Mohit as Devdas Outranks Arjun - Page 10

I am last person to be sentimental about such posts Sonya,

I am taught to shut out my emotions while arguing.

I only become sentimental and hurt with people whom I am close to thats it!

I was just making a general statement!

Originally posted by: kayamath_fan2

okay, last post for today, goshh I need to study
But I totally understand you Annie...I know what you mean...
but the problem is I think more cause both acted.. =( thats why you tend to compare, and
I really understood, and that was Also Sonya's intention I guess, that Mohit actually was as good as Arjun was..which is a huuuge compliment of courseee...And Im really really sorry if it hurt you guys...I mean..I totally undestand you guys..but yeahh..it would be appreciated as well if you guys would see how we understood it !! =( in a hurrryyyy, cant reply moreee =(

Sonya, I guess its better if you just strike Arjun from the topic, it will lead to less misinterpretations !!!

Well Anu, until and unless they convince me, I won't change the title or the content. I know you're talking out of experience and for my good, but I have some personal policies too. Why didn't anyone mind me saying Sanaya was not a perfect match for Mohit in that scene? So, it's fine if it's Sanaya but not Arjun? Okay, now that's not a very good justification that I might respect. Besides, no body requested that I change the title; instead, Mohit was mocked clearly with comments like "Are you kidding me?" So why should I be more thoughtful, because this forum is supposedly packed with more Mayank-Nupur fans?

Hey Anu I guess your interpretation of her posts is different and for others its different. She may possibly have not stated her point across as she wanted to which led to this reaction. The readers would read what is written and interpret!

Ok one thing..if u want to appreciate Mohit or MONAYA...why piggy back ride on the credentials of RP AB...every single time? There was no need to mention AB here...on the mere basis of seniority even, there is really NO COMPARISON between these two actors! Call it natural talent or experience, AB is a talented actor. Mohit has a long long way to go indeed. Just changing your hairstyle and wearing glasses doesn't automatically bestow people with talent and superior acting skills! Also in a lot of romantic scenes, Mohit has imbibed a considerable amount of the gestures and mannerisms that AB has perfected in HIS romantic scenes with RP. He's a good learner coz we all know AB is friends with him and AB must have given him some tips as a concerned senior. So my question remains: Aren't you guys doing some sort of disservice to Mohit by constantly comparing him to the other lead? I mean doesn't his talent, as seen by you people, deserve to be praised on its own merit? I also find it extremely laughable that RP is considered a good actor in order to bring out the shine in Mohit's acting when just a few months ago, her acting was dismissed as overacting/ OTT acting! I have just laid down my viewpoints in a very civil manner. I am entitled to these opinions of mine and I am NOT LIABLE to answer any challenges! So please do not bother quoting me!

Originally posted by: Shivani1arti

@ bold: glad u agreed😳 yup arjun's the best
& i respect ur pov as well

SEE, exactly this puts me off !!!
You guys ALWAYS need a prove from EVERYBODY that Arjun is the best! and woww..isnt best comparing as well ??
BEST - meaning better tahn everyone - meaning you need to compare !!
anyways, what irks me the most is that..you need a statement from everybody that arjun is the best!
and now..if a topic itself starts with Arjun is a perfect actor, no need to say, mohit was actually as good as Arjun...whats wrong to say that? if you can say Arjun is the best?
None of the topics with Arjun is best gets closed..which means its right...which would mean this is also not against the rules!
anyways, im no one to give lectures to anybody..but it just totally turns me off when ppl have double standards...and these days deliberately turn the entire sense of the topic in the other way so taht finally it is called as against the rules! THAT is the worst thing abt this forum...

@ Anu................... well it didnt come across the way u put it..................t didnt hurt us, i was shocked..............

Yeah they peformed on same scene.................but to say something like one outranked other, was something which i m sure no MN fan can take kindly................

Just like SG fans wnt, if i compare Sanaya or Mohit to the Sreejita or that Rohan guy................

anyways plz continue with study................. :)

Originally posted by: Shivani1arti

@ bold: glad u agreed😳 yup arjun's the best
& i respect ur pov as well

i think you didn't read my first post carefully ........i had mentioned very cleary about arjun being a better actor( infact i find him to be the best actor on tv)i just had a problem with people labeling mohit as a bad actor........

Originally posted by: Senny

Sonya well it seems you have been a little new here. Well we have a lot of topics stating Monaya are the best or Arti are the best. No one is inter mingled.

Monaya fans, stick to their topic and don't bring in Arti and same goes for Arti and their fans. As for Monaya fans, their fav is the best and I see no comparision there.

I am sure moderators would view this strictly and decide accordingly.

I have always respected Arjun but I am not such a great fan of any besides rati, her chem with arjun, abhi and now navina.

Well Senny, I find those as boring topics. Once I was discussing my work with my creative writing professor. I told him, Professor I think good literature is that which generates discussion. Someone says Mayank-Nupur or Samrat-Gunjan is the best pair on the face of the earth. And, then tons of people agree to that passively. Such topics might be of your interest, but I'm least interested.

@ sonya: girl u liked mohit better than arjun as devdas....it's fine
but why r u not fine if some others(majority) liked arjun better as devdas....
u have ur own view....we our's...u keep thinking of him as better...we keep thinking arjun better
i have no problems with comparison.....it's just that forum rules don't allow it.....
now don't ask me why i like arjun more...i can't explain my our love for him or his talent to u....

i didn't know this much was going on here....this is fun...lol

well, this topic's first statement is abt arjun outstanding performance in general n overall

n the last statement is abt even sanaya wasn't at par in that scene

no sonya didn't make any statement @ sanaya's acting skills in generall

so being a sanaya fanatic....it's me who should start the fight/disagreement/arguement......but no!!!
i know why this forum is never boring, if there is nothing... misinterpretation of topics n replies will come into picture