Why Chirag being a negative character disappointed me! - Page 3

Originally posted by: SamLovesIshita

The matter is that nobody can love Ishaani as much as Ranveer ! Be it Chirag or if any positive character is brought.

Seconded! But it's not about if someone can love her as much, it's about an honesty in the story. Like I mentioned KHNH, where I never got the feeling that Rohit could ever love Naina the way Aman did, but there was a beauty and honesty in Rohit's love for her that made us love him. That's what I was talking about. Ranveer loves her way too much. If someone can love Ish one thousandth of that love, she'll be very lucky.

Originally posted by: Elvish_Hobbit

Oh, no! But haven't there been some *good* shows by EKK? There was a vampire show that did well, and another one that starred Karan Kundra. These both shows did well and audience still remember them (my friends). I'll be glad if they don't the crap in this show. Let it be the same and simple show that we loved. I hope. :)

Pyar Ki ek kahani was the vampire show which I dint watch so no idea. But kitnai Mohabat hai was different true (Karan Kundra 1). There is at present Kumkum Bhagya which is kind of different and good going now. But nothing lasts forever. Lets hope things go the good way.
One thing is if serial drags for many years then it gets rubbish. But if it ends within a year or two it remains good.

Originally posted by: Elvish_Hobbit

Seconded! But it's not about if someone can love her as much, it's about an honesty in the story. Like I mentioned KHNH, where I never got the feeling that Rohit could ever love Naina the way Aman did, but there was a beauty and honesty in Rohit's love for her that made us love him. That's what I was talking about. Ranveer loves her way too much. If someone can love Ish one thousandth of that love, she'll be very lucky.

Ya, I do get your point. But why do you need someone else for Ishaani with one thousandth of Ranveer's love when there's Ranveer already. 😃

Originally posted by: abhigya24

Pyar Ki ek kahani was the vampire show which I dint watch so no idea. But kitnai Mohabat hai was different true (Karan Kundra 1). There is at present Kumkum Bhagya which is kind of different and good going now. But nothing lasts forever. Lets hope things go the good way. One thing is if serial drags for many years then it gets rubbish. But if it ends within a year or two it remains good.

I didn't watch that one myself but my friends were CRAZY for that one. Whenever in college, they'd talk about the whole vampire saga. I feel this show was way too better than Meyer's Twilight. Karan Kundra's show seemed good as well, I had seen one episode or so of it. Kumkum Bhagya, yes, my friends watch this one too. But I love MATH, and want it to be good and philosophical.

Originally posted by: SamLovesIshita

Ya, I do get your point. But why do you need someone else for Ishaani with one thousandth of Ranveer's love when there's Ranveer already. 😃

I don't need anyone who can love her one thousandth of Ranveer's love. All I was trying to say the true power of love comes from sacrifice. Not only in romantic love, but the greatness any kind of love is defined by the sacrifice of an individual. At times this sacrifice goes unnoticed, and no one knows what someone has lost for others, but this is what leads the world. In our real world there are people who sacrifice themselves so that others may carry on. Without their sacrifices our world would be consumed by evil sooner than it is actually meant to be. So, Ranveer's love for Ishaani is the purest kind of romantic love. And, I feel, his is the [romantic, but] non-sexual type, and this is why his sacrifice means a lot, to me. If Chirag were a positive character his love and sacrifice would have been worthwhile. That to make someone happy he sacrificed his own happiness. This way I wonder if Ishaani (in case, she gets married) will really be happy. Won't you feel bad then? I shall. I'd feel all the previous episodes would be useless, and most of all his sacrifice. This is why I wanted Chirag to remain a positive character.

Originally posted by: Elvish_Hobbit

I didn't watch that one myself but my friends were CRAZY for that one. Whenever in college, they'd talk about the whole vampire saga. I feel this show was way too better than Meyer's Twilight. Karan Kundra's show seemed good as well, I had seen one episode or so of it. Kumkum Bhagya, yes, my friends watch this one too. But I love MATH, and want it to be good and philosophical.

Yes I too had a lot of expectations from MATH I was happy too but I dont know nowadays I am a bit dissapointed the way the story is taking turns. Anyways lets hope for the best.

Originally posted by: abhigya24

<div></div>Yes I too had a lot of expectations from MATH I was happy too but I dont know nowadays I am a bit dissapointed the way the story is taking turns. Anyways lets hope for the best.

I did not have hopes of any kind, I just saw it switching the channels and it appealed me very much. I do not hope for the worst too. The hope I can think of is this show having the shades of Wuthering Heights. I think they *officially* announced this show to be inspired from the novel. It'll be amazing to see that story here. They never meet, but their love doesn't die.

@Elvish_Hobbit

Originally posted by: Yuvika_15

@Elvish_Hobbit

I think they did that becos if they kept chirag positive, that would mean there would be a group of fans that would have wanted chirag-ishaani 2geva...fans would have been split between the 2 couples, and in the end only 1 couple will last...ishaani cant b with both of them, and if they kept chirag positive then some fans may have threatened to quit the show if their fav couple didn't get 2geva, so they risk losing viewers that way. so with having chirag negative their intention is to kinda make chirag-ishaani fans NOW turn into IshVeer supporters and NOT want chirag-ishaani 2 get 2geva...which works well for them becos they want ishveer 2 ultimately be together- I hope I haven't confused u. in simple words CVs always think that they need to turn the 3rd angle evilto make the story work😕

a good example of that movie u used, but the comparison with the show is a little difficult, becos u see with dramas, fans take it to another level...like they'll start petitions, bashing the channel etc. if they fav couple is going through separation track but with movies, u just watch it n don't think much of it once u leave the theatres.

2bh, I always found it hard to believe that chirag's love for ishaani was genuine...I always had this gut feeling it was fake and jus an attempt to hide his real thoughts/intentions which have obv been revealed now! it was typical 4 him 2 become negative...

Really? Fans can go upto this extent? Wow! I never heard this. You make many a good point that this was inevitable for Ish-Ranveer to get together and that it'll cause the fans to burst from anger. As for the movies, I did use the examples because they, despite their third angle in the story, were successfully able to impress the audience. The thing is most people want their favorite characters to end happily. While I feel it's the bittersweet (not sad) feeling that is the best one. Being Chirag positive would have given the story a bitter sweet experience to the audience. They chose to show otherwise. As for Chirag's feelings, I was tend to believe they were "real" because of the statement made by Chirag himself. I wondered why he'd lie to his own parents? I wasn't too sure about his intentions but wanted him to remain a positive person. Now, hope for the best. That's all.

Originally posted by: Elvish_Hobbit

Really? Fans can go upto this extent? Wow! I never heard this. You make many a good point that this was inevitable for Ish-Ranveer to get together and that it'll cause the fans to burst from anger. As for the movies, I did use the examples because they, despite their third angle in the story, were successfully able to impress the audience. The thing is most people want their favorite characters to end happily. While I feel it's the bittersweet (not sad) feeling that is the best one. Being Chirag positive would have given the story a bitter sweet experience to the audience. They chose to show otherwise. As for Chirag's feelings, I was tend to believe they were "real" because of the statement made by Chirag himself. I wondered why he'd lie to his own parents? I wasn't too sure about his intentions but wanted him to remain a positive person. Now, hope for the best. That's all.

they do much worse! some fans nowadays go to extreme lengths if they aren't happy with the storyline... so i'm not surprised they made chirag negative early on in the show rather than leaving it late and risking viewers developing a strong liking in his character.