D iverse thoughts engulfed my mind, listening to a Mohammed Rafi CD, when the sonorous strains of the immortal Noorjehan-Rafi duet from Jugnu, Yahan badla wafa ka (1947) wafted through. It was 60 years ago that he sang this duet with Noorjehan...only for her to migrate to Pakistan soon after. The battle of the crooners While reading Kishore Kumar's biography Method in Madness by Derek Bose, I came across a sentence wherein he con- tends, "…in 1969, Kishore Kumar displaced Mukesh, Mohammed Rafi, Talat Mehmood and Man- na Dey at one stroke with Arad- hana, and since then, ruled as the indisputable king…" It may be therapeutic, even prof- itable for an author to place his biographical subject on a pedestal. But anyone with moderate knowl- edge of the subject would dismiss such a claim as preposterous. It is not that Aradhana or the Burmans had rescued Kishore from obscurity He had at least one . hit every year preceding Arad- hana (1969). If in 1968 there was Mere saamnewali khidki mein (Padosan), there was also Yeh dil na hota bechara (Jewel Thief) in 1967. In 1969 itself, Kishore had three other solos which were equally well-received—Mere naseeb mein (Do Raaste), Wo shaam kuch ajeeb thi (Khamoshi) and Tum bin jaaun kahan (Pyaar ka Mausam). Long before Aradhana, Talat Mehmood had faded into oblivion: his last major hit was Jahan Ara in 1964. From 1964 to 1969, he had sung just ten songs. Mukesh had been identified with the voice of Raj Kapoor, whose acting career faded after Sangam (1964). Nevertheless, a study I undertook, threw up some incredible statistics: in the five years preceding Aradhana, Mukesh sang 138 songs. In the five years that followed, he sang 139 songs. Between 1970 and '76, he even picked up three Filmfare Awards! Manna Dey was identified with Raj Kapoor and Mehmood...was the foremost choice for the classi- cal and qawwali numbers. He won the Filmfare Award for Mera Naam Joker in 1971. From 1970 to 1980, Rafi sang 1258 songs; Kishore 1266. If 1969 is tak- en into consideration, Rafi's out- put is higher. He sang 190 songs and Kishore 20. The decline The decline in Rafi's songs can be attributed to Shammi Kapoor, Johnny Walker, Dilip Kumar and Rajendra Kumar's deserting film careers, the decline in OP Nayyar, Ravi, Shankar-Jaik- ishen and Chitragupta's compo- sitions (they contribute 25 per cent of Rafi's Hindi film songs), RD Burman's ascendancy and after Padosan, Kishore Kumar's high concentration on singing. Before subscribing to Bose's view, give an ear to Rafi's reso- nance in his last Filmfare and National Award-winning song Kya hua tera vaada. Rafi's diver- sity ingrained him as the monarch of Hindi playback. None of this detracts Kishore Kumar as a singer. Remember Rafi was trained in classical music but Kishore wasn't. Even today, not a day passes without Rafi's songs being played. FM stations too, remember to play them when they take some time off from playing inane remixes.