How should we critique MJHT??????

Page

Next Last

nehlove

@nehlove

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

I just wanted to post out a question for all the members and mods of this forum... How exactly are we supposed to give our valuable criticism on the show MJHT without being considered as bashers? If we feel something is wrong in the show do we voice our opinions or no??? How do I know that a general statement made for the makers (creatives) of the show will not be taken as a personal attack on a certain member(PD)? How do we separate the member from the creative of the show??

When I post random statement in CJ I am told it is only to post scenes... When I make a different post criticizing the creatives I am told that we have CJ for that... Now what exactly am I supposed to believe? Do I post my creative queries and creatives criticism on CJ or is that only for "Future scenes"? Can the MODs please be CLEAR on this... I want to know for sure what I am allowed to post on CJ exactly so that my topics are not closed down.

I hope none of what I have said above will be considered as "bashing." I always thought it was OK to voice our opinion on this OPEN forum so hopefully the MODs should have no problems with this topic and the very valid questions I have asked here.

Edited by nehlove - 16 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

OHYE

@OHYE

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

Ummh ......k I guess u r questioning the MODS moreso than the members.

Here's my take:
For me bashing is to engage in harsh, accusatory, threatening criticism (as defined in the dictionary). So I would critique MJHT without the use of harsh, accusatory, and threatening language. This is my answer to ur question. Good luck finding ur answer.

And oh yes ... for me future thread is for suggestions. Topics are for critiques.

Edited by OHYE - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

I think CJ is just for suggesting future scenes and feedback.

but i guess we can critique the show in other topics

can we?

Quote

nehlove

@nehlove

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

^^ I dunno... can we?? I tried to critique by saying how creatives should not copy but I was told stuff like that shoul be posted in CJ... so I was clarifying...

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

i dont think the CJ thread is the right place to bring in all the sources MJHT has copied from

but oh well

Quote

nehlove

@nehlove

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: OHYE
Ummh ......k I guess u r questioning the MODS moreso than the members.

Here's my take:
For me bashing is to engage in harsh, accusatory, threatening criticism (as defined in the dictionary). So I would critique MJHT without the use of harsh, accusatory, and threatening language. This is my answer to ur question. Good luck finding ur answer.

And oh yes ... for me future thread is for suggestions. Topics are for critiques.

So if I say that I think that the creatives of MJHT are blatantly plagiarising is that bashing or criticism?? I mean I don't see any harsh words when I say that statement. I am after all only stating a fact, right??

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

neha

the confusion is perhaps

some people get offended by facts and assume it to be bashing perhaps

i didnt find anything wrong with ur topic..but then that is an individual assessment

Quote

xxXAanchaLXxx

@xxXAanchaLXxx

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

okayy lol i dntt think i can voice anything in this topic....cuzzzz yahaan to wahii aayega jo abhi bhi mjht dhekhte ho....aur humne wo shubh karya bahut pehle hi karna chod diya hai!!lol neha... y do u even bother watching it????main jab bhi dhekhne ki 'koshish' karti hoon....i jusstt end up pulling my hair off in an effort to calm myselff!!!thatt show has lost all its.......sorrryyyy the list iss sooooooo lonnnggg n m no wayyyy gonna waste my time over whats lacking in mjht....m sure ull agree with me!!😡anyways neha.... yaaar mujhe nahi lagta ki mods tujhe answer kar payenge...wo khud sar khujla rahe honge ki ab hum kya bollee!!???!!kyuu ki show ka to satyanash ho hi gaya haiii!!!!cumn to the next topic here....scooppss!!!!it ruinss the suprise of thee shoooowwww....talkinnn of it.... theres nthngg left in the showw noowww....the only thingg which can suprise me nooowww is sommee college classroomm scene!!!which havent been aired since god alone knows whennnn!!!aur probablyyyy some old teacher coming back from longg vacation!!!like deodar aur ms aha...orr of course on the side... something which might suprise me woulddd be the creatives admitting thier mistake and new creatives coming alonngg.... who have gone to college atleastt once in theirr life!! and would knowww that college isnt not just about plays and dramas, taking revenge from each other... or juss sitting around at a police stationn... doiinnnggg gunda giri etc etc etc....

in short- this show is rainingg cats and dogs!!!

Quote

incandescence

@incandescence

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: nehlove
I just wanted to post out a question for all the members and mods of this forum... How exactly are we supposed to give our valuable criticism on the show MJHT without being considered as bashers? If we feel something is wrong in the show do we voice our opinions or no??? How do I know that a general statement made for the makers (creatives) of the show will not be taken as a personal attack on a certain member(PD)? How do we separate the member from the creative of the show??

When I post random statement in CJ I am told it is only to post scenes... When I make a different post criticizing the creatives I am told that we have CJ for that... Now what exactly am I supposed to believe? Do I post my creative queries and creatives criticism on CJ or is that only for "Future scenes"? Can the MODs please be CLEAR on this... I want to know for sure what I am allowed to post on CJ exactly so that my topics are not closed down.

I hope none of what I have said above will be considered as "bashing." I always thought it was OK to voice our opinion on this OPEN forum so hopefully the MODs should have no problems with this topic and the very valid questions I have asked here.

if u r in any way writing a fact in a topic, it is not treated as bashing or even criticizing. Can any one..Mods, members or the respected creatives deny the fact that the scenes were copied? No, they can not. If they do...they'll just come off looking completely stupid. As for the respect factor and personal attack. A personal attack is when someone attack another's character. If i write 'u should b ashamed of ur self to copy scenes/dialogues from film/forum'...That...would b a personal attack. Have u done that?..If not..then ur topic in no way could b termed as bashing. If they r indeed copying things from films/forums then whats the big deal about saying it out in the open? it's an OPEN forum...i think....

Now about CJ......i thought its for suggestions n feedback Only....so if we give a feedback on their copying stuff....and suggestions to them to stop doing that and come up with something original for a change...then that also can in no way b treated as bashing or criticizing.....anyone saying otherwise needs to check the meaning of bashing, criticizing and a forum....

Quote

OHYE

@OHYE

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: nehlove

So if I say that I think that the creatives of MJHT are blatantly plagiarising is that bashing or criticism?? I mean I don't see any harsh words when I say that statement. I am after all only stating a fact, right??

If you wanna be that blunt than so be it. I am not stopping you. Since u r asking me, if I was in ur place I would have said MJHT is being "inspired" by such and such 😆 instead of using plagiarising. That brings out humor and doesn't hurt sentiments in my POV.

BTW bashing is a type of criticism called destructive criticism. So, personally I wouldn't consider the usage of a word like plagiarising as a constructive remark, because it sounds accusatory for many out there.

Edited by OHYE - 16 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

How should we critique MJHT??????

Related Topics

Explore Topics