What's wrong with Bani? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

2.9k

Users

12

Likes

82

Frequent Posters

dhakarn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 5 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: J2lover

You see! Everyone has an agenda here, except bani! Jay and mayuri are dedicated towards becoming powerful! Meera is dedicated towards being the sensible elder sister! Balwant is dedicated towards searching for aadi naagin and ofc veer is dedicated towards his gharwaali!😆 But hai toh sahi!

Muzhe bani ka goal hi samjh nai aa rha abhi tak! What does she exactly want! Want to kill cheels? Kill them by making plans! Want to kill veer? Fine, start making plans to trap him! But bandi karr kya rhi hai? She has no idea!😆 if she wants to kill all the cheels? Why not shift the focus from veer and target others first? Isn't ponky or monil an easy target for a kill than veer?

But madam just wants to do nothing apart from instigating the most control freak man on earth, and bore the audience!🤔


Yeah, one would think with veer out of her way she would just kill all those cheels she hates so much, but no... Instead she saved them n gave a lame reason that she would do it herself.... So do it na ? Who is there to stop her

dhakarn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 5 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Manu_986

first I want to clarify this one thing, Bani isn't bad but circumstances are making her represented as bad!

Talking about first disconnect, Meera might have shocked when she first time came to know about bani being naagin. now she just cannot be worried for her everytime. they might have used to with this odd fact.

the second thing you said about her real family. why would she think when she already knew about her past that her parents died in plane crash. Right now she has no idea about her parents who weren't died, infact they were killed. See actually there's one thing common in every naagin. They believes only on those things or incidents which happens in front of their eyes. They don't use brains when it comes to take revenge. Bas apne marte huye naag partner ke aankho me jo vision dekhti hai ussi pe blindly trust kar leti hai. which is actually a big loophole and we have to accept it. because these things are common in such finite show like naagin.

Okay, here I am totally with you, why bani is adamant on taking revenge when jay is alive?


Thanks for replying


Yeah, but they are too cool about it.... Even Jay's siblings too didn't seem shocked, instead they were all excited... Which I don't think will be a normal person reaction... Like if we look from trp audience pov who might not be exposed to many supernatural shows, would at least wonder why nobody is reacting to the fact that his / her sibling is not human?


Hmm, yeah that's the mistake of the writers through out all the seasons of the naagin series.. All their leads are kinda blind...

forest_foliage thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: dhakarn


Thanks for the reply


Yeah, but then here we can't blame bani as she don't know who saved her from truck blast.. I guess she will know only when she sees her jhumka.... Also she might think that veer is doing things for her in his obsession, but then her hate for him and cheels in general stumps every reason

There has to be a starting point for Bani to grow slightly sensitive towards Veer and Jai's revelation won't contribute to the cause. Bani has to overcome Naageshwari in her, and view her present without the lens of the past. Going by her stubborn nature, and her rigid, malicious hatred for the Cheels, especially Aakesh - only a hard hitting fact can truly shake her up & compel her to bring about a change in her biased perspective - that fact is Veer saved her from the truck blast. But she won't know about it unless she visits that home once again where Veer had brought her after saving her from death. Bani won't trust Veer if he tells her anything about it, and he won't tell her about it as well. So Bani will have to use her brain & find out about it by herself.
Koudou thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#34

Est ce que verre respecté bani moi je rien vue de la part de verre arrête de dire de mal contre bani a part son amour pour bani et le protégé contre sa famille je rien vue

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago
#35

Oh man, what a question. I could write a bloody essay on this topic going by what I have seen and understood of Bani. Let me divide it into pre and post basis her past life revelation.

Pre Past Life Revelation:

Bani initially comes across as a polite girl, and in my language, dull, who does stress eating and talks to animals which is rather lame.🤔 She is a caring person, who loves her foster family and seeks the approval of a foster mother she never receives. She feels a subtle attraction to Jai, who is a desirable bachelor (HOW????) and is in turn impressed by his act of defending Noor's honor, when she is embarrassed and humiliated by Veer publicly, which makes Veer an object of disdain in her view. She is rather quick to judge that Noor's disappearance was the fault of Veer's brothers, not thinking once, that Noor would have disappeared out of shame and guilt.👎🏼 When Noor is found dead, and Veer and his brothers bury her, she very rightly assumes that she died because of Veer. She feels love and hate at the same time for Jai and Veer. No justification for the love👎🏼, but hate is justified👍🏼. She seeks justice for her dead friend, and Veer blocks all her attempts, only to protect his brothers and also flirting his way through it, which earns him even more disgust. All of a sudden eyewitnesses appear out of thin air and Naina, another useless Naagin is saved from two Cheels by the timely intervention of Naagin Bani👍🏼who is aware of who she is, and she has a certain sense of pride in herself, which I did feel. Matlab, I felt it was written all over her face, I am a Naagin and I am proud of it👎🏼. To add further fuel to the fire, Naina is abducted by the Cheels and she dies in the truck blast, initiated by Ballu, to protect the family. Bani's anger over this too is completely justified.👍🏼 She is saved by the timely arrival of Veer, which she obviously doesn't know. She reaches home to be greeted by Veer and a marriage proposal intended for Meera. She confronts Veer and later bumps into Jai who till now has been receiving visions of a past, which is now even seen by Bani, and both embark on a journey to revisit the past. At the Naag mandir, both Jai and Bani recall the past, and Bani swears vengeance over the Cheels with Jai by her side, before their supposed union.👎🏼

Post Past Life Revelation:

Post this revelation, her only motive is the destruction of all Cheels, whereas this life was chosen by her to find her lover and complete the union which was left incomplete in Satyug. But Bani chooses revenge over love👎🏼. She decides to get married to Jai the same day as Veer and Meera to show her hate for Veer👎🏼. In the midst of all this, Jai is kidnapped and supposedly flung off from the cliff by Veer, which turns out to be Teer, his twin brother. Veer distraught over Teer's death marries Bani to wreck her life and Bani vows the same. After marriage her first target is Ponky and she tries to trigger Ponky to attack her, the only instance till now👍🏼 only to be halted by Veer. She tries harassing the Cheel family, to be stopped by Veer each time. Then enters Mayuri, who is morni and they engage in verbal and physical catfights, which is lame and unnecessary.👎🏼 Jai turns out to be alive and he does mention that Veer did not try to kill him, but Bani conveniently ignores the truth👎🏼. Bani to instigate Veer shamelessly goes and dances in front of Ballu's business associates👎🏼, but the guy does not get incensed but is humored by her ruse. She again tries to instigate him by messing with Teer's supposed coffin👍🏼 only to be stopped by Veer and later is saved by JaMayShu's attempt to kill her. Bani's strong moral and ethical compass compels her to save Veer because she wants to kill him in a fair fight and not by stealth👍🏼. Post that Jai infiltrates the Singhania family only to be caught by his scent and attempt to breach the Rudraksh ka Mayajaal. Bani, on the other hand, is clueless why Jai's scent is caught👎🏼 but she realizes had she killed Teer, her scent would be caught and she would have been exposed too, which leads her to the truth of Teer's death👍🏼. And after this, she is shown doing nothing fruitful, except loitering in the mansion like Peeves and locating a stone, which is controlled by her and Veer. She successfully identifies fake Veer👍🏼and saves the Cheels from the stone👍🏼, with no sign of feeling any curiosity as to where did her husband disappear👎🏼.

So summarizing my point, Bani is a polite and decent girl but there is a lack of emotional connection to her family or friends or supposed lover. The only emotion that defines her overall is her unbridled hate for Veeranshu, triggered in the present by his actions and supported by Aakesh's actions in the past and a curse that has left her bitter and vitriolic, overwhelming every other emotion within her. The lack of emotion for any other character she considers her own is because the only thing she feels within her is hate.

I mean, I have seen people with hate dude, for instance, Maya Jaisingh from Beyhadh 2. She had undergone trauma, humiliation, physical and mental torture, and that pain was evident when she was avenging her perpetrators. But Bani, no other emotion or feeling comes across to us. We can understand her POV and pain, when we think and explain ourselves about it, not because Bani can convey her pain to us because Bani conveys only hate and hate and hate.

Hate has blinded her to anything good that is possible by the Cheels, because in her opinion they are incapable of good. Hate does not make her see the faults of anyone else, hate makes her consider that everything in her life is Veer's fault, hate makes her a tantrum-oriented, arrogant, temperamental, childish, petty, and an immature snob, and she has a Mean Girls version as well only for her darling Mayuri. She is Bani only namesake because she breathes Naageshwari in her behavior and speech. As Bani, she had more control over her thoughts and actions, but now all control has shifted to Naageshwari. Bani hates Veer, mostly because Naageshwari hates and does not trust Aakesh. Bani trusts Jai, and might I add, does not love Jai, but she is with him because Naageshwari loved Hriday. If these are not enough, Bani's characterization as a Naagin is weak and lame, where she has been reduced to a petty streetside goon, who gives petty death threats, utilizes lame tactics to antagonize her opponents, and is perpetually confused, and angry. That's Bani for me.

Well, I did write a thesis, not even an essay. Sorry girls for a long read.😊

Edited by libran90 - 5 years ago
Midnightsorrow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Shirsha90

Bani has a few reasons. I am writing those points. Don't get angry with me, I know you like Veer a lot. 😆

1) She believes Veer killed Noor and she was her best friend. Veer didn't kill her but Bani doesn't know that. She loves her to a great extent.

2) She believes Veer is involved in human trafficking. Only Veer's dad and his brothers are involved in those activities. But Bani doesn't have any idea about that.

3) She thinks Veer tried to kill Jay. I mean Teer looked like Veer, so she is confused who actually tried killing Jay.

4) She thinks all the shape-shifting eagles of this world are dangerous and evil. Shape-shifting eagles always used to attack naagmandir in Satya Yug. When Naageshwari trusted Aakesh he broke her trust. Then Lord Shiva cursed her and she never imagined something like that could happen to her. That was a traumatic experience for her. That incident affected her soul so much that she is unable to forget about it even after so many years. In Kali Yug, Noor said to her, "Kehne ko to sharab ka business hain, lekin iske ar mein pata nahi kitne illegal dhande hain..."

@Bold How is Bani going to find it in her to trust a Cheel like Veer? Wouldn't that curse from the past put her in a dilemma?
925059 thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: AutumnColors

@Bold How is Bani going to find it in her to trust a Cheel like Veer? Wouldn't that curse from the past put her in a dilemma?

Exactly! It will be difficult for Bani. If she comes to know about Jay's real face her perspective towards Jay will be changed. Her blind love and trust for Jay will be gone. Then the situation will be changed. Veer should also try to earn her trust. Yes, he saved Bani from his family's attack. But that's not enough for her. Bani needs to know that Veer didn't kill Noor. She has to know that Veer has nothing to do with human trafficking activities. Apart from that, I think the makers should show Hriday tried to kill Naageshwari even in Satya Yug and Aakesh killed Hriday to save her. Then it will be much easier for Bani to think about Veer in a different manner. Let's see how the equation between Veer and Bani changes!

dhakarn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 5 years ago
#38

Thanks for the really amazing and detailed reply ... @libran90


Bani is right in many places but completely wrong in some other... She just needs to accept the fact that she is wrong, maybe then only she can begin thinking right ...

BTW I am a she, not he 😃

Edited by dhakarn - 5 years ago
libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: dhakarn

Thanks for the really amazing and detailed reply ... @libran90


Bani is right in many places but completely wrong in some other... She just needs to accept the fact that she is wrong, maybe then only she can begin thinking right ...

BTW I am a she, not he 😃

You are welcome, my dear.😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".