unbelieveable cast in devdas!! - do check!! - Page 37

Created

Last reply

Replies

388

Views

23k

Users

75

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

441597 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: SRK_fanatic


Again an epic fail after trying to attempt sarcasm by a person who doesnt even know the S of saracsm🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
awww poor thing didnt even understand that 🥱....he meant he never wanted to accept his wife's death ...so was living in denial hence never even glanced through her death certifictae even once 😊...Dont torture ur brain more trying to understand the vulnerability of Mayank's emotions and how effortlessly the actor has potrayed it 😳....AS some fans have become brain dumb after watching expressionless actors and their pure love story for 2 yrs 😲 now that they even fail to understand even basic human logics & emotions😭😛....You cant flaunt something u dont have-lack of wit ,humour & sarcasm being the case here aaww pity 😭

😆
This is what i'd call Spurious Double-talk!😆😆
You don't need to pay exactly a LOT OF ATTENTION to figure out on-spot that someone who had an ACCIDENT cannot die of fire.Embarrassed
Also, as per your claims of "Logistics and understanding " of human emotions go, tell me how Nupur's survival remained unknown to her family for THREE years? Is it possible, under any circumstances? And how come a living pateint got randomly exchanged for a Burnt dead body under the supervision of Docs and Nurses, and a totally different person was scuttled off to a trauma centre....explain that part, please.Tongue
Honestly -you know people should really learn to accept faults and shortcomings even of their Favourite pair.....and i think its rich of you to accuse others of lacking logical sense when you yourself lack the ability to take criticism impartially.
At the end -i'll reiterate..."This SG DEVDAS thingy is hideously illogical no doubt, but that dosen't make Nupur's "alive" state Logical either"
Peace out.😃
SRK_fanatic thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

😆
This is what i'd call Spurious Double-talk!😆😆
You don't need to pay exactly a LOT OF ATTENTION to figure out on-spot that someone who had an ACCIDENT cannot die of fire.😳
Also, as per your claims of "Logistics and understanding " of human emotions go, tell me how Nupur's survival remained unknown to her family for THREE years? Is it possible, under any circumstances? And how come a living pateint got randomly exchanged for a Burnt dead body under the supervision of Docs and Nurses, and a totally different person was scuttled off to a trauma centre....explain that part, please.😛
Honestly -you know people should really learn to accept faults and shortcomings even of their Favourite pair.....and i think its rich of you to accuse others of lacking logical sense when you yourself lack the ability to take criticism impartially.
At the end -i'll reiterate..."This SG DEVDAS thingy is hideously illogical no doubt, but that dosen't make Nupur's "alive" state Logical either"
Peace out.😃


Jesus! who is claiming Nupur's comeback was a logical one 😆...I m just laughing at the inability of some fans to point out the logical errors...Yea what u said made sense...but not the earlier post...She should have mentioned the stupidity of the particular scene where doctor was mentioning the reason for Nupur being alive...Instead she goes on criticising Mayank's dialogue which was the only thing that made sense in the entire scenario😉..And I was ONLY talking about Mayank's emotions she made fun of...Not the crap doctor was mouthing about the bodies being exchanged & all....& SEEING HER second response its even more clear how matured & well thought out her previous reply was as well...😃 So didnt bother explaining my POV but since I can see you are not some blind fanatic- ie criticise a hideous paroo as well as a sill bringing back from death track-I m replying back to u
Edited by SRK_fanatic - 15 years ago
riteshhere thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Well I did not go thru whole like 50 pages of this post.
Only wanted to put my view.
I really do not understand since when we started to talk about logic in MJHT and people started feeling bad when illogical stuff is shown. Because we love many things in MJHT which are most illogical in real life.
I do not know if topic maker had check the episodes when drama was being planned. It was not planned for students to showcase their talent. It was planned ONLY because Samrat wanted to try to make Gunjan happy and drama was one part of it. It was Samrat and Mayank's idea of the same plan to make Gunjan Paro. As for Devdas, Rohan was doing his role but he was not able to do that good, so Mayank was Devdas as he showed them how brilliantly he can act and everybody thought he shoud be Devdas. (So Trustee had no role in drama which is topic maker's main concern). Now when Mayank did not appear for the role and Gunjan's old stage fears came back, then Samrat decided to go and play Devdas so as Gunjan can be relaxed. I guess that explains trustee being hero of the drama in college (which was NOT AT ALL planned to showcase students' talent).
Till now we have loved many illogical things in MJHT (Like MayUr going in jungle to find highway when they could have followed the same detoured road they came from to reach highway or playing dumb charades in National Student Talent competition or SaJan getting engaged without any of their parents all of a sudden and all). But we have never paid any attention to such illogical things. Also, the biggest illogical thing in MJHT right now is Nupur returning after 3 years if we are talking about logic. (Believe me, I love Nupur and I am very happy and I also have played my part in the efforts to bring her back. So, please do not categorize me). But let us face it, it is illogical which happens only in unbelievable daily soaps. But we are most happy for that because we are getting what we wanted.
So why people are so concerned about one illogical thing when there are many other illogical things that they love by all their heart.
P.S.: My POV. We all love MJHT with all its faults.
aashizin thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: riteshhere

Well I did not go thru whole like 50 pages of this post.
Only wanted to put my view.
I really do not understand since when we started to talk about logic in MJHT and people started feeling bad when illogical stuff is shown. Because we love many things in MJHT which are most illogical in real life.
I do not know if topic maker had check the episodes when drama was being planned. It was not planned for students to showcase their talent. It was planned ONLY because Samrat wanted to try to make Gunjan happy and drama was one part of it. It was Samrat and Mayank's idea of the same plan to make Gunjan Paro. As for Devdas, Rohan was doing his role but he was not able to do that good, so Mayank was Devdas as he showed them how brilliantly he can act and everybody thought he shoud be Devdas. (So Trustee had no role in drama which is topic maker's main concern). Now when Mayank did not appear for the role and Gunjan's old stage fears came back, then Samrat decided to go and play Devdas so as Gunjan can be relaxed. I guess that explains trustee being hero of the drama in college (which was NOT AT ALL planned to showcase students' talent).
Till now we have loved many illogical things in MJHT (Like MayUr going in jungle to find highway when they could have followed the same detoured road they came from to reach highway or playing dumb charades in National Student Talent competition or SaJan getting engaged without any of their parents all of a sudden and all). But we have never paid any attention to such illogical things. Also, the biggest illogical thing in MJHT right now is Nupur returning after 3 years if we are talking about logic. (Believe me, I love Nupur and I am very happy and I also have played my part in the efforts to bring her back. So, please do not categorize me). But let us face it, it is illogical which happens only in unbelievable daily soaps. But we are most happy for that because we are getting what we wanted.
So why people are so concerned about one illogical thing when there are many other illogical things that they love by all their heart.
P.S.: My POV. We all love MJHT with all its faults.

oww ritesh i am proud of u yar you r one of rati fan and still u put ur real pov here i am really glad abt it 👏 👏 👏 u have a guts to accept the truth , actually this is fiction show and we know na anything can be happened in it and u gave examples r also part of the show and yup not only this examples but many others r there also but as u said we love mjht with its fault bcz mjht is show which has given us superb and magical our fav couple whom we love ,thanks for sharing ur pov 😳
Edited by aashizin - 15 years ago
MagicLantern thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: DiyaS

Sadly I haven't watched mandi & paar '.... Naseeruddin Shah( loved the way he potrayed the comman man in his films''..i used to really like his films costarring farooq shaikh ) and Shabana Azmi are gods when it comes to acting'''.....I am not into dark movies.... cause I tend to get too involved & it affects me badly so I avoid such movies.......but I luckily caught up with mausam ''initially I was quite reluctant to do so ( after I got to know the premise of the movie) but I am glad I succumbed to it .........I cursed myself for giving it a miss all these years I happened to watch it just recently(what really got me to watch it was sharmila & gulzar ..........I am a big fan of their work)I am wanting to catch up with agoor & jaane bhi do yaaro ( have heard gr8 things about them)since a long time.......hopefully I will catch up with them one of these days

loved tzp 3 idiots wake up sid & wednesday amongst the recent films...............I am also a big fan of romatnic films.........my kind of films are ddlj, kkhh, dil hai ke maanta nahin,qsqt, hum hai rahi pyaar ke, lamhe,chandni well its a long list.....I love romantic & hrishekesh mukerji's movies & any film starring kajol & sharmila tagore( loved mausam , amar prem ,aaradhna ,safar , satyakaam) .........my major complain with the filmmakers is that they don't make good love stories any longer'''.hated most of the romantic films recently barring jwm

I really love sajan's love story's .........that's the major reason that has got me hooked on to mjht..........its definitely tv's best love story for me..........sanaya mohit rock as gunjan & samrat



you know, sonu, i f you like romantic movies with a difference, there are two you should watch if you can ... little known gems with Amitabh Raakhee ... another couple I really love ... Bemisaal and Jurmana ... very hatke love stories ... not the usual simple romantic ones. Another very interesting one was a movie called Basera with Shashi kapoor, Raakhee and Rekha ... love stories with very unusual twists, no simple black and white, but really making you think.

N me too love Sajan's love story ... it' started off as such a cliched love story and has evolved into such a beautiful one ... it's the best tv love story for me and I'm loving this track ... just hope they end it well, cos the cv's have a strong track record of messing up endings.

Hey thanks divya......... i will definitely try &catch up with the above mentioned movies.........i have seen basera but the end was quite tragic..........

Rakhee I believe is a phenomenal actress (I am taking my mothers word for this ….she is a big fan of her work)

What I like most about sajan is that the smallest things be it the bracelet, chain or flowers held so much significance……….love the whole essence of their relationship

charmie_mayur thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: riteshhere

Well I did not go thru whole like 50 pages of this post.
Only wanted to put my view.
I really do not understand since when we started to talk about logic in MJHT and people started feeling bad when illogical stuff is shown. Because we love many things in MJHT which are most illogical in real life.
I do not know if topic maker had check the episodes when drama was being planned. It was not planned for students to showcase their talent. It was planned ONLY because Samrat wanted to try to make Gunjan happy and drama was one part of it. It was Samrat and Mayank's idea of the same plan to make Gunjan Paro. As for Devdas, Rohan was doing his role but he was not able to do that good, so Mayank was Devdas as he showed them how brilliantly he can act and everybody thought he shoud be Devdas. (So Trustee had no role in drama which is topic maker's main concern). Now when Mayank did not appear for the role and Gunjan's old stage fears came back, then Samrat decided to go and play Devdas so as Gunjan can be relaxed. I guess that explains trustee being hero of the drama in college (which was NOT AT ALL planned to showcase students' talent).
Till now we have loved many illogical things in MJHT (Like MayUr going in jungle to find highway when they could have followed the same detoured road they came from to reach highway or playing dumb charades in National Student Talent competition or SaJan getting engaged without any of their parents all of a sudden and all). But we have never paid any attention to such illogical things. Also, the biggest illogical thing in MJHT right now is Nupur returning after 3 years if we are talking about logic. (Believe me, I love Nupur and I am very happy and I also have played my part in the efforts to bring her back. So, please do not categorize me). But let us face it, it is illogical which happens only in unbelievable daily soaps. But we are most happy for that because we are getting what we wanted.
So why people are so concerned about one illogical thing when there are many other illogical things that they love by all their heart.
P.S.: My POV. We all love MJHT with all its faults.






OH COMMON DEAR!! sam n mayank cannot plan a play just for gunjan!!plz do think! gunjan is not a student!! nor they can plan things like dis to make a single person happy!! at least not a college play!! for a teacher!!! anyways it's no use explaining some of u coz.......... ......... oh just let it be!! 😕 😕 😕
kuhu_cullen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
one more thing, that was supposed to be a dress rehersal.................................with mayu as devdas.......... how come sam knew all the dialouges??????????? chalo yeh jane do. agar dress rehersal tha, y audience????? was it the final play?
may be im wrong.......................plz if so, correct me.
aa123.80 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: surilee_mayur

one more thing, that was supposed to be a dress rehersal.................................with mayu as devdas.......... how come sam knew all the dialouges??????????? chalo yeh jane do. agar dress rehersal tha, y audience????? was it the final play?

may be im wrong.......................plz if so, correct me.



No, this wasn't s dress rehearsal at all. It was the final play.
And as for Samrat knowing the lines, didn't you see him rehearsing scenes with Gunjan? Plus, she had explained the whole story to him... So obviously, he knew everything. And he attended the rehearsals going on in college.
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: aa123.80



No, this wasn't s dress rehearsal at all. It was the final play.
And as for Samrat knowing the lines, didn't you see him rehearsing scenes with Gunjan? Plus, she had explained the whole story to him... So obviously, he knew everything. And he attended the rehearsals going on in college.

guys common..........now lets stop.......mjht mein bloopers hi bloopers hain........strating to end.......from mayur to sajan to dia and udaY to benji......all have got illogical things many time.........lets end this discussion now......😛
wickedangel thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
gosh cant believe people are still crying over illogical and unbelievable things when the biggest illogical and cliched track is about to start in mjht🤣....I think instead of discussing how wierd it is for teacher to act in a college play lets talk about a person coming back from dead😆....in my opinion that has a more shocking value🤣....I mean seriously people after the whole coming back from dead thing because of bodies getting switched in the accident can we still worry about the logic in a college play..🤣..
my question is okay so they told this nupur's family that her body was burned but what about the other nupur's family😕....did they not recognize her face🤔...or was it a mass amnesia thing😲🤣.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".