...most unfair practice by shankar... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

5.3k

Users

20

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

^orpita^ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
I know he wants to win but i found it bit weired though donno theres no complain against him i also love shankar not his team though but seems like shankar also dont have any faith on his team members like me 😆😆😆😆😆 last time he came 2ice now again 😆😆😆😆😆 he loves singing a lot i tell u 😆😆😆😆😆 but on the other hand i lovee that song and thank god he sang it 😃 loved it though 😛😃 but as a captain donno how far it look good of him coming everytime 😆😆😆😆😆 but i enjoy his singing 😆😆😆😆😆
xobile thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
This topic has been done to death.

All I'd like to add is that we should all say NO to name calling.
Sid4TeamCanada thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: sonia65

...he has lost it before he could compete....we all know he is a total let down for a guru.....a guru or teacher produces able ,capable students and this guru has only elevated his role as a singer to greater heights which is not the sole motive behind this programme.......he comes even here in the semis and sings against anwesha...shankar you are a total loser.....why wait till the grand finale..give this man the trophy and finish this facade once andfor all....

agree with u ..( except for the loser part 😛).... shankar ko trophy de do abhi se... tell him to leave him team at home in final, since he really doesn't need them much... v hardly see them :P per u knwo wht, abhi se trophy kaise dein,.. shreya bhi toh hai! even she LOVES to sing her songs in all the rounds😛 shankar vs shreya wud be perfect final for both of them - they both can come sing in every round, and get perfect 10's ! 😛
and u know wht... as a singer shankar is all good and all that, but i am TIRED.. seriously i m TIRED of him everytime coming to perform in EVERY round (yes i may be exaggerating but u knwo wht i mean!)... it's just SO unfair, that u have students of other team working SO HARD to get past the critical analyses by audience and judges, and then he comes opposite the other team's contestants any time that they get a good mark, he sings one of his songs, and the audience give him a 10! i mean COME ON, we know when captains perform, they get nothing less than a 10... and that's partly becuzof the fat thatwe knwo these are "professional accomplished singers", so they can not go wrong, and thus we expect (and in turn perceieve) them to be PERFECT... but the other student we critically analyse, if they get a 9.5 we think they did OH SOOOO WELL... it's SO SO SO unfair every time u have a student coming to sing from one team, and against the students shankar comes himself to sing..
1) it is JUST unfair, becuz he WILL get a 10 from audience...! just given the fact that he's shankar and he's singing one of his songs, songs that audiences love... how can the audience NOT give this accomplished GREAT singer a 10?
2) it shows that he doesn't think the rest of his team are capable of competing... ayesha got a 9.5 in yesterday' semi in himesh vs shankar.. and in response to that shankar goes liek ab kyaa karein, i think main khud hi aajata hoon.. WTH - whts the rest of the team there for? to get the free laddus?
3) again, adding to my point 2... this is abt TEAM vs TEAM.. not TEAM vs CAPTAIN.. TEAMS are supposed to play and TEAMS (as a TEAM) are supposed to win! shankar vs shaan semi final shankar's win was pretty much due to HIM COMING AGAIN AND AGAIN in every round and gettign a perfect 10... it wasn't his TEAM'S win! now in himesh vs shankar, shankar didnt coem that much, and we saw how it was a close match... now that is an ALMOST FAIR match... becuz the TEAMS equally competed..
4) some ppl commented on other captains coming to sing as well.. well i got to say the SAME thing abt shreya as i said abt shankar .. shreya has such a good female singer in his group - ujjaini, who she hardly gives a chance to sing.. and thats also unfair, becuz shreya comes in many rounds, sings her famous songs ( she is a GREAT singer after all!) and she gets perfect 10's... so OTHER than shreya and shankar, wht im gonna say is, even thoough the other captains also come to sing in rounds other than medley, however most of them play it fair.. shaan vs shreya: shaan only came in rounds where shreya was singing.. so it was FAIR - EQUAL match!
on a side note, i WOULD LOVE to see shaan AND himmesh in final... SHAAN I FOR SURE want in final - and if he does come in final, he BETTER have prepared songs to sing HIMSELF... captain ka jawab captain hi hona chahiye!
Edited by SidraLuvMayurBL - 15 years ago
xobile thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
^^awesome post! completely sums up the anti-Shankar side of the argument without resorting to personal attacks!

🤣 at free laddus! haha


musickimasti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Well .. today I did not mind Shankar M comming once against Anwesha ... as I saw the status of his team when they performed later .... good that he did not came again and again .... he was confident on Javed A

Today Javed A did all the bad works and actually came here for attention and revenge motto ... from the begining he was doing that ... his giving Sharib 6 was a joke for himself .... when Ismail D contradicted his comments (he being a music director) .... all others know music and he is the only person who does not .. writing songs does not mean he knows music and he created the maximum hullah here ...
So it's Gajji's fault of calling a person like him to judge music .. that way he could have called Sania Mirza also for judgement ... she is more famous persona ... or even Sachin Tendulkar :O)
it's bad for Shaan that he faced this today ..... Kismat karke aaye .. ek ke baad ek ...



Imagine if Himesh's team was in the finale!!!? Javed would have given those guys a really tough time. Probably would have given a 3 on medley and thrashed all the singers LOL
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#16
agreed with xobile, great post by SidraLuvMayurBL! A free laddu from me too!
Edited by bambooshoot - 15 years ago
kumarn thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
All the drama between Javed and Shaan is scripted by Gajji just to make Shaan's followers insecure and hence more dough into his kitty. The final will be decided by public voting and Shaan will win by a landslide.
sonia65 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: SidraLuvMayurBL

agree with u ..( except for the loser part 😛).... shankar ko trophy de do abhi se... tell him to leave him team at home in final, since he really doesn't need them much... v hardly see them :P per u knwo wht, abhi se trophy kaise dein,.. shreya bhi toh hai! even she LOVES to sing her songs in all the rounds😛 shankar vs shreya wud be perfect final for both of them - they both can come sing in every round, and get perfect 10's ! 😛
and u know wht... as a singer shankar is all good and all that, but i am TIRED.. seriously i m TIRED of him everytime coming to perform in EVERY round (yes i may be exaggerating but u knwo wht i mean!)... it's just SO unfair, that u have students of other team working SO HARD to get past the critical analyses by audience and judges, and then he comes opposite the other team's contestants any time that they get a good mark, he sings one of his songs, and the audience give him a 10! i mean COME ON, we know when captains perform, they get nothing less than a 10... and that's partly becuzof the fat thatwe knwo these are "professional accomplished singers", so they can not go wrong, and thus we expect (and in turn perceieve) them to be PERFECT... but the other student we critically analyse, if they get a 9.5 we think they did OH SOOOO WELL... it's SO SO SO unfair every time u have a student coming to sing from one team, and against the students shankar comes himself to sing..
1) it is JUST unfair, becuz he WILL get a 10 from audience...! just given the fact that he's shankar and he's singing one of his songs, songs that audiences love... how can the audience NOT give this accomplished GREAT singer a 10?
2) it shows that he doesn't think the rest of his team are capable of competing... ayesha got a 9.5 in yesterday' semi in himesh vs shankar.. and in response to that shankar goes liek ab kyaa karein, i think main khud hi aajata hoon.. WTH - whts the rest of the team there for? to get the free laddus?
3) again, adding to my point 2... this is abt TEAM vs TEAM.. not TEAM vs CAPTAIN.. TEAMS are supposed to play and TEAMS (as a TEAM) are supposed to win! shankar vs shaan semi final shankar's win was pretty much due to HIM COMING AGAIN AND AGAIN in every round and gettign a perfect 10... it wasn't his TEAM'S win! now in himesh vs shankar, shankar didnt coem that much, and we saw how it was a close match... now that is an ALMOST FAIR match... becuz the TEAMS equally competed..
4) some ppl commented on other captains coming to sing as well.. well i got to say the SAME thing abt shreya as i said abt shankar .. shreya has such a good female singer in his group - ujjaini, who she hardly gives a chance to sing.. and thats also unfair, becuz shreya comes in many rounds, sings her famous songs ( she is a GREAT singer after all!) and she gets perfect 10's... so OTHER than shreya and shankar, wht im gonna say is, even thoough the other captains also come to sing in rounds other than medley, however most of them play it fair.. shaan vs shreya: shaan only came in rounds where shreya was singing.. so it was FAIR - EQUAL match!
on a side note, i WOULD LOVE to see shaan AND himmesh in final... SHAAN I FOR SURE want in final - and if he does come in final, he BETTER have prepared songs to sing HIMSELF... captain ka jawab captain hi hona chahiye!

hey sidra this is for you....👏👏👍🏼...the way you summed up and even voiced your opinion...only sorry that it will all go waste....'cos once again shankar will come in the finals and sing his songs..the rest of the team should come with a big tape around their lips...
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#19
- Well Well Well.. Arguments have again arrived to Shankarji, i don't know why people start this thing all over again!!! Basically, Shankarji himself clarified when he went on stage, He wants the Best For his team does not want to leave any stone unturned. In terms of singing experience Shankar ji is way ahead than any of the captains and we should praise this man's humility.

- Shaan has not brought himself against Shankar because of the simple reason that Shankarji is a far greater well-versed singer, the difference would come out eventually if they had both sung against each other.

- If there is a rule that you can come then even if i would have been a captain, i would have come for my team if i had been a captain.. what is the purpose of a well-experienced captain, if he can't come up for his team?.. His strategy was simple, he wanted to take a one point lead for his team in the start, so that his team would be comfortable performing in the next round. I do not find anything wrong with that, every captain has his own strategy.

- If you are a person with SPORTSMAN SPIRIT you should face what ever that comes in your way and not just keep on babbling, nagging and criticizing the other team upon this point or the other.

- Shaan's team is lucky to have anwesha on their side, that is the main reason for their consistent scores in MKMM and today especially. Anwesha has such great command in sur that it is definitely Shankarji who should sing opposite her. You should be happy about it that she has the great shankar mahadevan coming against her. But no, people have to nag. Actually those people nag who do not have faith in the capability in their team.

- Rahul and Sharib have fully done up to the expectations. It is just Neeti who spoiled everything. But this is part of the risk of the game. Sometimes things go great, someday they don't.

- Shankar ji did not say a single word against the judgment. That is true Sportsmanship and i hearitily admire him for that. He respects the point of views from the judges and that is how it should be. Javed Saab is a talented judge, he has had judged so many reality shows, i think whatever marks and comments he gives they should be accepted as they are. His fair judgement should not be argued. He gave good marks as well and bad marks as well, so we cannot say that he was Biased with the teams. So, respect this great well-versed man, we people are not even close to him with the great amount of experience that he has. Respect that.

- This is not a GROOMING show for god's sake people!! why do you forget that!! This is a competition between the 6 singers of bollywood and their team. They are a member of their team they can come up anytime they want to. it has a different format, accept that!

- So my advice for supporters from both sides is CHILL OUT and come out of this complaining thing all the time. These are so great experienced people of your INDUSTRY, do you really think you have any right to criticize them like that?? I mean I can never imagine condemning people like Shreya, Shaan, Shankar, Javed Saab.. these are so great justified fair names. It is an honour in itself to see them here. Please HAVE RESPECT people. The more you show and give respect, the more respect you will get.

In the end, just want to say Chill out and Relax! thanks.
4teen12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
I dont blame Shankar....in fact, it is a pity that Shankar's team has reched Grand Finale. If we are to see only Shankar bringing himself on 2-3 times during an episode, it shows how weak his other team members are, that he does not have confidence on them.
Dont blame Shankar for it!! He is a great composer and singer.
Putting aisde the competition, I was spell bound to see him sing the first song and then again in medley...its just Shankar, Shankar and Shankar, all the way for his team.
Niti was pathetic in the DJ round but one cud see Shankar mustering up words to comfort her for her next performace along with Rahul on 'Jaane Ja', a song which is evergreen fav romantic song. Shankar, knowing the limitations of Niti, improvised it into a simple 'waltz number' without any harkats...yet, she faltered. Rahul, though tried catching up the original tune, fell short by miles as compared to Kishore Da.
Shankar does not have anyone with him, so its basically
Shankar - Shankar - Shankar
Vs
Shaan - Debo - Anwesh - Harshit - Shabad
How I wish Shreya's team or even Himesh's team had made it along with Shaan's for the GF.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".