Mohit as Devdas Outranks Arjun - Page 12

Originally posted by: annie07

Ah Anu, precisely my point.........................yes we will appreciate if we truly felt so....................infact MN fans have been one to bash their own favs, when they have not met the standards.............

I rem. Arjun being bashed badly for being blank in a scene.............so if i feel someone deserves appreciaton, i will appreciate that person..............

and as far as Mohit is concerned, i liked him all light-hearted comic scenes, masti scenes...................as far as emotional and romantic scenes are concerned, i think he has a long way to go.............

and thats my POV........................and so i disagree to the point made............

again its neither bashing nor fighting................its just not concurring to the statement made..............

I totally agree with the part about Mohits acting Annie !! totally true - and we ofcourse as fans, do try to find and try to appreciate if he has improved, especially in the emotional scenes..and yess, of course Mohit has a long way to go !!! nobody denies that !!

each one has their own opinion totally true !! but we felt ki he really has done amazingly well !! I totally respect your view !! and glad that NOW our discussion is over..finally I can study properly !! lolzzzzzz!! okay, final byee now !! =))

Okay Annie, if all you can say is "I disagree." You leave no room for discussion. It was good having you here. Hope to see you soon again in a topic where you'll have more to say.

Originally posted by: pandemonia3

Ok one thing..if u want to appreciate Mohit or MONAYA...why piggy back ride on the credentials of RP AB...every single time? There was no need to mention AB here...on the mere basis of seniority even, there is really NO COMPARISON between these two actors! Call it natural talent or experience, AB is a talented actor. Mohit has a long long way to go indeed. Just changing your hairstyle and wearing glasses doesn't automatically bestow people with talent and superior acting skills! Also in a lot of romantic scenes, Mohit has imbibed a considerable amount of the gestures and mannerisms that AB has perfected in HIS romantic scenes with RP. He's a good learner coz we all know AB is friends with him and AB must have given him some tips as a concerned senior. So my question remains: Aren't you guys doing some sort of disservice to Mohit by constantly comparing him to the other lead? I mean doesn't his talent, as seen by you people, deserve to be praised on its own merit? I also find it extremely laughable that RP is considered a good actor in order to bring out the shine in Mohit's acting when just a few months ago, her acting was dismissed as overacting/ OTT acting! I have just laid down my viewpoints in a very civil manner. I am entitled to these opinions of mine and I am NOT LIABLE to answer any challenges! So please do not bother quoting me!

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

Of course, I'm fine with others liking Arjun. I'd appreciate if you point out why you found Arjun more appealing. But, I'm certainly not fine with comments like, "This is the best joke of the Day" and not a word more than that, because that's plain jealousy. It's a pitty how people cannot overcome such base human characteristics.

i don't think u are fine with others liking arjun more...it's my pov...
anyways how the hell will i explain to u why me or majority of us like ab more....u haven't found him better as devdas & i m sure u won't....i m okay with that...but then u shoud b e okay with our pov as well.....as i said in my previous post we can't explain to u why we love him & his actings more
@bold: what else do u expect when u write the heading" mohit outranks arjun as devdas"...i know they could have written civily but the title was such that any normal fan would say this only....btw u never praised any mayur thing so how they will understand whatever intention u have..they will percieve u as loyal sg fan only na......but still they said correct arjun is better

LOL, ur topic newz has no room for discussion, coz its like a judgement passed.......................

and actually discussion starts, when two parties take different sides...................

btw, this forum, is a free place, so no1 can stop me from writing, til i m not breaking any rules, which i m not


@ on a note, i wonder where is Sonali...................... something which we all need to look into................

Goodness me sonya...I m sure if you had listened to your creative writing professor more carefully, he would have advised you to read a text more carefully so that you don't miss out on necessary details. You see such an aberration would lead to a failure in the objective of fruitful discussion which you claim is the purpose of this thread! If you HAD read the rest of my post you would have noticed my disclaimer that specially asks the forum members NOT TO QUOTE ME! Oooooops! I have highlighted this bit so that it catches your eyes as you once again skim through this post of mine DONT QUOTE ME! Goodnight!

Originally posted by: rakhiii89

Yes this topic is no Arjun vs Mohit.

so when ppl say Mohit cannot act - don't waste your time in posting your disagreements if it is driven by the sole reason of considering the view of the majority as bashing! i mean seriously...if opened a topic one shud try to respect the view instead of stereotyping.

Could you please explain what do you mean by stereotyping? I seriously fail to understand how am I stereotyping here?

I don't consider the view of the majority as bashing. In fact, I haven't even used the word 'basing' yet to your surprise. But, yes I do feel that I'm not bound to follow the majority blindly. And if the majority is respectful enough in sharing their views, you're welcome.

ummm.... did it ever occur that Arjun was supposed to down play....

He forgot the dialouges??? Since when does Mayank forget ?? He started off saying the dialouges and stopped in the middle... he knew Sam would pick it up....

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

Well Senny, I find those as boring topics. Once I was discussing my work with my creative writing professor. I told him, Professor I think good literature is that which generates discussion. Someone says Mayank-Nupur or Samrat-Gunjan is the best pair on the face of the earth. And, then tons of people agree to that passively. Such topics might be of your interest, but I'm least interested.

Well its better Sonya if we don't dwell into my interests and get personal. Lets stick to the discussion.

I certainly love intelligent topics.

But why are you discussing me again and again. Stick to defending your comparision posts please, I don't appreciate such personal discussions with people I hardly know!



Well Senny, I don't know much about you to discuss your personal
interests. I'd have to first ask if Senny is your name before I can
dwell in your personal life. Anyway, You said that I should create
topics like "Samrat's the best" and have a number of Samrat-Gunjan fans
agreeing with me. I told you that those are not the kinds of topics that
might possibly be of my interest regardless of how interesting they may
sound to you. I don't understand what made you think I was talking
about your personal interests.


As i say its not necessary that your words would be interpreted as you want them to be.

No do whatever you want, make any posts you want without stepping on others feelings. I respect them and this is the way this forum at least was once. I just said that Monaya fans stick to their fav and so is for Arti thus there are no war zones.

Your topic is now at least from my perception a warzone!

If not and you think you are right and made your point clearly so why are you defending yourself again and again.

You shared your point of view, let others share theirs. 😃

Originally posted by: pandemonia3

Ok one thing..if u want to appreciate Mohit or MONAYA...why piggy back ride on the credentials of RP AB...every single time? There was no need to mention AB here...on the mere basis of seniority even, there is really NO COMPARISON between these two actors! Call it natural talent or experience, AB is a talented actor. Mohit has a long long way to go indeed. Just changing your hairstyle and wearing glasses doesn't automatically bestow people with talent and superior acting skills! Also in a lot of romantic scenes, Mohit has imbibed a considerable amount of the gestures and mannerisms that AB has perfected in HIS romantic scenes with RP. He's a good learner coz we all know AB is friends with him and AB must have given him some tips as a concerned senior. So my question remains: Aren't you guys doing some sort of disservice to Mohit by constantly comparing him to the other lead? I mean doesn't his talent, as seen by you people, deserve to be praised on its own merit? I also find it extremely laughable that RP is considered a good actor in order to bring out the shine in Mohit's acting when just a few months ago, her acting was dismissed as overacting/ OTT acting! I have just laid down my viewpoints in a very civil manner. I am entitled to these opinions of mine and I am NOT LIABLE to answer any challenges! So please do not bother quoting me!