Presentation vs taste - Page 3

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

Apparently it changes from time to time.
When Navneets jelly was inedible Ishrat went, only coz she couldn't complete the presentation accurately.

Honestly, the judges lack consistency in judgement.

Originally posted by: monu_tan

Ishrat's dish was incomplete, it wasnt a presentation issue.

I beg to differ.
The only thing she couldn't make was the chocolate cup!
She kept breaking them. For tasting she put the broken cup which wouldn't change the taste but mar the presentation.

Try for yourself - a slab of chocolate will taste the same as a slab of chocolate broken into 2!

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

I beg to differ.
The only thing she couldn't make was the chocolate cup!
She kept breaking them. For tasting she put the broken cup which wouldn't change the taste but mar the presentation.

Try for yourself - a slab of chocolate will taste the same as a slab of chocolate broken into 2!

Honestly, the way Doyal was dumping the dishes into that large container looked so unprofessional - almost forced, as if she didnt want to do it... She was just dropping the dishes as if in a dust bin 😛 I agree, the look of the food cannot get precedence over taste, but I have my doubts for the result considering Doyal was so far behind, had given up, then got motivated and suddenly did everything so very perfect that despite the bad looks she won it...

I know.. so let's see.. Devyani's 30 minutes of feluda made her lose the tag...according to chefs.. she didn't spend much time on it..

Originally posted by: monu_tan

Haha in that case she didnt even need to make the broken choco cup, dairy milk daal deti.😆

The fact is Ishrat cudnt complete the cup, which every other contestant had completed so technically her dish was incomplete. I liked Ishrat better than many other contestants on the show, but it wasnt her day. Had she been saved on that day it would have been bigger mess for Master Chef.

Well the cup wouldn't taste any different if she 'completed' it.

According to your logic even Doyel didn't complete her dish!
She should have simply made three layers using ingredients of the other layers a well!

Think about it! Who's mistake seems graver?
I know to contradict you'll stick to your guns!

But try not bothering abt having to respond and think with a clear mind. You should get your answer.

I do not want to carry on a discussion with one person nor offend anyone.
Peace

Raina, why keep banging ur head against a wall?

^^^^ I know just realised that while typing out the message.
But u just wanted people to think and wrote that last msg.

I'm not responding to that chain of msgs anymore.

Doyel did make all the 13 layer items, she didnt make only 3. Lets be clear at that, which means her dish was completed. While presenting her 13 layers she messed up and only 3 layers were visible. Its as simple as that ONLY if someone chooses to see as that.

I NEVER trust the judges because they always say something and do another when it comes to elimination. As always star plus reality shows are rarely reality, and I have no doubts about that when judgement is based on anything but food 😕