Comment about 3rd semi's Shaan Vs Shankar Match - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

163

Views

17.9k

Users

44

Likes

155

Frequent Posters

safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

Shankar is the BEST!!! really hope shaan doesnt win the finals.


Shankar is a best MD and Best Singer..But Shaan is d real winner ..Shaan never hoose unfair way to win..
God Bless Amul Shaan Strikers..Jeetenge Shaan se..Thy will win by God Grace and public loves..
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: shirani7

Just finished watching the episode...man that was quite an action packed episode like Ayushmann said.

Harshits antara was really beautiful like Shaan said...Anwesha was very good in the duet round...and medley was great too 👏
To comment on the whole rahul neeti thing: At first i have to say that in my opinion Rahul did an outstanding fantastic job, he really deserved singer of the day.
And about Neeti...when i saw the trailer this week, at first i didnt notice Neeti forgot the lyrics...only when Shaan said it...i watched it back and then i saw it yes. But Rahul managed and covered it up beautifully just like all the judges said...it was an amazing performance.
i can understand Neeti as shankars team had 2 competitions in a row.
What Shankar said was true: they could have just stopped singing or black out and just keep standing there...but they didnt.
BUT all the things Shaan said after Shankar were also true. Forgetting lyrics and getting 10 is absolutely unfair! Then they all should sing: lalalala. Like Mohit said...they are judges and when they give less marks for bad sur or whatever they also should do it for forgetting lyrics. But i think they all gave 9 for Rahuls performance and like Himesh said they cut one point because of Neeti...which was right in my opinion.

It was actually a bit scary when Shaan and Mika went up to each other..and when they got into the audience i really thought everybody had lost it. It had gone too far and i was really shocked to see Shaan so angry. It was also a suprise when audience gave 7.5.

But well at the end they all apologised which was good. Shaan seems someone who is a nice and honest human being and its good that he fights for a fair match.



totally agree with you... I think the judges are experienced people they have seen thousands of singers and judged many reality shows.. everyone is entitled to their own opinion.. and rahul sang absolutely Beautifulll... it was his best performance, its not his fault that neeti messed up the song.. the judges saw everything and they gave marks according to what they thought was correct..the audience gave marks according to their own opinion... so there should not be any fight on that... because everyone has his own opinion..

and secondly, shankar has been given all the rights to come as many times as he wants.. its necessary for them to win each match, because voting is less for shankar, so for that he can employ any strategy he wants that is within the rules of the programme..HE DID NOT BREAK ANY RULE BY COMING ON STAGE TWICE..
sashb thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Shaan is the best captain..he is the only captain whop gives equal chance to all his singers even when Harshit is running through a bad phase..and I guess Shankar stooped too low yesterday to sing for 2 rounds...Also, what Shan said abt the lyrics was absolutely correct..in a competetion, everything should matter..If Sur and Tal matter then how come lyrics do not matter??
sandysri thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Since you were present in the studio, did they instruct the audience to act or was it all natural?
Since Shaan's wife was not at the studio for this episode looked like he knew what he had to do.
baghabayen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Everyone is talking about just shaan v/s shankar incident..nobody is putting any light on yesterday's performances.

Shadab with haazi ali is good.shankar's sapno se bhare naina is superb,outstanding performance,the best performance so far in this competition.I did not like harshit's performance in jugalbandi and rahul was so so.

Anwesha in DJ round was good,but i feel it could have been better,shankar's naach baliye is also a very good performance.

In much talked duet round i liked rahul and neetis PERFORMANCE but i preferred debo and anwesha's SINGING more,IMO singer of the day award should go to debo and anwesha.

This episode is not the best one in terms of singing all that i can say.
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: baghabayen

Everyone is talking about just shaan v/s shankar incident..nobody is putting any light on yesterday's performances.

Shadab with haazi ali is good.shankar's sapno se bhare naina is superb,outstanding performance,the best performance so far in this competition.I did not like harshit's performance in jugalbandi and rahul was so so.

Anwesha in DJ round was good,but i feel it could have been better,shankar's naach baliye is also a very good performance.

In much talked duet round i liked rahul and neetis PERFORMANCE but i preferred debo and anwesha's SINGING more,IMO singer of the day award should go to debo and anwesha.

This episode is not the best one in terms of singing all that i can say.



Shankar's both performances were simplyyyyyy out-standing...
i liked anwesha's performance, but yes i agree it could have been better, she seemed nervous today.. Rahul's singing in the duet round was justttt amazinggggg... i loved every bit of his singing in it.. and i think he was clearly deserving the Singer of the day award this time.. anwesha was not up to the mark today so i dont think today was her day to get the singer of the day...
in terms of singing, it was a greaatttt episode because we got to see shankar ji's great performance twice and it was an honour.. but that whole drama was too upsetting, destroyed the entire mood of the show... but overall, a good, thrilling episode i must say..
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Love to see Majority supports justice and honesty..Shaan u rock and won lots of hearts..
chinky801 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

Love to see Majority supports justice and honesty..Shaan u rock and won lots of hearts..



Shaan u rock and u won many hearts and u also earn respect..

Unlike Shankar just won another match, lost the loyal respect that he was getting from the viewers.

He might go down as one of the elite singers , but as human point of view , he lost it

WE LOVE U SHAAN
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: t2004sachin



Shaan u rock and u won many hearts and u also earn respect..

Unlike Shankar just won another match, lost the loyal respect that he was getting from the viewers.

He might go down as one of the elite singers , but as human point of view , he lost it

WE LOVE U SHAAN



Hmmm POV for shaan is true..he really won lots of respect from d people..
navaneeta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Shaan's POV was ethical and honest ....
- A duet (in a competition) has to be duet where both the singer get to sing lines properly ....
- Captain coming in each round and singing actually brings down morale of the other upcoming singers .... if they are marked against captains, irrespective of what they sang ... they will not be judged on fair ground ....
Winning is important ... but using unfair means and underestimating own's team singers and captain singing songs and not giving members chance makes the show very bad .....
There is no POV of judge ..... they were very much AGAINST Shaan ....
In duet ... 5 marks should be for male and 5 marks for female .. maybe Rahul gets full 5 for his good performance, but Neeti should not get full 5 or even 4 for her part ... right ... so net net even if Rahul gets 5 and Neet gets max to max 2.5 ... so 7.5 should be the score ... which was exactly the avg by audience .....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".