Mohit as Devdas Outranks Arjun - Page 7

Originally posted by: myownarea

I think comparison invites comparison ...so if she says she found mohit great and ended it there..no one would really say otherwise...but when u compare with another actor, there are bound to be people who feel the other person is better (here , the majority...hence its called bashing...but really how can we define bashing given the topic itself invited it? )

I dont think anybody has ever opened a post saying Arjun was better than moh..it in XYZ scene ....cos that is what INVITES comparison...After comparing, u cant crib that the others dont agree..

What she meant, I dont know...but what came across is not agreeable to many.

I agree its best to avoid comparison....
everybody has their opinion and POV... I respect that...

In lighetr vein I should the trp of the forum rises for such topics :-)

Guys, I totally understand why you may find thsi topic bad and all..but PLEASE, just read the first sentence - Sonya herself stated clearly that she finds Arjun a GREAT actor, even better than Mohit - And I think all of us agree..cause Arjun has more experience and all, and he really is a good actor !!!
I mean, come one, she didnt mean it in that way !!!! and your misunderstanding the topic purposely!!!
please guysss stop it !!!
I sincerely request that !! please!!!

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

I have said it before, and I say it yet again for those who have short-term memory loss problem: Arjun is a complete actor. I like his acting a lot. As per my view, Mohit was no match to Arjun when season 1 began. Needless to say, experience is an excellent asset when it comes to learning. In season two, they were good match to each other. But, in those two particular scenes, Mohit outranked Arjun. Now I wasn't taught by any book to follow the majority opinion even if it is biased or prejudiced.

Let me also clear it out that this topic is not "Mohit Vs. Arjun!" I'm talking about the performance of the two characters in the two scenes. I have stated my reasons for thinking so.

Oh as to why I said outranked Arjun. It's because they both were shown doing the same scene.

My advice: Don't waste your time in posting your disagreements if it is driven by the sole reason of "I'm a mayurian, and I can't see anyone above Mayank." I mean seriously....!

@ bold - So far i agree.......................and as u said like Mohit evolved, so did Arjun, so he was always a notch or two ahead...............and neither were we taught in any book to follow other's opinion if i do not agree with it..................

and our disagreements are based on facts, and not just on our being a Mayurian ( though, today i m proud to be 1).....................

Our opinion is based on true judgement of an actor's talent and his performance, and not just based on blind love ......................

Yes this topic is no Arjun vs Mohit.

so when ppl say Mohit cannot act - don't waste your time in posting your disagreements if it is driven by the sole reason of considering the view of the majority as bashing! i mean seriously...if opened a topic one shud try to respect the view instead of stereotyping.

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

Annie, I'm sorry but I fail to understand your logic. You've said Arjun is way better than any other actor. So why am I to believe that? Because, you say so?

Did i say u have to believe that???? no, ur entitled to ur POV and i m to mine............and mind u, even if u dnt agree, i wnt think its bashing.................

So feel free, India is a free democracy.................

I think both were good………. mayank performed the solo scene better than the one he performed with gunjan in the canteen…..no prizes for guessing that sajan's is chemistry is far better than majans hence sam looked more convincing (manyank had to look less convincing coz he performed the scene with gunjan not nupur)……. I can't understand why mohit is labeled as a bad actor he's a pretty decent actor …….. arjun is a very good actor but mohit is not bad either………I agree arjun is a better actor but one department where mohit scores over arjun is his chemistry with his costars( I am sure people love his chemistry with arjun, rati, sanaya ,abhisehk,navina & jas karan)

Mohit , rati & abhisehk sharma are three people who share gr8 chemistry with all their costars now isn't that a sign of a good actor

Moreover its not easy to hold your ground against a talented actor like rati & mohit manages wonderfully so isn't that a sign of a good actor

So its my request stop bashing mohit unnecessarily……..one need not put mohit down to prove his or her point

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

I. As per my view, Mohit was no match to Arjun when season 1 began. Needless to say, experience is an excellent asset when it comes to learning. In season two, they were good match to each other. ....!

Originally posted by: annie07

LOL, exactly, as somebody said everyone has their own POV...............

so when the topic starter says Mohit is better than Arjun is sme XYZ scene............its her POV..................

MAJORITY do not agree, its their POV...................where is bashing............

Its not in MJHT's Preamble , that Mohit has to be worshipped by all...............

and i disagree with topic starter.................Arjun is way better than many actors on TV today.............and to come in same league as him, is kinda difficult.................

👏👏👏👏👏WOW ANNIE. U r so right....i always like your posts..u write tit for tat....u can become a great lawyer yaar
👏

Sonya whatever your logic is behind all of this, its just better to not make such instigatory posts, esp comparing the actors, be it just on one scene, its plain comparision which has hurt many people's emotions.

Why do something which would hurt others?

Sharing your views is one thing and hurting other with it is another!