What an unfair contest !! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

4.7k

Users

24

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

everest1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
I totally agree with the original comment Aditi did not turn turn things around she was rude to the customers. There was total bias by the judges Lilymily you seemed to be watching a different show. IF you watched without bias and prejudice you would see that the blue team was given help, encouragement and tips from the judges. The red team did gel and worked on their own efforts they were not spoon fed by the judges. It was clear to see that the judges and sided to make sure the red team lost.

The blue team was a larger team just by the fact the judges were there all they way helping them out.

Watch Master Chef from the country it originally came from Britain, judges are judges not biased helpers. The show in Britain is based purely on cooking skills and not dancing and loads of other rubbish. Its refined and the cooking is a work of art, on the British show.

The Indian one is based on prejudice, bias and politics, it has very little to do with cooking. Its not a cooking show. Its frankly galling to see soap stars come on etc etc. Why is it so tacky?
lilymily thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: everest1

I totally agree with the original comment Aditi did not turn turn things around she was rude to the customers. There was total bias by the judges Lilymily you seemed to be watching a different show. IF you watched without bias and prejudice you would see that the blue team was given help, encouragement and tips from the judges. The red team did gel and worked on their own efforts they were not spoon fed by the judges. It was clear to see that the judges and sided to make sure the red team lost.

The blue team was a larger team just by the fact the judges were there all they way helping them out.

Watch Master Chef from the country it originally came from Britain, judges are judges not biased helpers. The show in Britain is based purely on cooking skills and not dancing and loads of other rubbish. Its refined and the cooking is a work of art, on the British show.

The Indian one is based on prejudice, bias and politics, it has very little to do with cooking. Its not a cooking show. Its frankly galling to see soap stars come on etc etc. Why is it so tacky?


Oh Please...don't give me lecture on whether I am biased or prejudice...what I saw I wrote. I think you are biased because you didn't see what help judges gave to Red team by making Devyani taste the Juhu Pav Bhaji and giving her suggestions on how to improve it.

Again, no need to compare Masterchef India with UK. Every country's masterchef is different n so is their theme. You cannot compare one with another. Just FYI, Masterchef Australia is the most popular Masterchef...no one even cares about Masterchef UK 😎

Edited by lilymily - 12 years ago
everest1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
I'm not sure where you get the fact Masterchef Australia is the most popular...have you got official data on that?

Comparisons will always be made its a fact. In a world of Globalization that happens the show originally started in Britain and comparisons will be made you state that the Australian one is most popular, comparisons had to be made to say it is the most popular.

I stand corrected and apologise I should not have said you were prejudiced I meant the judges were, but very little help was given to the Red team. The judges even told the blue team watch Doyal and and how she attracts customers, that was unfair. The Red team were virtually left on their own in comparison to the blue team. If the judges had left both teams to work on their own the blue team would have been left floundering.

When an original format is taken and reworked comparisons are bound to be made. I'm also not sure how you make the comment 'no one cares about Masterchef UK' how do you know this? Again any data on this. You don't care fair enough but you can't make a sweeping statement for everyone. And whatever you say the fact is the show was developed in Britain and has been copied.

Reading from the other comments on here many feel this show is biased and the judges have been unprofessional. Every country's Masterchef is different only in that the original format has been taken and tweaked such as Masterchef USA and Australia but Star Plus has taken Masterchef India from a Cooking show on skills to a whole new level of garishness.

And apologies once again I did not mean to lecture you as you say😊


hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
The day SP decided to do away with the Food critic, then itself the format started its downward journey. Then the opening episode with the skimpily clad girls 🤢 and Akshay Kumar. Yuck! Double Yuck!

Like someone said, the 2nd season was the best.

This has to be the absolute worst season to date.
DiamondLife thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
they were not counting more than one of same customer was ringing..OR did i miss anything??

I saw Chef Sanjiv's mother walked in..to Dayal and she rang so many time but counted once only

Same thing, Judges did not give points to any team even after ringing the bell..they said theirs dont count
NoComments thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
Oh - multiple bells were counted for the blue team and it was never shown that they had ordered as many number of plates! I will infer only what I see, and to me that was unfair!
Multiple suggestions during food preparation were given to both teams - so again taking away points seemed out of place.. And yes, the judges definitely kept on helping the blue team with a lot of suggestions and hints during the actual execution of the sale.
Aditi - I did see her almost forcing down the Pav bhaji into a customer's mouth at the end, and I found that too aggressive and gross!
Anyway - all of this is beyond history now and the show has lost all the credibility anyway!
This season of MCI is certainly the worst - it has now almost become like a poor adaptation of Apprentice, rather than MasterChef!!
How I miss the interesting contests from season 2 and a much more honest contest!
Edited by NoComments - 12 years ago
akash08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: jyothi-m

</div>
I did not find anything wrong.Blue team did not force customer one person rang the bell for the plates he ordered not so many times.

<div>

Red team was robbed cos judge liked blue teams dish more than red team.


Aditi was not forcing she told them taste give money and ring the bell.



what is taste?? take one bit, do not swallow and ring the bell??

She was like hitting the customers with a stick to ring the bell.

Forget about winning, the whole team should have been disqualified.
akash08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: everest1

I'm also not sure how you make the comment 'no one cares about Masterchef UK' how do you know this? Again any data on this. You don't care fair enough but you can't make a sweeping statement for everyone. And whatever you say the fact is the show was developed in Britain and has been copied.

Reading from the other comments on here many feel this show is biased and the judges have been unprofessional. Every country's Masterchef is different only in that the original format has been taken and tweaked such as Masterchef USA and Australia but Star Plus has taken Masterchef India from a Cooking show on skills to a whole new level of garishness.

And apologies once again I did not mean to lecture you as you say😊





I do care about Masterchef UK and do not miss a single episode !!
BullsEye777 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: akash08



I do care about Masterchef UK and do not miss a single episode !!



Me too😳😆
lizman thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30


On a side note - do we have somewhere here, where we can discuss Apprentice UK, as it starts next week ????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".