unbelieveable cast in devdas!! - do check!! - Page 35

Originally posted by: loving_bird

lolzzz kavya rightly said it .......but i need to add everytime MN were critised i myself had made many post of criticism on them offcourse pointing to creatives ....

it here again point is on creatives where they went wrong in there thought process .......
liking of couple part is different thing altogether.
it must be a treat to watch it for u guys just that don't ignore those part which doesn't make any sense.........
i had a good laughter reading that that topic starter post clicked like button & ended that matter ...it was creative part wrong.....they had to think before going .had laugh & ened that matter

i really don't know why MN were dragged here.....everytime i see that if some MN fan write something a little bit also whole MN story whole MN r dragged ....

that more reason why i try to ignore these topics as MN fans whole MN than will be dragged....just bcoz of one reply of mine.........( i can't state for others everyone has individual thoughts)

i wanted to reply to this last nyt itself, but my net......

it's not that anyone of us ignored our creative genie's or something, it's jus a matter of priority....we do criticize, that's what we are doing even now....but then, we are not going to stop loving the illogical tracks/scenes for our selfish reasons

n cmng to MN...i agree that this topic was mis-understood in the begining n it's quite common for two reasons.....Sg are the leads in the play n TS has mayur on his/her ID n the 2nd one.....this topic should have been started on the very firs day when they said seniors are are the leads in the play n not y'day, when actual play started.....
n again this topic being a criticism thread for CVs...n not for MN/SG.....so every character, couple are brought in, jus to show the logical talent of our CVs....n in my view, this is common with all starone CVs, not jus MJHT

Originally posted by: aa123.80

I think you missed the part where Dev went to London for studies and came back. That's where the movie also started. Then Dev left Paro, she got married to another man, and he comes back.

Ishita, in the original Sarat chandra story, Dev goes only to Kolkata ... the London bit was the modern adaptation by Bhansali. Dev Paro were in love in childhood, when Dev came back from kolkata, her mother approached his, his parents refused because Paro was of lower caste/status, Paro then comes at night to ask Dev to marry her ... Dev can't defy his parents ... and he leaves her. Paro's mother arranges her marriage, Dev returns too late ... the weak hero of many of SCC's novels ... Paro is married off to a wealthier older man ... Dev takes to drinking ... meets Chandramukhi ... she falls in love with him, but he never clearly reciprocates ... drinks himself to death, but as he's dying, he returns to Paro to die at her doorstep ... that's Devdas in a nutshell.

diya, thanks for devdas story in short
bcoz frm yesterday, i was confused @diff devdas stories i was getting to hear
n i'm glad, the story which i actually know is the original one.....thye jus can't get the originality of old movies despite of all new techniques, sophisticated sets etc etc

Originally posted by: ght_sajan

Sanjeev kumar was the finest actor the Indian film industry ever saw'''I loved him in koshish ' he got into the skin of every character he essayed

Have you seen mausam staring sharmila tagore & sanjeev kumar it was another masterpiece 'it had two of the most amazing actors( sharmila tagore being my favorite)'''...directed by the very talented gulzar

It's sad that gulzar doesn't make films any longer''''..I loved his mausam & koshish''they were masterpieces ''.certain filmmakers really need to learn a thing or two about filmmaking from him'.today things are all so commercial'. filmmakers lack sincerity these days '''.I don't see them being very passionate about the craft of filmmaking all they are interested in is moneymaking except for a few exceptions like raju hirani & aamir khan etc'.they are those few people who don't underestimate the sensibilities of the viewers & truly believe in dishing out good stuff

As far as illogical tracks being dished out from the cv's ,''. I don't think it bothers me any longer as I have sadly accepted it & learn to deal with it'''.it's a mad race every body is running after trps'.so things like logic goes flying out of the window

I like this discussion better than the main one 🤣 Okay, returning to great actors ... watch Naseeruddin Shah and Shabana Azmi in three different movies ... Masoom, Mandi and Paar ... what a RANGE!!!!!

and speaking of Sanjeev kumar ... yes, I've seen Mausam ... AWESOME movie ... Sharmila was fabulous both as the shy girl and as her own daughter, the prostitute ... again, what a range!!
Have you seen Angoor ... Sanjeev Kumar, Moushumi Chatterjee and Deven Verma ... based on Shakespeare's A Comedy of Errors??? HILARIOUS movie!!!

Well, we are getting some decent movies now ... in the middle there were only masala ... A Wednesday was a great movie, 3 idiots of course, I even liked Wake up Sid recently ... so there's some hope.

Originally posted by: kavya.b

i wanted to reply to this last nyt itself, but my net......

it's not that anyone of us ignored our creative genie's or something, it's jus a matter of priority....we do criticize, that's what we are doing even now....but then, we are not going to stop loving the illogical tracks/scenes for our selfish reasons

n cmng to MN...i agree that this topic was mis-understood in the begining n it's quite common for two reasons.....Sg are the leads in the play n TS has mayur on his/her ID n the 2nd one.....this topic should have been started on the very firs day when they said seniors are are the leads in the play n not y'day, when actual play started.....
n again this topic being a criticism thread for CVs...n not for MN/SG.....so every character, couple are brought in, jus to show the logical talent of our CVs....n in my view, this is common with all starone CVs, not jus MJHT

luv u kavya!!!!!! u have always been so supportive

My answer in one line---- Aisa Devdas kahin nahi dekha hai 😕 Blame goes to Cvs...

I don't mind...as long as SaJanians are enjoying it>>>

I like this discussion better than the main one 🤣 Okay, returning to great actors ... watch Naseeruddin Shah and Shabana Azmi in three different movies ... Masoom, Mandi and Paar ... what a RANGE!!!!!

and speaking of Sanjeev kumar ... yes, I've seen Mausam ... AWESOME movie ... Sharmila was fabulous both as the shy girl and as her own daughter, the prostitute ... again, what a range!!
Have you seen Angoor ... Sanjeev Kumar, Moushumi Chatterjee and Deven Verma ... based on Shakespeare's A Comedy of Errors??? HILARIOUS movie!!!

Well, we are getting some decent movies now ... in the middle there were only masala ... A Wednesday was a great movie, 3 idiots of course, I even liked Wake up Sid recently ... so there's some hope.

Sadly I haven't watched mandi & paar ….... Naseeruddin Shah( loved the way he potrayed the comman man in his films……..i used to really like his films costarring farooq shaikh ) and Shabana Azmi are gods when it comes to acting……….....I am not into dark movies.... cause I tend to get too involved & it affects me badly so I avoid such movies.......but I luckily caught up with mausam ……initially I was quite reluctant to do so ( after I got to know the premise of the movie) but I am glad I succumbed to it .........I cursed myself for giving it a miss all these years I happened to watch it just recently(what really got me to watch it was sharmila & gulzar ..........I am a big fan of their work)I am wanting to catch up with agoor & jaane bhi do yaaro ( have heard gr8 things about them)since a long time.......hopefully I will catch up with them one of these days

loved tzp 3 idiots wake up sid & wednesday amongst the recent films...............I am also a big fan of romatnic films.........my kind of films are ddlj, kkhh, dil hai ke maanta nahin,qsqt, hum hai rahi pyaar ke, lamhe,chandni well its a long list.....I love romantic & hrishekesh mukerji's movies & any film starring kajol & sharmila tagore( loved mausam , amar prem ,aaradhna ,safar , satyakaam) .........my major complain with the filmmakers is that they don't make good love stories any longer……….hated most of the romantic films recently barring jwm

I really love sajan's love story's .........that's the major reason that has got me hooked on to mjht..........its definitely tv's best love story for me..........sanaya mohit rock as gunjan & samrat

Originally posted by: DiyaS

Ishita, in the original Sarat chandra story, Dev goes only to Kolkata ... the London bit was the modern adaptation by Bhansali. Dev Paro were in love in childhood, when Dev came back from kolkata, her mother approached his, his parents refused because Paro was of lower caste/status, Paro then comes at night to ask Dev to marry her ... Dev can't defy his parents ... and he leaves her. Paro's mother arranges her marriage, Dev returns too late ... the weak hero of many of SCC's novels ... Paro is married off to a wealthier older man ... Dev takes to drinking ... meets Chandramukhi ... she falls in love with him, but he never clearly reciprocates ... drinks himself to death, but as he's dying, he returns to Paro to die at her doorstep ... that's Devdas in a nutshell.

Thank you so much Diya....Ok.So in the movie they changed it to London. And maybe the CVs tried to copy the movie. The rest is the same..... And yesterday, I think they were trying to show the scene where Paro asks Dev to marry her and not go away......

u r absolutely right such a poor college where students have no oppurtunities in extracuricular activities