Shaan is full of drama..! - Page 10

Originally posted by: sudhirm_2007

Its against rule.. This is a contest not an Award giving ceremony.. If Sachin tendulkar comes as a guest for junior cricket team match and a serious match then if suddenly he plays for one team definitely other team will object for it .. koi tamasha thodi i hai..

Originally posted by: shirani7

yes i agree but you are forgetting that sachin is a cricketer, but shahid isnt a singer! 😊

and why isnt anybody talkin about genelia?

bec gennillia dint sing ,she just kept her way so sweet as priyanka,uday,gennillia,sharuk and karan will too show soon,and vidya balan too

Originally posted by: purva

First of all... don't say sorry. I am all for healthy arguments. As far as there are no personal attacks I am fine with anybody not agreeing with me 😊

And now about the bold part.. I would have agreed with you if Shaan would have stopped Genelia from blowing kisses to the audiance or dancing while the group was performing.. then it would have been accoding to the rules. Also when he was given option by Himmy to give 8 points for singing or 10 points for performance.. he would have said 8 if he was going by rules.. or maybe 9 to make it fair... no?? But there all his fairness went for a toss and he said 10 😉😆

OK in the spirit of debate.

1. Shaan got Genelia's help AFTER Mohit had got Shahid's help and it was all approved. Shaan had thought Mohit would get an unfair advantage. But since the producers allowed it, Shaan used Genelia to gain some advantage too. Thats fair.

2. I was talking about the episode in which Shaan showed that he did not want to unnecessarily bring down other teams. Look at this video, especially the part where HR asks Shaan to rate Abhas: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJEMdiw0PHs&feature=related

Originally posted by: xobile

OK in the spirit of debate.

1. Shaan got Genelia's help AFTER Mohit had got Shahid's help and it was all approved. Shaan had thought Mohit would get an unfair advantage. But since the producers allowed it, Shaan used Genelia to gain some advantage too. Thats fair.

2. I was talking about the episode in which Shaan showed that he did not want to unnecessarily bring down other teams. Look at this video, especially the part where HR asks Shaan to rate Abhas: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJEMdiw0PHs&feature=related

Originally posted by: xobile

OK in the spirit of debate.

1. Shaan got Genelia's help AFTER Mohit had got Shahid's help and it was all approved. Shaan had thought Mohit would get an unfair advantage. But since the producers allowed it, Shaan used Genelia to gain some advantage too. Thats fair.

2. I was talking about the episode in which Shaan showed that he did not want to unnecessarily bring down other teams. Look at this video, especially the part where HR asks Shaan to rate Abhas: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJEMdiw0PHs&feature=related

Originally posted by: shirani7

Hi! im sorry but you are wrong with your first note. It wasnt after shahids help it was BEFORE. Im watching it all over now, it was with anweshas performance and also with harshits performance, she was blowing kisses and whatever and shahid was like: that isnt fair yaar, i cant do that ...so he asked shreya to come because they needed some lady luck but ofcourse then shreya didnt come. And then shaan HIMSELF said that maybe if shahid would sing he could also get a kiss from genelia. Ofcourse it was all a joke and everything so thats why i didnt understand why shaan became angry. You can watch the episode yourself...

Ohh i was talking about the medley rounds. Shaan sed that they shouldn't have Shahid singing and performing in the medley round. But they did so Shaan did too.

BUT i take your point. Shaan showed inconsistency by first using Genelia to get audience votes and then preventing the other team from using Shahid.

My only response is that somehow I still don't feel like Shaan is a bad/insincere/non-genuine guy. I do agree that he was being a bit dramebaz but I think it's OK for him to get a little pent up at times in a competitive situation. The lack of an objective and fair jury can be quite frustrating.

From what I've seen of him on TV, I think he's a cool guy. One mistake won't change my feeling. Especially becoz he never got personal - he dint say anything about Mohit, Mohit's team or Shahid - he was just arguing on principle. Of course it seems he was being a bit inconcsistent himself. But at least he didnt badmouth or namecall others to make his inconsistent points.

Well if you've just started wathcing the show and taht too because you saw a cute guy I don't think you have the right to comment

Originally posted by: purva

1. Nope... Genelia blowing kisses was BEFORE Shahid helping Mohit. She even mentioned that those kisses are for more points.. don't know what power she was using there but why was that not against the rules for Shaan who wants the rules to be followed all the time?

2. And what I am talking about here is Shaan vs. Mohit which was shown in US yesterday.. out of 8 and 10 points.. which points are of leniency? Obviously 10.. Shaan asked for 10 points when Himesh asked him how much to give and then he was questioning Amey's points.. so much for fairness 👎🏼

I understood your first point and I've already replied to it when I replied to another person raising the same issue.

And, honestly, I cannot understand your second point at all. So I'll have to ignore its precise details and give a general response:

In a very old comment I said that Shaan does NOT try to put rival teams down. And my example was the Abhas example (for which I later posted a link to a video). If you disagree with me on this point, and if you think Shaan DOES put rival teams down then you probably have your reasons too.

^^^This person Meena always butts in to create a controversy

Originally posted by: safeenafarheen

And to those people whom i blasted shankar just to check there too at the very first too i was in support of my those fav after shaan and shreya it was shankar..and i point him from the very first show itself shankar is talented singer,but that above person has to go through that he compare shankar and he destryed shaan as much he can with shaan haters and annoyed shaan fans,i like shankar but never much attractable with his team,this was my very first comment and still to those fake members,who caused my thought in to fake manner..,ha ha..