deep analysis.Psychological effect and all that Heavy Stuff Isn't It? Do u know the difference between a real and fictional character or even the difference between Ficitional and Real World in the first place?
I am simply unable to figure out that what is the purpose of bringing such statements- Shapeshifters don't exist in the real world but frauds and criminals do right? If you knew that a suspicious person has charmed you sibling are you going to just sit and watch them marry that person? Would you actually not doubt that if your sibling marries such a person they would literally be ruining their life?
Yes I don't deny that such issues happen in the real world otherwise there won't be any Savdhaan India or Crime Patrol depiciting such incidents but this is almost like strecthing a point beyond the realm of Fact or Fiction.
Let me repeat that no man whether he's Fictional or Real can be Perfect right so what's the point of bringing such issues for the defence of a mere fictional character?
I know this because I have people who are divorcees around me who think twice before pursuing another relationship.
Whatever has happened in their lives are unfortunate and the past cannot be bought back but all we can do is wish the best for them so that they can move ahead and have a better life.
I think u need to stop bringing or mixing real life issues beyond a point bcoz whenever u discuss any fictional character bcoz in that way every character will have flaws whether they are positive/negative or grey.
We are here to simply discuss and express our POV and while yes real life issues can certainly be discussed on this forum they need to be in the context of a relevant discussion. Going overboard in certain characters defense is certainly not advisable neither having certain false assumptions.
If u wanna discuss real life issues then the whole point gets derailed.Nothing in this world is perfect.
And yes I still find Rishabh's character boring so what?
Edited by masked - 3 years ago
Book Talk
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
Cricket
Real Estate
Cryptocurrency
Financial markets and global economy
