A shameful victory for Pandavas

Page

Next Last

fullhouse

@fullhouse

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

I am not against any body, but a warrior like Bheeshm never deserved this...I really wish Vyasa could have given a respectful death to the great warrior

Quote

Frequent Posters

ElMystique

@ElMystique

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: fullhouse
I am not against any body, but a warrior like Bheeshm never deserved this...I really wish Vyasa could have given a respectful death to the great warrior

Are you talking in referance to starbharath or Mahabharath????

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

fullhouse

@fullhouse

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: frappie

Are you talking in referance to starbharath or Mahabharath????

haven't read the original mahabharat...but heard that even in that Bheeshm died like this only.

So my point refers to star Mahabharat

Edited by fullhouse - 11 years ago

Quote

Arijit

@Arijit007

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

VYAS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH STAR BHARAT!!! YOU SHOULD READ THE REAL MAHABHARAT RIGHT NOW!!!

Quote

sanayabarunlove

@sanayabarunlove

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: fullhouse

haven't read the original mahabharat...just heard of it..

So my point refers to star Mahabharat

then you my friend have just seen the most horrible distortion ever in mahabharat history!!

Quote

fullhouse

@fullhouse

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

My point was that I 've heard that in original Mahabharat too Bheeshm died like this only..which I didn't like.. That's why I said Vyasa..

The same was shown in star mahabharat too

Edited by fullhouse - 11 years ago

Quote

ElMystique

@ElMystique

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Honestly I havent watched starbharath since a couple days so I donot know about the events currently ...

And

I would like to say Vyasa has written whatever happened actually

There are two schools of veiws here few who read Mb as a fiction and few who believe that characters existed ..

If you are accusing Vyasa for Bheeshma's death then it is definitely not his mistake according to me because I believe the characters exsisited..

and regarding Bheeshma's death it was the most Glorious death he could ever get.Though Bheeshmacharya wanted Mukunda to slay him and attain moksha😊😊😊

Edited by frappie - 11 years ago

Quote

sanayabarunlove

@sanayabarunlove

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: fullhouse
My point was that I 've heard that in original Mahabharat too Bheeshm died like this only..which I didn't like.. That's why I said Vyasa..

The same was shown in star mahabharat too

Nothing about Kurukshetra is unfair and at the same time it IS unfair too!! In the original Mahabharat Shikhandi comes infront of Bhishma and using the former as a shield, Arjuna sends many arrows the later's way, injuring him. It was Bhishma's punishment for siding the wrong people. It was his punishment for having kept quite when his grandson's wife was almost disrobed infront of an entire sabha! And he couldn't have been defeated until they played that move. If for justice to prevail, a deceit can be helpful, then one might aswell cheat their way in! Believe in God, you automatically follow the right path.

Quote

ElMystique

@ElMystique

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

I mean no offence but

I personally dont think it was a "shameful Victory"

It was not a Victory in first place

they lost their beloved grandsire and secondly They have done their Duty .

Quote

TheWatcher

@TheWatcher

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#10

It was indeed a shameful victory for the Pandavas, it would have been better if Krishna himself would have killed everyone.

How it was a shameful victory? -- They killed Bhishma by treachery, they killed Bhurishrava by treachery, they killed Drona treacherously, they killed Jaydrath treacherously, they killed Karna treacherously, they killed Duryodhana also treacherously.

Do I need to count more?, can I ask where was their 'Samarthya' during the battle, no matter if you are a Pandava fan or of the opposition party, there is no shame in accepting that the Pandavas won with treachery, even though they were righteous.

I am not denying that the Pandavas were righteous, obviously they were righteous

Edited by TheWatcher - 11 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

A shameful victory for Pandavas

Related Topics

Explore Topics