Embarrassing revelation of truth by Mika ,Shankar

Wanted or not Truth comes out.Mika accepted today that both Sharib anf Debojeet were given 10 marks only because creating the Mahool and there were lots of mistakes in Sur while Ameya was completely in sur in such hard songs and every judge did knew that still he was not given marks.

And Himesh is such a #### .Suddenly he realize that sur is important and now he will give marks based on sur . 😡

Even Shankar accepted that they are ignoring the sur in aamne saamne and other rounds,

Does these guys have any respect at all while sitting as judges or they think audience will believe blindly whatever they says since they are accomplished person in music industry.

It's Shame ,due to these guys people like Ameya never get their due recognization..

i agree
it's music so it has to be about sur not moohal or performance

Originally posted by: KaJen1

i agree
it's music so it has to be about sur not moohal or performance

The thing is even if u are judging based on other things ,these should be same throughout the show and for different participant ,so they clearly know what is expected from them.
And most importantly they should tell the audience on what basis they are judging so that audience who can't judge the sur specially in classical music ,should not feel that some one sang bad even though he might have sung very good.

In short stop fooling the audience.😡

I can tell that all the judges on this show are biased. Shankar looks like he is giving right marks but he is cunning and is also giving wrong marks.

Originally posted by: labamba

Wanted or not Truth comes out.Mika accepted today that both Sharib anf Debojeet were given 10 marks only because creating the Mahool and there were lots of mistakes in Sur while Ameya was completely in sur in such hard songs and every judge did knew that still he was not given marks.

And Himesh is such a #### .Suddenly he realize that sur is important and now he will give marks based on sur . 😡

Even Shankar accepted that they are ignoring the sur in aamne saamne and other rounds,

Does these guys have any respect at all while sitting as judges or they think audience will believe blindly whatever they says since they are accomplished person in music industry.

It's Shame ,due to these guys people like Ameya never get their due recognization..

Well said, I posted the same thing in the poll topic I made for Sharib. A lot of people are hating on Ameya, but he is 100% right, he knows how bad the sur was in Sharib's performance and that is what ticked him off. How can Sharib's singing be the best in the entire show (as said by Himesh) when the main thing about singing, sur, is not correct. The judges are so partial when it comes to Shaan or Shankar's team.

Himesh is BS........he doesn't what sur is and the only thing that comes out of his mouth is "when u look at this episode on tv, you'll know why i gave this marks" and all the crap about "all is well" on one of his episode......please i want to gage.........ridiculous!!!

Originally posted by: GujuGrl

Himesh is BS........he doesn't what sur is and the only thing that comes out of his mouth is "when u look at this episode on tv, you'll know why i gave this marks" and all the crap about "all is well" on one of his episode......please i want to gage.........ridiculous!!!

lol you forgot the josh and roti liners he keeps shouting.

Originally posted by: robinc07

Well said, I posted the same thing in the poll topic I made for Sharib. A lot of people are hating on Ameya, but he is 100% right, he knows how bad the sur was in Sharib's performance and that is what ticked him off. How can Sharib's singing be the best in the entire show (as said by Himesh) when the main thing about singing, sur, is not correct. The judges are so partial when it comes to Shaan or Shankar's team.

Agree. Sharib was off sur lot of times. The show is not "atmospere" ka maha mukabala but "Music ka maha Mukabala. And Sur is basic essence of music.

Its unfair to give marks depending on mahaul....some songs can createit some can't. You can't expect same effect as Ma from Bachna aai hasino( just giving example)....so is it okay to give contestant good marks for Maa even if he singing is worse than the otehr guy just because the song is touching?

Erm... we haven't gotten that far where I am. So that's a dissapointment. But these things should have been clarified at the beginning of the show dammit! Peformance yaan sur... Individual yaan group...

Cheers,
dc

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

voice quality anyone?

didnt hear any judges mention that as reason ..... still 7 out of 10 for singing in key?

n 10/10 for off key but dil ko chua?