How should we critique MJHT??????

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Kavya

@Bazinga

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: carolinecj
I think CJ is just for suggesting future scenes and feedback.

but i guess we can critique the show in other topics

can we?

Dude you forgot to mention that its only positive feedback. As for criticism, Neha let us face the fact that it is against I-F's rules. The statement "criticism is allowed" is only a name sake statement, the truth is that criticism is NOT allowed in I-F and more so in MJHT Forum. I do not remember any of us (be it the negative/ex MN fans or positive/current MN fans or true fans or False fans or whatever sects o fans exist here) threatening the 'creatives' here and harsh criticism IS a kind of criticism which is CANNOT BE CALLED BASHING. Now if I say "I blame the creatives for killing Mayank Nupur for me" and one calls it accusatory then all I can say is I am sorry that TRUTH HURTS.

Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 16 years ago

Quote

mads

@mads

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

neha u really wanna kno my answer ??

dont ask any such question again ever...

coz apparently, this forum does NOT entertain ANY kind of negative feedbacks ... it is only interested in praising a certain member and holding up the name of being a "good and healthy" forum... again, for a particular member...

if u dont like something..jus be mumb abt it..and dont say anything at all...

we hav tried to put forth our POV..and we hav ALSO praised whenever we felt a particular track or scene was good...

yet, now when we.,..the same ppl feel that its our right to criticise and do something 'right'... we are being told that its infact 'wrong'...

so lets just not mess our brains wit this... I frankly am gonna post in the CJ and/or in this forum...ONLY to paise a particular thing now.. and if I dont like something..I'm not gonna give a damn...

we cared a LOT for the show..hence we tried to be responsible fans..and NOT fanatics... but apparently, that care is being misunderstood...

I dont give a DAMN now.. PERIOD.

sorry for the loong rambling!! but I cudnt stop myself...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kavya

@kavya.b

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

bang on neha
i too need a clarification for this aftr seeing a few topics being closed for the reason " we have CJ 2 post these things"

n abt creatives... million worth Q, how can anyone think that we r meaning only PD n going against her wen we mention creatives so clearly

incase if it is 2wards PD, even then we r not refering 2 her as member of IF wen post things, we refer her as one of the creative head this show

LOL i dont understand these things at all

Quote

Piya

@piya2025

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: kavya.b
bang on neha
i too need a clarification for this aftr seeing a few topics being closed for the reason " we have CJ 2 post these things"

n abt creatives... million worth Q, how can anyone think that we r meaning only PD n going against her wen we mention creatives so clearly

incase if it is 2wards PD, even then we r not refering 2 her as member of IF wen post things, we refer her as one of the creative head this show

LOL i dont understand these things at all

If u get to understand koi mujhe bhi samjadena😆😆😆Im very much nadan bacchi abt this thing..Ok on a serious NoteI agree👏👏👏I dont have anything againts mods or any1 but yeah if we get a perfect reason y d topicbeing closed it would be really nice😊(I.E-Mods close a topic when its a comparison topic saying its a comparison 1) 😳

Quote

kavya

@kavya.b

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: piya2025
If u get to understand koi mujhe bhi samjadena😆😆😆Im very much nadan bacchi abt this thing..Ok on a serious NoteI agree👏👏👏I dont have anything againts mods or any1 but yeah if we get a perfect reason y d topicbeing closed it would be really nice😊(I.E-Mods close a topic when its a comparison topic saying its a comparison 1) 😳

arey yaar, i too dont have anything against our mods but we hardly get clear reason wen a topic is closed
i never understood, wat kind of topic is allowed 2 post n wat's not ... abt criticism

Edited by kavya.b - 16 years ago

Quote

nehlove

@nehlove

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: kavya.b
bang on neha
i too need a clarification for this aftr seeing a few topics being closed for the reason " we have CJ 2 post these things"

n abt creatives... million worth Q, how can anyone think that we r meaning only PD n going against her wen we mention creatives so clearly

incase if it is 2wards PD, even then we r not refering 2 her as member of IF wen post things, we refer her as one of the creative head this show

LOL i dont understand these things at all

THAT is my main question here... Unless you specifically mention PD... how can it be assumed that we are attacking a particular member when we use the word "creatives"..... Its like we can't say anything against the creative team of the show because it will always be taken as an attack towards PD... However, it is ok to praise them???? How come the praising topics are not closed down and asked to divert to CJ too....

Quote

kavya

@kavya.b

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

^^ i dont think we'll get an answer for this
praisings r ALLOWED but no CRITICISM as a topic

i remember the no. of threads in the forum praising them n PD
none of them was closed

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

umm

over inspiration is Plaigiarism

and there is no two words about it..

I dont think that is a hurtful comment..

Quote

430105

Hibernated

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

simple answer: praising is allowed, but criticism is considered bashing! Why? I think a show is all the more successful, if criticisms are taken sportingly and worked upon! And personally, more than praises, criticisms make the show to develop better, since they realise where they're going wrong. I think criticism is fine, but bashing isn;t. But we should be allowed to criticize the show, since we are the viewers as well!

Quote

kavya

@kavya.b

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: utfracks
simple answer: praising is allowed, but criticism is considered bashing! Why? I think a show is all the more successful, if criticisms are taken sportingly and worked upon! And personally, more than praises, criticisms make the show to develop better, since they realise where they're going wrong. I think criticism is fine, but bashing isn;t. But we should be allowed to criticize the show, since we are the viewers as well!

totally agreed
any tym criticism should b accepted n infact if ur (not u) intelligent enough, u should b waiting for the criticism more than praisings.. LOL i believe so

do correct me if i'm wrong

Quote

1 2 3

How should we critique MJHT?????? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics