DOTW - Intimate Scenes Right or Wrong?

-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Salaam Namastey to all MJHT'ians

Lately we've had loads of discussions or rather should i say arguments on the Intimate scene being shown in the Show MJHT. First it happened with Mayank and Nupur and just 2 days back with Samrat and Gunjan. And we've had mixed reviews on this. Some have no objection to such scene. Some do have, based on different reasons/views.

Today I have a Question to raise in general to know your view's as a General Member and not as a SG or MN Fan. But as a general TV/MJHT Viewer.

*Do You feel such intimate scene should be showed on TV?
*Is it Right to have such scene's in the Youth based Show?
*If its Right, then Why do you think It is? And if Its Wrong then Why?


Please Note : We are here to discuss in general. And not to mock the characters/actors/CV's or the Members or Fan Group. So no Comparison between MN & SG and also no differenciating based on others Opinions or based on your Fav's. The reply should be just your individual Viewpoint as a Daily TV/Show watcher. Post that point at certain Member/Character in thier comments would be treated strictly and might face actions. Its Only a Discussion Post so No Arguments/Fights. Each One is expected to respect Each Others Opinions.




Thanks n Regards
IF Dev Team

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

4.6k

Users

45

Likes

132

Frequent Posters

EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Great post Preeti & 1 def reqd a lot 😊

as a viewer in general & not as a SG fan or anything else i m fine with intimate scenes if shown with some purpose some backdrop & if shot aesthetically

to me nor was SaJan's Roshni se or MayUr's Pehli baar sequence sleazy or vulgar i never had issues with either pair depicting their love

as a youth based show we can expect these scenes right or else we have only saas bahu sob stories in Indian TV but in a quite a few of these shows too we had scenes hotter than even SG or MN ever had

truly more provocative than these MJHT scenes on TV we have a certain mr serial kisser' popular songs that are a instant hit & a rage played across music channels & cable TV too plus there's always d net or foreign shows who are leagues ahead in this area or some pathetic Deo ads that are so Ewww

so for me nope not an issue i m def ok with these scenes after all in a love story they'll come after a point it cant always be abt eyelocks & holding hands

my only problem with these scenes is when it is sleazily shot or d scene is put just to raise d TRP's with nothing to do with d story
Edited by aahana86 - 15 years ago
Faraan92 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
i thnk its totally right to hav such scenes in youth based serial..
Dats my POV.. 😊
annie07 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Well great Topic Preeti............
Intimacy is a part of life................I rem. Arjun saying in sbs..........."Intimacy is a part of every relationship"...............and thus...........its nothing wrong in it..............
Ok, now coming to intimacy in youth based show...........so 1stly what is a youth based show.........there are many dimensions to it.....it can be abt college, frndship, career................or it can be about realtionships also.
If its a love story, if there are two people in love..............intimacy will be there...............and it isnt wrong...........
Y. dnt we see such stuff and even worse in Bollywood movies............even in so called family dramas.........and songs videos..........those are all aired on TV, and youth do watch them........
So y being biased labelling a show as youth show.........
Besides, vulgarity and cheapness, may not necessarily mean physical intimacy, it can be even in a way ppl look at each other or dialogues mouthed..................so we cant judge it this way..........
Anyhow, i m all ok with intimacy on TV, as long as we dnt go Hollywood style............
Just my POV
aishhh. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
I would say it is perfectly alright (with me atleast) as a general viewer
now let me give the reason> 😊
firstly, the creatives are trying to show a relationship...now if there is a relationship, then this relationship will have its due stages...the scenes that have been shown are basically just a progression in either MaYur or SaJan relations.....
second, there are reasons behind those scenes > they are justified - and they are not being shown for unnecessary reasons - not even TRPs in my view.
third (n final....if ur gettin bored of me...lol) is that even though this is a youth based show, the "youth" themselves should choose whether they think it is appropriate for them to watch it or not....the creatives n mjht team are doing their job. i.e. viewer's discretion........😳
thank u preeti for the post...
i hope u guyz are not bored of me........😲
sonamd thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
no issues....its common...with mn..kiss made me blush n with sg...g outfit made me blush...wen she lied down..i cld c her cleavage...but no offence!!!!
Iqraimran thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
nice psot...................i really uncomfportable when we watch this serial wid our family like brothers r also sit wid to watch this serial after all its youth base ........but now a days youth base show demand these types of scenes and jahan tak family show ka question hai ab family show ful on sab kuch dekhate hai.......ye youth base show kay hai?
i realy don't like intimate scene between sajan and mayur both but wht we do............here's some people who have no problem jab hum sab DMG AUR REMIX DEKHTA HAI y we have problems these scenes.......
In my opinion youth base never have these types of scenes guyz some peoples watch these youth shows wid their younger brothers sisters nd smtime family also but again wht we do its demand youth base mostly watch online by youngers.........so many watch their fav serial on PC ....I m also pehli baar mayur and roshni se sajan seq on PC ..NOT WID MY BRO AND SIS ........its also depend on your family environment......its not looking so odd to watch these scnes wid family.........but its all depend on a person mind and family environment
but if u go uk country like this its like disney shows guyz..........but we here many hindu and muslims which never like these scene
for me its wrong ..............but its my opinion again i said its depend person mind or family enivronment
intmacy shows a relation.....its wrong i don't agree their r many ways to show a good relation...........but kahi na kahi our daily shows demand these intimacy scene..........but guyz i really like arjun in pehli baar and monaya in roshni se.....they do fabulous job👏
Edited by aditti_sajan - 15 years ago
430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Intimacy has always been an issue.
And today, I can surprisingly speak as a Neutral member.
First off, I see no harm in showing intimate scenes in a youth show. But the way our Indian TV portrays these scenes is the main question. If they want to show that a couple kissed, it's very stupid of them to stop at such a point, where viewers are forced to think that the couple did more than just a kiss. They leave it to viewers to try and see what the scene meant. Disney shows have teens kissing each other, which is no big deal. Every passionate or intimate scene should be shot aesthetically. Only then, the scene looks romantic, otherwise it looks nothing but vulgar. So the way the scene is shot is more of a concern, than the scene itself.
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
thank god youll guys opened these posts.....i at a personal level hate intimate scenesthey make me really very uncomfortable....so i dont watch them......but if such scenes rea shown they shud be with a background and for a reason......and ofcourse they shoudnt look cheap....as for as the mayur and sajan scene go both of they were fully clothed and the songs were picturised decntly......so no problem
saher_90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
No,Its not @ all right!
As far as we know A sober/simple girl never wont do anything like this that they've showed in serial..They are spoiling A sober/simple girl image n that is very wrong i wont accept all those intimate scenes they showed in serial..
P.S thanks preeti i wanted something like this topic thanks alot:)
No Offence..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".