Injustice..scripted !!

Page

Next Last

Chitra

@Chits1

Trailblazer

Posted: 12 years ago

Devyani's stuff was well presented and Doyal's didn't even have the layers,how did she win? can someone from the MC team pls give an explanation??????????????????

Quote

Frequent Posters

raj-avin

@raj-avin

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Am just tired of this show. Main thing is taking viewers for granted. being a cooking competition, viewers completely depend on what judges say. We can only see how dish looks like.

They said Doyal's faluda tasted really well but her presentn was a big flop. Ajay even said its better to not talk abt presentn. Devyani's presentn full marks also the taste wasnt that bad ( from what judges said). So ideally will look like Devyani shd be winner.

Last few weeks ,judges are making several wrong decisions.They dont shows us the proper discussion between the judges after tasting. does all of them taste dish but they just show one judge tasting each dish ,so how can they arrive at decision or compare the dishes. no clue what they r trying to show.😲

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Raina

@Raina101

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Doyel- 10 faults ( coz you could see only 3 layers of the falooda)
Devyani - 1 fault - the noodles

How is SP and MCI going to justify this?

Quote

Chitra

@Chits1

Trailblazer

Posted: 12 years ago

editing team not showing us the main points.The show is just 30 mts,so what the judges say and decide are way apart.

devyani's looked good and doyal had just 3 layers.How can they justify?

Kunal said,devyani had just the falooda wrong thatz it..no other fault,Looks like the director needs some drama lady and that is doyal,so she was saved.

Quote

Ramisaa

@Ramisaa

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

dis season luks fully scripted..dey only saved doyal caz she screams and jumps around like a maniac nd dat raises da trps

Quote

Alina

@-Alinaa-

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

Make Ripu winner, Doyal runner up n Navneet 2nd runner up rite away.

Quote

Rana

@hamzanuha

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

I couldn't watch yesterday's episode; am deeply disappointed but not surprised.

Somehow, I'd felt that Devyani wouldn't be in the top three as she was too traditional - her dress - & the judges are looking for someone who can be presented on an international level. Pankaj related in a no. of interviews how she was sent abroad to represent India at various food festivals (don't know about Shipra, she doesn't even seem to have gotten her own cookery show).

Doyal's cooking prowess aside, the makers seem to be in an indecent need for trps by hook or by crook, hence she wasn't eliminated. The same goes for Navneet.

Acc. to you all, there was no explanation given for Devyani's dish. Hasn't that become the norm rather than the exception? Despite having 1/2-hourly daily episodes with the cooking & tasting split into 2 days, they don't show all the judges tasting or commenting. Pathetic!

In MC Aus, not only do all the judges taste & comment, but they also explain where the eliminated contestant went wrong. But then it's like comparing the sun (MC Aus) with a guttering candle (MC India)!

It's gone beyond the point of no return. It has now become a joke of a competition where dramebaazi & favouritism matter, not the innovation nor the presentation (it seems). Good night.

Quote

Chitra

@Chits1

Trailblazer

Posted: 12 years ago

I agree,devyani was very traditional,so maybe not acceptable for big shows by Star Plus or any other show,if she wins,so somehow,they had to eliminate her.

Doyal,is getting TRP's for the channel,with her cheap acts.Star plus is despo for TRP,I guess,so that explains the eliminiation 🤔

Quote

Fatima

@Fatima_Q

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

They turned Ishrat out because she couldn't complete the dish. And here out of 13 layers Doyal's dish only showed 1. And they save her because of taste alone? 😕

They could have tasted Ishrat's dish and seen it was better than Navneet's who apparently doesn't know how to make something as simple as jelly.

Don't know what they are basing their decisions on...and who ever is editing the show is doing it in a way to keep up the elimination suspense, but it comes off looking like the judges are making poor decisions. For me personally, this is the worst season of MC.

Quote

Pillwa

@PilloWtalk_13

Stunner

+ 13

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

yes yes make ripu
winner:d

Quote

1 2 3 4

Injustice..scripted !!

Related Topics

Explore Topics